Is Eataly Eating Little Italy?

Robert Sietsema

Between its ever-shrinking footprint and the boutique owners whose delicate sensibilities are offended by the San Gennaro Festival, Little Italy has taken its fair share of knocks in recent years. And to add insult to injury, the neighborhood's merchants are saying that Eataly is taking away its customers.

Some of Little Italy's shop and restaurant owners told the Post that "the real people who live in Manhattan don't come here anymore," preferring instead to patronize the behemoth of West 23rd Street. There are, however, still "millions of tourists" who form a nearly endless throng on Mulberry Street.

And that may be part of the problem -- what remains of Little Italy has long been a tourist trap where you're as likely to find Brooklyn Bridge snow globes as top-shelf mozzarella. Long before Eataly squatted down in the Flatiron District, the locals were learning to avoid Mulberry Street like week-old veal Milanese.

And that's sad, because places like Di Palo's, Alleva, and Piemonte have retained both their character and superlative products in spite of their diminished surroundings, and offer their shoppers a far more authentic experience than you'll ever find amid the air-freighted tropical fruit and vegetable butchers of Eataly. Little Italy is indeed "a little dirty, grimy ... hot and smelly," as one Eataly patron told the Post, but if we wanted to frequent a mall, we would move to Minnesota.

And it's not as if Eataly offers its shoppers a convincing alternative to the crowds of Little Italy, or much of a respite from the tourists. Instead, like all successful malls, it offers them air conditioning and more options than anyone, anywhere, needs or will ever take advantage of. But one thing it doesn't offer is the city's best fresh mozzarella. That honor, as we happily discovered last year, goes to Di Palo's.

Have a tip or restaurant-related news? Send it to

And follow us on Twitter: @ForkintheRoadVV.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
N. K.
N. K.

Oh, come on - Eataly is the newer, younger version of Little Italy.  She is fabulous, but she can never take away from the character of the original.  Dry your tears and remember the greatness, the mob takedowns over fresh L'ossobuco alla milanese, up to your elbows in accordian players.  Relax Bellisima:


honestly, that's what Little Italy deserves for selling themselves out on their own traditions.

Ramona Santorelli
Ramona Santorelli

What are you talking about "selling themselves out"??????  You appear to be one of those people who believe everything they read, Eataly can NEVER replace any shop in Little Italy.  Eataly is a bigger version of Dean and Delucas. And if Dean and Deluca which is on Broadway and Prince Street did not take away customers from Little Italy which is only a few blocks away, then you can rest assured that Eataly cannot.  But that was not what your comment was all about anyway huh? You still cannot get over the San Gennaro huh?  poor baby!