Welcome to blogs.villagevoice.com
Blogs
  • News
    • » Daily News
    • » Runnin' Scared - News Blog
    • » Tom Robbins
    • » Wayne Barrett
  • Music
    • » Top Picks
    • » Find a Bar or Club
    • » Pazz & Jop
    • » Down in Front
    • » Sound of the City
    • » Siren
    • » Submit an Event
    • » Jukebox
    • » Join Music Newsletter
    • » Entertainment Ads
  • Calendar
    • » Calendar Home
    • » Top Picks
    • Valentine's Day Events
    • » Comedy Events
    • » Fitness Health & Beauty Guide
    • » Submit an Event
    • » Entertainment Ads
  • Restaurants
    • » Restaurant Guide
    • » Restaurant Reviews
    • » Sietsema's Counter Culture
    • » Find a Bar or Club
    • » Fork in the Road (column)
    • » Fork in the Road (blog)
    • » Sponsored Online Menus
    • » Choice Eats Tasting Event
    • » Join Dining Newsletter
    • » Restaurant Ads
  •  
  • Arts
    • » Calendar
    • » Books
    • » Theater
    • » Art
    • » Dance
    • » Obies Theater Awards
  • Films
    • » Now Showing
    • » Movie Showtimes
    • » Reviews
    • » Join NY Film Club
    • » Movie Ads
  • The Ads
    • Ad Index
    • Flip Book
    • Media Kit
  • Classifieds
    • Personals
    • Sexy Black Book
    • Free Online Classifieds
    • Place an Ad (print)
    • Career Fair
    • Real Estate for Sale/Trulia
    • Personals Blogs
    • Real Estate For Rent
  • Blogs
    • » Runnin' Scared
    • » Sound of the City
    • » La Daily Musto
    • » Fork in the Road (blog)
    • » All City
  • Columns
    • » La Dolce Musto
    • » Tom Robbins
    • » Sex
    • » Horoscope
  • Best Of
    • » Arts & Entertainment
    • » Bars & Clubs
    • » Food & Drink
    • » People & Places
    • » Shopping & Services
    • » Sports & Recreation
    • » Best of Ads
  • Bars/Clubs
    • » Bars/Clubs Home
    • » Bars/Club Ads
  • Archives
  • Reader Recommendations
  • Promotions
    • Street Team
    • Join The Street Team
    • Contests & Promotions
    • Text Alerts
    • Buy Village Voice Merchandise
    • Supplements Archive
  • Site Map

Top

blog

Stories

  • celebs

    Celebrities on the Down Low

    By Michael Musto

    1
  • celebs

    Howard Stern on "American Idol"?

    By Michael Musto

    2
  • film

    Dear John: Worst Movie Ever Made?

    By Michael Musto

    3
  • TV

    Diane Sawyer Fucked Me Over

    By Michael Musto

    4
  • Goldie Hawn

    Goldie Hawn Turned Down a Flaccid...

    By Michael Musto

    5
  • Oscars

    Oscar Nominations!

    By Michael Musto

    6
  • Musto on Musto

    I'm in the New York Times!

    By Michael Musto

    7
  • quick Q&A

    Inside The Downtown Celebrity Kno...

    By Michael Musto

    8
  • Obama

    Obama's Speech Rocked

    By Michael Musto

    9
  • ???

    Does Howard Stern Wear a Wig?

    By Michael Musto

    10
  • Featured

    Who Fared Best on the "Hope For H...

    By Michael Musto

    11
  • Andy Dick

    Andy Dick Charged with Gay Sexual...

    By Michael Musto

    12
  • celebs

    Who Should Star in the Spice Girl...

    By Michael Musto

    13
  • Featured

    Gay Gladiators Attack New York!

    By Michael Musto

    14
  • celebs

    The Hottest Blind Item of Them Al...

    By Michael Musto

    15
 
Featured

Matt Tratner, Victim of Gotham Horror Story, Speaks Out

By Michael Musto, Wednesday, Apr. 22 2009 @ 6:24PM
Comments (90)
Categories: Musto on Musto, scandal

mustoadvice.jpg
I recently ran a post about gay party promoter/teacher Matt Tratner, who told folks that while he was away, he found out that the friend he'd entrusted his apartment to went unhinged and destroyed and burned pretty much everything there. The story escalated to a suicide attempt, Swat teams, chaining to a bed, and other things out of a real-life CSI episode, all told with breathless by horror in a message from Matt that I'd been forwarded.

A few of you expressed sympathy to Matt and his destructive/self-destructive friend, while the great majority of cynics dissected the story and found it wanting, also wondering why it hasn't popped up in other media.

Well, here's an email I just got from Matt himself.

    "Michael,

    We have met many many times... You have attended many of my events, lounges and clubs. I have no problem with you writing something about me. But I would hope that you would at least contact me for facts.

