The Three Most Overrated Women of 2011

Categories: Celebs

BadTeacher-012411-0001.jpg
So far.

According to guyism.com.

Based on their sex appeal. (Yes, I try to spotlight the other team once in a while.)


3. Lea Michele

I guess her Tony Awards appearance last year is still not instigating waves of glee.


2. Cameron Diaz

You mean, her reuniting with ex beau Justin Timberlake in Bad Teacher isn't making the world orgiastic again?


And the number-one overrated gal is ...

1. Kate Middleton

I almost fell asleep while trying her name, but somehow rallied.

I have nothing against her, mind you. It's just that she's so overra ... zzzz ...


My Voice Nation Help
28 comments
beau brummell
beau brummell

Ned.:Dont worry because as of August youll see another ROYAL "WEDDING" in Monaco.Never mind the  dream prince is senior but the bride is sexy ,so straights will pretend thatyes,its a marriage as it should be without gays...

Ned Nifty
Ned Nifty

Kate Middleton was important to millions of gay men in 2011 because during that royal wedding it allowed us to fantasize ourselves standing in Kate's place beside Prince William and being being told that Prince Harry would be joining us in the bridal chamber later. Both Prince Williams and Prince Harry are two hot military men that even the hardest straight guy would be hard to resist having some kind of fantasy about -however brief. Let's all thank dear Kate for at least getting both men before the cameras in April of this year.

Wil
Wil

No question, it's Katy Perry, Jennifer Aniston,and Kate Middleton (so boring)

David
David

Thank you for saying Kate Middleton, as in 'middling' beauty.  And Prince William, blah--too geeky like Charles,  Now, Harry, on the other hand---hot!  Definitely inherited Diana's star quality.

Blackwax12
Blackwax12

lady gagaposh spice aka mrs. david beckhamdominique strauss kahn´s maid (our titillating love story for the summer)

jonster
jonster

I agree.  Cameron Diaz needs to change it up a little.  Reminds of Goldie Hawn with that crocodile mouth.  Of course, she's rich and can do anything she wants to do.  Kate Middleton needed a much better "sex" pic released to the public besides the one in a negligee walking down a catwalk.  She looked like a boy.  Lady Di got out of a limo before her wedding in a gown with a plunging neckline and impressive cleavage and stirred up the masses.  Kate just lost weight and got upstaged by her little sister.  I agree about Lea Michele.  Sorry.

Pietro
Pietro

Sarah Palin, Michelle Bachmann &  James Franco

Lost Weekend
Lost Weekend

Curious that you only listed the top 3, when the #4 spot went to Lady Gag.Perhaps it's because some of us are still not convinced she's a woman?

Devore
Devore

Perhaps she's so overexposed that someone wanted to avoid mentioning her for once.

Gregorama
Gregorama

I'd say the one who's far more over-rated, besides Kate is her scary-faced sister, Pippa (a totally unacceptable name for a grown adult).  The press was calling her "Her Royal Hotness".A)  She ain't royal   and B)  SHE AIN'T HOT!!  Good god...are we really this desperate for new media darlings?? 

Barbara Primous Jackson
Barbara Primous Jackson

I agree with Cammy D, and Katie, but I am a gleek so I refuse to listen to your blasphemy.  You could have replaced with Lea Michele with Beyonce and the list would have been perfect.

TimSPC
TimSPC

I wish the Voice's twitter would let me know it's a Musto link before I click on it.

Billy
Billy

Justin Timberlake makes me cringe, no matter what he does. He has this attitude about him that I find irritating. That said, great list, Musto.

Savannah Montgomery
Savannah Montgomery

Back off Justin (jes sayin'...don't make me come over there)...he's the only one of his generation who transitioned smoothly into adulthood...with no "hey look at meeeee" messiness.

mjm
mjm

where's Palin and Bachmann

Lea Michele needs to get over the fact that she's not the second coming of Streisand

Josh Blauvelt
Josh Blauvelt

I agree about Kate - she's pretty but in a girl-next-door way. I read this list yesterday; the writer is quite irritating in a "I'm a snarky 13yo - look at me!" kind of way.

I don't agree with the other ones: Lea Michele is gorgeous - props to my hot jewesses worldwide!; and Cameron Diaz is still gorgeous at... what is she, 49 now?...I'm hella gay but I'd def. consider switching for the night.

MarkyMark
MarkyMark

Cameron Diaz has been overrated since she was a fetus. 

Movielover
Movielover

So true about Kate.  That whole royal worship thing is a huge snooze!  As the Movie Lover, guess who said, "I always did say the English have strange taste."  Probably more than one said it!  I'll tell.  It was when Max De Winter told Edith Van Hopper (in Rebecca) he was going to marry Joan Fontaine.  "Mrs. De Winter?  Ha!  Goodbye my dear and, good luck!"

@JoeWatchesTV
@JoeWatchesTV

I'll give you the Duchess of Cambridge (I knew a guy in Boston who used to call himself the same thing).

But when Lea Michele cries in the "modulated up a third" final chorus of a pop song made famous by other people my heart breaks a little and in repairing itself makes itself just a little stronger each time.

And when Cameron Diaz farts and then quickly flashes her amazingly boyish hips at me I wanna ... I ... oh I got nothin'. Trailer for her movie looks funny, though. I like Phyllis from The Office and Jason Segel.

Segel a little too much. Funny and loves puppets, too. I would totally debase myself for him, 'cause that's what you do to keep a guy, right?

(Ooh, made myself laugh a little right here.)

Jack E. Jett
Jack E. Jett

Katy Perry should be at the top of this list for infinity.  Same with Sister Russell Brand.They are a modenrn day version of small pox.

Whomp
Whomp

From the photo, it looks like Justin is one of the three most overrated women.

©2013 Village Voice, LLC, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places New York

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city