Soup Dumplings at Shanghai Asian Cuisine -- NYC's Best?

P1020041x.jpg
Here they are -- in the crab and pork permutation.


Fifteen years ago when Shanghai soup dumplings first hit town, they caused a sensation, and foodies were lining up at the 7 train to sojourn to Flushing to get them at the original Joe's Shanghai. Soon thereafter, the dumplings -- bulging with dangerously hot soup, more grease than soup -- became commonplace on the menus, not only of all the Shanghai places that opened up in Manhattan's Chinatown (I counted six at one point), but also on the menus of Chinese restaurants representing other regions, or sometimes no particular region at all.


P1020042x.jpg
The dining room of Shanghai Asian Cuisine


Eventually, Joe cloned himself, and there were two Joe's in Manhattan. The problem was, the dumplings at all these places started sliding downward. First, many of them were deprived of their negligible crab component, which in the best examples send the filling in an oceanic direction (pig of the sea?). Second, the skins on the dumpling kept getting thicker and thicker, as dumpling makers unsure of their dumpling-making chops indemnified themselves against the charge of broken dumplings by making sure the dumplings never broke.

Well, a friend clued me to the dumplings at Shanghai Asian Cuisine, a newcomer to Elizabeth Street in the block south of Canal, lying at the mouth of the arcade that connects Elizabeth and Bowery.

The dumplings are superb: thin-skinned, extravagantly stuffed with plenty of pork and crab, with a little tuft of yellow crab protruding from the pucker like chin whiskers on a hillbilly codger. OK, the crab is probably the frozen product, but the enhanced crabby edge enlivens the ground meat. And, as in the original soup dumplings we enjoyed in Flushing long ago, these are so delicate that the slightest false move ruptures the skin and out gushes the fillling. Defeat!

So what about the restaurant's name? Well, the Shanghai stuff is mainly the lower end of the menu (meat balls, mock duck of mushrooms and bean-curd skin, chicken in wine vinegar, braised noodles, etc.), and the "Asian" stuff at the high end mainly Cantonese, Sichuan, and other regional Chinese. Stick with the Shanghai food.


P1020043x.jpg
The exterior of Shanghai Asian Cuisine


Shanghai Asian Cuisine
14 Elizabeth Street
212-964-5640


Like this post? Take a gander at the rest of our blog.


Follow us on Twitter if you dare:
@robertsietsema [Robert Sietsema]
@chantytown [Chantal Martineau]
@ldshockey [Lauren Shockey]
@ForkintheRoadVV



Advertisement

My Voice Nation Help
6 comments
Mike
Mike

The XLB here are terrific, but the shrimp + watercress dumplings are even better!

Mike Winston
Mike Winston

I went over for lunch today and I strongly agree that these are the best I've had in Manhattan.

Mak
Mak

I've passed this place a million times and never went in.  But I will now.  Good XLB in Manhattan have been very difficult to come by since Goody's closed.  I think  Joe's actually had a bit of a renaissance last year, and that the food had improved significantly, but it is well back on the downhill track again.

TT
TT

Shanghai Cafe Deluxe is very good too.

RSchwim295
RSchwim295

How would you compare it to the one on Prince St in Flushing (Nan Xiang Xia Long Bao)?

Rsietsema
Rsietsema

I definitely need to go back to Joe's and try the soup dumplings again -- it's been over a year. Are you talking about the Manhattan Chinatown Joe's?

Loading...