    1) I never emailed you or ANYONE about my situation. While staying with a kind friend who took me in I posted a note on my Facebook. If someone sent you my posting, I can assure you and I am SURE from the email you can see it was NOT ME.

    2) To your cynical readers... I have countless photos of the apartment, as does the 107th Precinct in Queens and Internal Affairs (Since they wanted to follow up that no unnecessary force or abuse came to a mentally ill man.) Also the apt building managers office has photos. In addition One Police Plaza also has records of the situation.

    3) At no time have I personally asked anyone for money or handouts. My friends who are ever loving and kind have done everything on their own trying to help me get my life back together.

    4) I would have no problem meeting with you to give you all the evidence needed - As you can imagine I am already very upset by my loss and it is very hurtful to think that people are drawing conclusions without all the facts.

    Here is your opportunity to contact me - I am sure I will see you at many of the same events and venues as always and look forward to seeing you again soon.

    Ever grateful,

    Matt Tratner"

Well, I called and emailed Matt back and told him I would promptly post the above missive to clear things up. So shut up, you jaundiced bitches.

UPDATE:

PS: Here are the photos that Matt has sent me. He wrote, "Notice the Swat van in the background! You can also see the EMS van on the LAWN in front of the Apt and a stretcher...If you look at the window lit up on the second floor..You can see my "Friend" in the window as described when he was cutting himself. The photos are from my neighbor...you now have her email.. SHE CAN CONFIRM THE EVENTS!!!!"

Matt Tranter1.jpg

Matt Tranter2.jpg

Matt Tranter3.jpg

Matt Tranter4.jpg

Comments (90) Write Comment
Share

Related Content

  • A Whole New Gotham Horror Story April 20, 2009
  • Grisly Evidence from Matt Tratner, Party Promoter in Gotham Horror Story April 24, 2009

More About:

  • Matt Tratner

Comments (90)

Yikes says:

Ugh ... Why do I feel so gross and violated? I feel like Michael Musto just sexted me after reading these two sordid posts.

Posted On: Wednesday, Apr. 22 2009 @ 6:33PM
Jonster says:

Michael, you told him you would post his missive to "clear things up?" You're being facetious aren't ya. I've got a cheap little $85 printer that scans pictures into my computer. It takes seconds. I think the friend who posted that a "version" of Matt's story might have happened is probably right. Go ahead and meet him for coffee, take a look at the gruesome evidence. Keep the story going. I kinda wanna know.

Posted On: Wednesday, Apr. 22 2009 @ 7:45PM
An LDM Heavy Hitter says:


Not to beat a mentally ill horse, but:

-obviously,the person who wrote the above email was NOT the "Matt" who posted all those other panicked comments.

-If what he's saying is true, then all it means is that he's only telling this story on Facebook...the fact that he's trying to collect money behind it has been well documented.

-Internal Affairs has launched an investigation based on possible mistreatment of an EDP and there remains NO MENTION of this event ANYWHERE other than here.

-Neither MT nor any witness can or will produce ONE photo of the incident and ensuing damage.

As much as this all makes me feel like Angela Lansbury, I am tired of addressing this odious issue, so this is the last you'll hear from me on the subject.

Posted On: Wednesday, Apr. 22 2009 @ 7:45PM
Humbled says:

Well THAT certainly clears everything up! Maybe I will go ahead and buy him those two ipods he needs to help get him get back on his feet.

Posted On: Wednesday, Apr. 22 2009 @ 7:45PM
Tim says:

I cannot fathom how anyone who is out in the pulic eye, built up a reputation as a charity fundraiser(I have his AIDS walk fundraiser reminders on my facebook profile) and relies on a friendly relationship with thousands of people he sees everyday would ever possibly consider and then believe he could realistically get away with scamming them, especially if he is not going anywhere and remains on the scene here in NYC.

Posted On: Wednesday, Apr. 22 2009 @ 8:05PM
Joseph Miceli says:

Again Matt Tratner does not NEED to prove anything to anyone of you on this blog.. We as his friends will gladly take care of his needs and help him out. I would appreciate all you people who have nothing to do with this mind your own buisness.

Posted On: Wednesday, Apr. 22 2009 @ 8:28PM
Musto says:

I will add photos he sent me as soon as possible.

Posted On: Wednesday, Apr. 22 2009 @ 10:00PM
BS Detector says:

Well, it's a good thing Matt doesn't NEED to prove anything to any of us, because he certainly hasn't. The more he and all his friends and "witnesses" post-- each one unwilling and unable to provide a hint of corroborating evidence-- the more obvious becomes the lie.

Scam, scam, scam.

Posted On: Wednesday, Apr. 22 2009 @ 10:30PM
La Grand Puta says:

Our Musto was simply doing the job he does best: giving us, his jaded public, a good story.
As for all this baloohey from jaded readers-honeys, we've all seen the Law & Order marathons. We know that some of these things can't be labeled black or white until Sam Waterson gets the 'guilty' verdict. Chill out until we get a better picture.
Emails not from the victim, unreported trashing of apartments, it's all so intriguing, of course now we need more. And La Musto needs the credit for introducing this story to the rest of the world......

Posted On: Wednesday, Apr. 22 2009 @ 10:37PM
YAY! says:

We all can't wait to see the pictures!!! From the note he posted on Facebook it seems all these pictures will be reminiscent of the more horrific disasters in our lifetime!

Posted On: Wednesday, Apr. 22 2009 @ 10:47PM
DEMONA SATANACAS says:

The photos will surely be sensational indeed. And when I see the documentation of this momentous even somewhere other than on this blog, maybe I'll believe this bullshit but until then I'm just sitting back with a bucket of popcorn and taking in the show

Posted On: Wednesday, Apr. 22 2009 @ 11:33PM
ImageSurfing says:


I went to google and entered "wrecked apartment" and got hundred of images. Can I submit them as "evidence" of how MY life was ruined by a suicidal friend and three bands of SWAT teams?

I get the impression I will soon be seeing some of those same images again shortly.

Posted On: Wednesday, Apr. 22 2009 @ 11:54PM
yourmama@villagevoice.com says:

Attention newspapers! Want to prove your need to exist? Break this story wide open. VOICE editors: a reporter could get to the bottom of this in a half hour. Don't just print cryptic pleas & denials: get to work!

Posted On: Wednesday, Apr. 22 2009 @ 11:57PM
vince says:

Matt, we met a few times briefly maybe 2 years or so ago....I have NO idea what all this bullshit is about, but if u r having a rough go lately and need a hand, shout back 2 me. i remember u being a real sweetheart, and hope to hear from u now, or whenever in the future....vince. im sure u dont remember me, but ill remind u if need be

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 4:34AM
memo says:

Matt's neighbor sent pics taken from her phone please go to www.trinityangelnyc.com and see the there

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 6:11AM
Wondering says:

Just went to the link---nothing.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 6:50AM
kelli says:

I think the place is a mess because Susan Boyle lost her virginity with Pope Benedict there.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 7:10AM
FInally, some pictures says:

Finally, some pictures, albeit dark and not revealing much but some police cars.

http://www.trinityangelnyc.com/Trinity_Angel_NYC/Matt_Tratners_FRIEND-raiser.html

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 7:36AM
Pictures? says:

Those 4 pictures are a complete embarrassment to this whole story. Where are all the people? And I'm assuming the 100 police men and 3 Swat teams are inside? If so, where are all the tenants?

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 8:08AM
Anonymous Concerned Bullsh*t Detector says:

Ho-hum. Wow. One Police Plaza. It ~must~ be true. In fact, I think Bloomberg has cancelled several meetings at city hall, just to investigate this one disaster personally. He might even be down there helping muck out the stalls. Because this is a load of horse sh*t. Again.

At any rate, it's been amusing.

Please don't forget to click the "Donate" button as you exit the arena.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 8:16AM
Laugh @ Matt says:

Haha, I saw the photos!

So, you're telling me the apartment was so damaged that he can't even live there anymore. Then you tell me Mr. DeSoto showed you pictures of this ruined apartment. But you don't show those photos, oh no, you put up some shots of some...police cars. With no one around them. Not really the best choice. Neither was making up this whole scam in the first place.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 8:25AM
latenitebump says:

she, probably, owes her dealer!

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 9:02AM
wendell says:

I looked at the pictures in the above post and you can't see much of anything. Just a few police cars. Matt, this is getting even creepier.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 9:52AM
OliverInQueens says:

OMG!!! ARE YOU FRIGGIN SERIOUS!@#! WHERE IS THE NEIGHBOR IN THE WINDOW? AND WHERE ARE THE CROWDS OF PEOPLE LOOKING UP IN HORROR!!! OH THE HORROR!

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 10:09AM
Queens Resident says:

While it's neat to see dark photos of parked police vehicles in a completely obscured setting, far more useful bits of information would be the address of the building, and the date on which this horrific "tragedy" took place.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 10:18AM
Ed Rahn says:

What a joke! For those of you with Photoshop, take the pics and crank up the levels on the pics and you'll count a total of eight people in all the photos - COMBINED!

If you look at the pic with all the police cars parked on the street there's not a single person ANYWHERE. We've all been to "scenes" with lots of police and cars and the police are always standing around everywhere.

Everyone ask yourselves, if this thing had happened to you and people were calling you a liar, wouldn't YOU bury people with documentary evidence (pictures, lead detective's name, address, etc.) to prove you're telling the truth? Yes, you would.

Matt has done none of that. The best he can come up with is four dark pics of police cars.

yawn

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 10:23AM
Visiting poster says:

Regarding Kelli's comment and I hope you are reading this whomever you are. You disgust me. Your so-called 'joke' about Susan Boyle is really scraping the barrell. So you think the story is a scam and make your opinion on it. Fine. However you deem fit to poke fun at that story by mocking a lovely lady who I happen to know as a neighbour (yes, shock, someone from Scotland is reading this.) I may not like the man who represents my religion right now but your sordid joke about lovely Susan and the Pope is a totally despicable way to 'have a go' at the main story.

Disgusting, pathetic and nasty - now that is YOUR story. Congratulations.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 10:37AM
ChinoGArtist says:

Picture #1 - 8 people?
Picture #2 - 0 people
Picture #3 - 0 people
Picture #4 - 5 people

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 10:43AM
Tim says:

Still don't understand why Matt would be scamming anyone if he isn't taking money from the unbelievers and is staying put. Has he taken anything from anyone against their will? He's here in NYC and apparently available and not running from anyone. He's going to a regularly scheduled event tonight, not a fundraiser for his sake. Does anyone know if this is the pathology of a criminal? What motive would he possibly have to do all this anyway?

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 11:55AM
bed bath and befriender says:

matt is super "nice", but seems like a real fake bitch if you ask me. he's a nightlife promoter, aka, he couldn't show up on time at his first PR internship..

re: facebook... if he posts one more inspirational maya angelou quote, or derives solace from some old yiddish mantra which he then goes on to educate everyone about, i'm gonna fucking puke.

this guy goes around telling everyone how rich and glamorous he is, including the billionaire status of his parents, and which glamorous mansions he vacations in, yet he doesn't have homeowners or renters insurance? I'm a poor m-f-er, but I've got coverage for $300 a year just in case some whack job queens out on my shit....

i love how they have removed the "registered at bed bath and beyond" button from that sheisty trinity angel Web site.

matt trattner is sally struthers and bernie madoff rolled into one. and with his crack team of photoshoppers and defensive "eye-wittnesses"..... gosh, hold on, i just got a call... omg, my closet just got sprayed with homeless person vomit, i;m so sad... buy me stuff...

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 11:55AM
Obviously says:

And last time I checked anyone with rich parents wouldn't be living in the depths of Queens

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 12:08PM
Shivah says:

FACEBOOK: Matt Tratner; Shivah- Comes from the Hebrew word Shiv, meaning the number 7. Jews have 7 days to mourn all losses and then are no longer permitted to mourn. Today is the 8th day. Its time to start living again. I would be very, very honored if all my friends would join me tonight at ASPEN to celebrate life going on, to laugh, smile and finally have some fun.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 12:09PM
Dismayed in Manhattan says:

Tim writes: "Has he taken anything from anyone against their will?"

So, it's come to this. "The con man didn't con anyone except his victims. What's the big deal?"

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 12:35PM
Anonymous says:

where are the photos of the apartment?

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 12:43PM
Sissy Scammer says:

I've been going over this a lot, trying to figure it out.

I keep coming back to one thing: the date! No one has ever said the date this happened on. We could really check this out, if only we had the date. It's a really simple piece of information, so why won't Matt or any of his supporters tell us the date this happened on? That would really clear things up.

Then I thought wait a minute--April. Did this happen maybe on April 1? Is this a prank that got out of hand? Matt, if you're reading this and I'm right and this is an April Fool prank that's gotten way out of hand, now's the time to come clean. Then we can all just walk away with our dignity.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 1:02PM
ThedATe says:

I think it happened around April 16th?

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 1:23PM
Tim says:

I haven't made my mind up about this but absolutely won't leap to a mean sprited conclusion. Most of the people who know him seem to like him. Are they all bad people? Do they have poor judgment? I still don't understand how exactly he is a con man, what did he do to you and why take offense to this so personally? If you don't believe him then stop reading anything to do with this story, let him live in ignominy and move on with your life. What goes around comes around, including the spreading of ill will; even if you are correct in your appraisal, this nastiness serves no one in the long run. Please explain why he is doing all this and not just offer up some unpleasant speculative characterization or another question. The harsher the criticisms, the more it seems the disbelievers are sorry people with poor social skills/few friends. He is a well known personality in the city and has no accountable reason to go to the lengths some describe as a con job for anything, particularly at this point in his career/life. Why chuck what he has now and begin this lie? Is he a known liar? Does he make a lot of enemies? Does he cheat people in business? Does he lack integrity? Is he irresponsible? Does he have bad credit? Does he have a criminal record? Has he done this before? What could he realistically gain from pulling a con in front of thousands of people he knows and has to answer to everyday? It would be one thing if he was a hit and run artist or involved in a grift, but this guy is a fixture. If it is a con, he certainly isn't going to get away with much since so many people who don't have anything to do with him are desperate to take him down.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 1:34PM
random_guest says:

I'm just reading all this nonsence - LOL. Dear Tim, why are YOU here? You seem to be in all sorts of a tissy.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 2:11PM
Tim says:

@random_guest,
I know him only from Facebook but don't want to throw shade on someone with a rep for charity work and a record of working for civil rights, other people I do know from Manhattan nightlife and the neighborhood I live in who know him and support him are pleasant respectable people and I would never just assume they are accomplices in a scam by association as has been inferred. I don't understand why so many are in such a rush to condemn.
I think the word you mis-spelled is tizzy. I never heard of a tissy.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 2:31PM
Matt Tratner says:

I invite all of you who are in question to meet me tonight Thursday, April 23rd in person... 10pm at 30 west 22nd street bet 5th and 6th ave. I will be there to answer all your questions. HERE I AM WORLD... I openly invite you all to meet me and if you need to see photos talk to witnesses. Now I have given you all your opportunity. I openly welcome you all.

Yours truly,

Matt Tratner

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 2:46PM
Tina Problems says:

Oh, so it was all a gimmick to promote your party tonight?!

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 2:54PM
Rahm Heimstein says:

Matt: What day did it happen? What is the address?

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 2:56PM
GotoASPEN says:

Isn't Matt a Club Promoter and involved in Charity organizations? May be this a PR stunt to raise money for a Charity. Let's all go to ASPEN tonight. Maybe he will be handing over the money and items from his registery list to a good cause. Let's all hope. Afterall,today is the 8th day after Shiva. Let's celebrate a good cause.
Bravo Matt Bravo!!

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 2:57PM
Justsayin says:

You bitches are so cunty and jaded that I can't help but return to read the ridiculous comments you post. I don't even know Matt and have no reason to support him, but all I can say is GET A LIFE! You people are PATHETIC and half of you need to go back to 3rd grade with your AWFUL grammar.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 3:08PM
Dick Seer says:

Matt: Can't make it to your party, sorry. But I really have only two questions:

What day did it happen?

What is the address?

Anything you say is bullshit until you answer this.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 3:16PM
lld says:

Is there nobody sympathetic in the world anymore? Grow up, people, and leave the man alone if you don't like or believe the story!

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 4:03PM
dll says:

lld: A crime may have been committed. That's no small thing. It's nothing to ignore.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 4:07PM
Obviously says:

Its very easy LLD, we will be sympathetic AND compassionate AND generous once we see ONE SHRED OF concrete evidence this actually happened. But so far there has been NOTHING.

There are far better ways to be charitable in New York City than giving it to a cause that has absolutely no merit.

Show us one iota of evidence, a photo, or a copy of the police report, and the donations will start pouring in.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 4:12PM
Enough, already! says:


Fraud: Lying to someone in an effort to obtain money.

Wire Fraud: Using a phone line to lie to someone in an effort to obtain money.

Federal Wire Fraud: Lying to someone in an effort to get money over a phone line that crosses State boundaries.

When an outrageous lie is tied to an attempt to convince people to give you money, you've committed a crime.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 4:12PM
Digging a deeper hole says:


Police vehicles at the nighttime scene of an incident HAVE THEIR FUCKING LIGHTS TURNED ON!

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 4:21PM
GoshHookey says:

Digging deeper has totally hit the nail on the head! I've never seen so many police cars with no one around in my entire life - let alone, no blinking or flashing lights. Wow!

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 4:29PM
ThoseGoingTonite says:

I encourage all those going to tonite to get full documentation of photos. NO FRICKEN BLACKED OUT WASHED OUT PHOTOS EITHER!

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 4:32PM
hmmmmmmmmmm says:

i guess those deemed mentally ill is another way of saying he uses meth... or possibly he was an ex of matt's and wanted to really piss him off?

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 4:39PM
"It's not a lie if YOU believe it" says:

You would have been better off sticking to your dubious position of refusing to provide ANY evidence to back up your story.

No one would give a fuck if your weren't trying to relieve well-meaning people of their hard-earned money.

These four photographs back up your false claim that this building was evacuated from 11pm-3am?

I guess we're all waiting for you to admit that you're a soulless liar with a low IQ, but I don't suppose that's likely to happen.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 4:46PM
Anonymous says:

http://static.panoramio.com/photos/original/5221073.jpg

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 4:46PM
Anonymous says:

I'm expecting the pictures he shows us to look like this. Atleast this is the image i got after reading his note.

http://www.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~wirusk/graphics/tornado/tor_38.jpg

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 4:51PM
Obviously says:

I would expect the interior to look like this:
http://www.dvdbeaver.com/film2/DVDReviews33/a%20teh%20shining%20two%20disc/the%20shining%20PDVD_004.jpg

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 5:05PM
Jack says:

Out of curiosity, I enhanced photo number 4 in Photoshop and you can see 4-5 cops looking up the window where a figure of a guy is standing. An ambulance or a police van.

Here's the enhanced photo:
[IMG]http://i39.tinypic.com/1sfx3k.jpg[/IMG]

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 5:14PM
Come ON, already says:

For Michael Musto -- Why have you not asked some scrappy young (or tired old) reporter to look into this? Or even an intern? As someone said in an earlier post, this could be cleared up in a half an hour if you did that. Of course, I guess your blog would lose some traffic as a result. And Matty T. might be mad at you and not invite you to any more of his super-hot parties.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 5:26PM
Jack says:

Here's another enhanced photo.

http://i44.tinypic.com/2mplm47.jpg

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 5:29PM
ThanksJack! says:

Wow - 4 to 5 people? Where are the other 100?

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 5:41PM
Obviously says:

100 police would mean 50 NYPD cars. Cops only ride two to a car. That is a set-in-stone police procedure.

3 SWAT teams would mean at least an additional 24 people.

An entire evacuated building would be dozens of residents. ANGRY residents that would report this kind of story immediately to their lawyers, friends, and media outlets.

There would be AT LEAST one news reporting van at the location. I hate to be Hollywood-esque but think about the movie SCREAM and the character Courtney Cox played. In out media savy era, this WOULD get some news coverage.

Why is this charade even being allowed to continue. This whole thing is a complete scam, an overblown lie, and innocent people have donated money to a cause that has absolutely NO VALIDITY.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 5:57PM
Edward Morrow says:

Remember when the Village Voice had reporters!? Come on, get to the bottom of this, or else you're just a bitchy news commentary site written by its users.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 6:52PM
hmmmm says:

here's what i think - the two photos of the police vehicles were taken at the police precinct. they have a "different" color to them. the other 2 were taken at the "alleged" incident site. fakery. just post some carnage pictures and we will gladly help you out!!!

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 7:23PM
Jonster says:

Oh Michael, you always get mixed up with these wacky party promoters. And they seem to share an infatuation with blood and death.

What's compelling about this story is you can see slivers of the "real" story hiding in the details and you wonder what it is. He is obviously distraught, even for a drama queen prone to exaggeration.

And now a party is about to be staged where the evidence and friends of Matt can be viewed and questioned. What's the cover charge? Are you going Michael?

I'm sure had no idea this item would turn into such a pandora's box.

(PS - Pls give an update on the Mart Crowley BITB thing!!!)

Who was it said: Any Publicity is Good Publicity? This proves it.

Posted On: Thursday, Apr. 23 2009 @ 8:10PM
4thdecade says:

@ Tim Wednesday Apr.22, 2009 8:05pm

One word for you - Madoff!

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 12:24AM
4thdecade says:

...except Madoff at least promised to return your money!

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 12:54AM
JesusHChrist says:

Michael, why don't you do a little journalism rather than reporting this as a gossip story? Call the precinct, confirm the facts, and tell the haters who live on your blog that they are wrong.

I also know Matt and it is beyond me how anyone could be so cynical about someone who gives so much of himself to help the community around him. And it's beyond me how you can continue to let people post stuff on here that comes close to libel. It's easy for you to confirm the facts. You're basically letting a defamation case play out on your blog.

What he's going through is not the stuff of gossip pages. It's the stuff of real human pain and suffering.

And as for the publicity your readers think Matt seeks, it's quite simple. Matt has been hosting parties in New York for years and is very well networked in the gay community. Like many of us who are, we find it easiest to share news with large groups of our friends on Facebook. The note he posted was so horrible that many of us started sharing it with one another wondering if there was anything we could do. Obviously someone sent it to you, and it's been a tempest in a teapot ever since.

To anyone who thinks Matt used this to promote his own party, consider this. Tonight was his usual Thursday night party. It was in support of the AIDS Walk. If you donated to support the AIDS Walk, you not only got in free, you had an open bar. In other words, tonight was not a money making night for Matt.

And you were there Michael, so you could report that fact.

As for the people commenting on here who think they are part of Law & Order, dissecting the facts of the case, get a life. If you want to investigate, Matt has told you which police precinct to contact. You don't have to guess how many SWAT Teams can dance on the head of a pin. You can just call and ask.

Of course if you did anything so simple the story would be finished and you'd have to get on with your pathetic blog-commenting lives, and face the fact that your'e still single and probably always will be.

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 2:48AM
pampam says:

Yeah, Michael, can't you just call the precinct?

Oh, wait, Matt never said where this happened so how can you know which fucking precinct to call?????

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 3:19AM
bitzi says:

A lot of people raise money for AIDS and all sorts of charities. Does that automatically preclude them from being con artists, wackos, psychos, etc?

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 3:21AM
latenitebump says:

cindy mccain was stealing money from her own charity she founded to support her drug habit!
and she has millions of her own!!!!!!!!!

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 8:03AM
Ed Rahn says:

Memo to latenitebump: You're a liar - either stick to the topic or something you know about like women's undergarments.

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 9:11AM
Just tell us where, when says:

We don't have to wait for Michael Musto or the Village Voice to do their job--_I_ will call to police to confirm Matt's lie, er, I mean his horrific experience.

First I'll need a little concrete information, of course, but it should be the most simple thing in the world for Matt to provide:

The date and time of the incident

The address of the incident

What's that? You say he's never revealed those? How very suspicious!

I agree with the commenter on the other posting who said it looks like Matt had a harebrained scheme to get money from friends & family, and that things have spiraled out of control.

Date and place, Matt, date and place. Why won't you tell us?

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 9:29AM
Jonster says:

You can call the precinct. I did. They won't give you any information. It's against rules. There is no notice of this event occuring on the 107th police blotter. I called the Queens Courier and spoke to a reporter who did not hear one word of this catastrophic event ("and I would have," he said) and suggested it happened "between Matt's ears." Nor was it reported in any other venue. Who's more cynical? People who question a unverifiable sob story designed to raise money ahead of a fundraiser? Or someone who preys on the goodwill of his friends and acquaintances and those of us here who might be sympathetic to this guy's plight?

Michael you were there. What's the scoop?

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 9:58AM
Believer says:

I'm a believer! Just show us some simple pics. I sure would have put pics along with my story if it was that dramatic!

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 10:33AM
Marcus says:

See how fast an incident like this makes the news....

http://www.nypost.com/seven/04242009/news/regionalnews/bronx_teacher_barricades_himself_inside__166013.htm

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 10:34AM
Interesting Story! says:

Per Matt's story, his friend barracaded himself inside and tried to start the building on fire... in today's world - that would be called an "arsonist" or even a "terrorist" but still no news...

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 10:50AM
Spiral says:

It's seems to be traveling all over the internet!

http://twitter.com/JustinRZB/status/1588396688

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 11:32AM
Rotissa Rechiken says:

A mention on Twitter?! Wow, this story is really taking off.

Seriously, though, it's NOT taking off. I can't believe all the blogs haven't picked it up. Hype this up, people, or it's just going to die here in the comments section of Musto's blog, and we'll never find out what happened!

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 11:47AM
Amused in NYC says:

To all those who are defending Matt, I think you're missing the point.

Matt posted that letter word by word on his facebook page, as a status update. Matt has more than 2,500 friends on his Facebook page. Do you agree with me that it wasn't a personal letter sent to his close friends? Clearly he was trying to get attention for it, right?
OK, we're all on the same page.

Let's continue: go back to the original letter and READ IT. It is R-I-D-C-U-L-O-U-S. Clearly it is over-the-top, melodramatic, exaggerated, and least partially deceitful. I'm sorry, but when someone exaggerates to that extent, he is lying.
The photos he showed prove absolutely nothing. They only made it worse.

So it's not a crime to lie, right?
But the guy claims that his friends created a fundraiser for himself, conveniently created on his own "charity" webpage (www.trinityangelnyc.com) and linked to a Bed Bath & Beyond registry. Who are we kidding here? Do we have to be police detective to know that he himself created that page?

I think it really boils down to whether anyone actually donated anything to him. And if so, those people should come forward and complain. If no one gave him money, then his pathetic attempt to scam did not work and all he got was a huge stain on his reputation. Who in their right mind would ever take this Matt guy seriously from now one. I know one thing, I will not attend any of his events, I'm too grossed out.

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 2:59PM
Marcus says:

Just to let you know AMUSED IN NYC....

90% of the Bed Bath and Beyond rider has been filled...

There is a second one at Target for him where the purchases are starting to come in...

Last night he had a "fundraiser" at his circuit night at Aspen, saying it was for the AIDSWALK

He has a place where you can do PayPal donations (all major credit cards accepted)

There is also another benefit scheduled by his former partner Josh Wood at 1Oak, in an email that I just received saying "they would be passing the coffee can around".

Not to mention daily pleas still on his Facebook page. And dozens and dozens of people still offering words of sympathy and the notion to "help in anyway they possibly can"

IT NEEDS TO STOP. NOW

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 3:09PM
Amused in NYC says:

I find it interesting that the "tru"e people who are coming out to defend Matt are doing it on this blog and not contacting the Village Voice.
Come on, would Pastor Heidi Neumark really log on to this blog to say what she supposedly said?
(By the way, if anyone wants to contact her to verify whther she actually logged on to this blog and wrote what she wrote, her email is hneumark@gmail.com, her church office phone is 212-222-7045 and cell phone is 917-374-4212 - this is all from the webpage of the church)

Same thing goes for the "neighbor" that comments on this blog and says that indeed 100 cops showed up and she indeed saved Matt's dog. Give me a break. If she was truly the neighbor she would contact the Village Voice to come and interview her and take photos.

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 3:13PM
Repulsed and bored says:


How can you insult our intelligence by presenting those photos as documentation of what is alleged to have taken place?

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 3:18PM
Wake up, Voice! says:

If the Village Voice were still worth a goddamn, they'd be the one doing the calling. It was fun to watch Musto be disingenuous about this obvious fraud for a couple days, but now the Voice's failure to debunk Matt's story--or even to try to verify it--is starting to stink. Especially while dude's still soliciting for $ and iPods.

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 3:19PM
Amused in NYC says:

Wow Marcus, that's insane

Although just for all the laughing I have done since this began, I'd be willing to give $5
:)
But not to Matt, instead i'd give it to everyone who's been commenting here. We can divide the $5 evenly between everyone. Including Lucky, Matt's dog, lol.

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 3:28PM
web god says:

Check the above post, "Grisly Evidence.." for the NEW pictures just posted of the kitchen and bathroom.

Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 3:28PM
Anonymous says:

Just added to the TrinityAngelNYC.com page:

SAVE THE DATE


We will be collecting a $20 Donation at the Upstairs Lounge at Vlada to help raise funds for our friend. Enjoy delicious hor' devours sponsored by Vlada... Free Cocktails sponsored by Absolute Mango... and the sounds of NYC's hottest DJ Cori Spano!

VLADA
331 West 51st Street
Between 8th and 9th Ave
www.vladabar.com
SAVE THE DATE

I love how Matt spelled "hors d'oeuvres" and how he keeps referring to himself as "our friend Matt" - he's using all of this to his benefit.
and I'm pretty sure that even if he gets convicted for Fraud, there will be plenty of people who will be happy to go to his parties to catch a glimpse of the famous Matt. There are enough dumb people to go around :)


Posted On: Friday, Apr. 24 2009 @ 3:34PM
FAKERY says:

pretty good set - but not that well done...

http://blogs.villagevoice.com/dailymusto/archives/2009/04/grisly_evidence.php

Posted On: Monday, Apr. 27 2009 @ 11:01AM
Damage Control says:

Aparrently "memo" above is Matt... From a post on the 21st here: "And the email goes to "memorandum@mac.com" although the link on the bottom of the page mails to "memorandum@ME.com" - must be another typo."

His lack of imagination is consistent.

Posted On: Wednesday, Apr. 29 2009 @ 5:35PM
Anonymous says:

Well this would ALL be so much more heartwarming were it not for the fact that MR. Tratner is on an extended vacation, first in Greece then traveling for most of the summer. I guess the nearly $15,ooo from the fundraiser will help "offset" some of the expenses of being on the road. Nothing like a European Vacation to make the world right again!

Posted On: Tuesday, Jun. 30 2009 @ 3:27PM

Write Comment


Comments may not show up immediately after submission. Please wait a minute after posting a comment for it to appear.

All reader comments are subject to our Terms of Use. By clicking "Post," you acknowledge that you have reviewed and agree to these Terms.

Tools

Search La Daily Musto


Follow

Email tips to tips@villagevoice.com

SlideShows»

  • Bikini Burlesque (NSFW)
  • Brooklyn Taco Experiment
  • Idiotarod 2010
  • More Slideshows >>

Most …

  • Surreal Moments From My Life, Part 9000
  • Governor David Paterson's Sex Rumors Prompt Many Questions
  • A Flash Forward to the Palin Presidency
  • Black Celebrities on the Down Low
  • Michael Jackson's Doctor Charged With Involuntary Manslaughter! Joe Jackson Upset!
  • More Recent Entries...
  • Michael Jackson's Kids Come Out From Under His Shadow (40)
  • Would You Want To Be Madonna Right Now? (28)
  • New Candidate For Worst Movie Ever Made: Dear John (24)
  • Who Will Play Blanche Dubois? (21)
  • Black Celebrities on the Down Low (18)
  • Actor Ben Whishaw is Straight in One Magazine, Gay in Another
  • Goldie Hawn Turned Down a Flaccid Penis
  • New Candidate For Worst Movie Ever Made: Dear John
  • Diane Sawyer Fucked Me Over Twice Yesterday
  • Taylor Swift Isn't That Off-Key!

Calendar

  • Tue
    9
  • Wed
    10
  • Thu
    11
  • Fri
    12
  • Sat
    13
  • Sun
    14
  • Mon
    15
This week's best events
3 Best Things To Do on Tuesday, Feb 9
  • 20/10 Vision

    Where: Gallery Hanahou

    Type: Art

  • Fêtes de la Nuit

    Where: Ohio Theater

    Type: Off-Off-Broadway: Opening, Theater, Valentine's Day

  • The Residents

    Where: Webster Hall

    Type: Experimental

  • submit an event
  • 340 more things to do today >>

La Daily Musto on Digg

Services

Health & Beauty

  • VADA SPA

    View Ad | View Site
  • Contemporary Dental Implant Centre

    View Ad | View Site
  • NUTRAMEDICS INC.

    View Ad | View Site
More >>

Links

Links

  • La Dolce Musto: the column
About Us | Work for Village Voice | Esubscribe | Free Classifieds | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Problem With the Site? | RSS | Site Map
©2010 Village Voice Media All rights reserved.