NYC's 10 Best Bargain Seafood Restaurants

P1030980x.jpg
The catfish sandwich at Taste of Seafood (#10 in our countdown) is abundant, cheap, and delectable, especially smeared with tartar and jerk sauces.


For those who think omega-3 fatty acids mean longevity, fish is the new meat. For the rest of us, seafood is a just another delightful option for dinner, providing clean and briny flavors, and an elemental connection with the very sea our ancestors crawled out of.

And while we now realize that seafood is not as infinitely abundant as we once thought, leading us to concerns about sustainability, water-borne organisms are still one of the best things to eat in NYC. Relished locally since Indian times, crustaceans such as oysters, clams, and lobsters, and fish like whiting, flounder, and bluefish, remain iconic New York foods.

Here are our choices for NYC's best bargain seafood restaurants, including cheap and mid-priced spots, but not the most expensive ones. These are places for everyday dining, often with an informal flair. Go for the fish, not the décor! We've only included places where seafood forms the predominant part of the menu -- which leaves out, for example, most Hong Kong-style restaurants, despite some very good seafood. We'll save those for a future list.


P1030976x.jpg
10. A Taste of Seafood -- This long-running Harlem treasure used to be called "Servants of God -- A Taste of Seafood," but God wandered off somewhere, and now the place is located across the street from the original, with a pair of dining rooms decorated in nautical themes. The expansive menu features -- in addition to uptown standards such as fried catfish and whiting, in sandwiches or with chips -- shrimp with linguine, steamed lobsters and scallops, and the plumpest fried chicken wings you've ever seen. 59 East 125th Street, 212-831-5584


DSC07700v.jpg
9. Uncle Nick's -- Located off the beaten path for a Greek seafood spot, Nick's Chelsea location is the most comfortable, done in tones of buff and teal and decorated with immigrant memorabilia. The grilled octopus salad can't be beat, and the best bargain fish here is the flounder -- perfectly grilled, while most places choose to fry it. Appetizer salads in a Greek vein are lush and well-dressed. 382 Eighth Avenue, 212-609-0500


P1020134x.jpg
8. Mermaid Oyster Bar -- Though the original Mermaid Inn in the East Village is also commendable in prices and quality, Greenwich Village's Mermaid Oyster Bar has a special sparkle, and a collection of oyster offerings that runs to six East Coast and six West Coast per day. War of the oysters! With oyster po'boys, fish tacos, and steamed mussels, this could be your new seafood-themed drinking spot. Check for happy-hour oyster deals.79 MacDougal Street, 212-260-0100


DSC04816v.jpg
7. Grand Central Oyster Bar -- The city's last remaining example of the lobster houses popular a century ago, and with a landmarked Gustavino interior, the sainted Oyster Bar in Grand Central is really two restaurants in one -- a dining room with high-priced seafood for the swells, and an old-fashioned lunch counter and barroom for the rest of us. In those precincts (or at the actual oyster-shucking counter, if you're lucky enough to get a seat there), you can enjoy splendid chowders and pan roasts at bargain prices, and graze the city's longest list of raw oysters, clams, and urchins. 89 East 42nd Street, Grand Central, Lower Concourse, 212-490-6650

DSC04818v.jpg
Sitting at the Grand Central Oyster Bar's snaking lunch counter is sublime.


My Voice Nation Help
19 comments
Sarah123
Sarah123

Thanks for this list!!! because of your list i discovered Devins fish n chips, which is amazing!!!! thanks again. amazing arcle.

Private Schools in New York
Private Schools in New York

The most delicious food and my ever wanted is seafood, clams, lobster, etc. very perfect for diet :) Looking forward for the seafood festival at Louisiana.

Gad Levy
Gad Levy

NY is one of my favorite places when I talk about food, almost anything I tried taste really good unfortunately I don't eat sea food but thank you.

Diamondkevdandy
Diamondkevdandy

 That first pic of deep fries catfish with wonder bread is awful. Tarter sauce too! Might as well get a fish sandwich from Mc"ds!

Dddd
Dddd

you guys need better photographers....

Chacegaskell
Chacegaskell

Used to really trust you, dude. Found you one of the more knowledgeable food guys out there. But you're sending people out to spend their hard earned money at Mermaid Inn? Mediocre on a good day and $16.50 for 6 oysters--that's a bargain? Other poster is right Mary's Fish Camp has the most expensive lobster roll in the city, and the entrees (hit or miss) are all above $25. If that's the deal at least send them to Pearl's Oyster Bar, your recommendation from years ago where we still find the best fish at the best price--pie's gotten skimpy tho.

Meghan
Meghan

Mary's Fish Camp isn't exactly a bargain seafood place.  Le Bernardin prices, no, but all but one of the entrees are north of $20 (and push $30 for the lobster roll).

Maria Boutsis
Maria Boutsis

Thanks for the info.There's definitely a lot of places to try once I get in NY. Thanks

Patrick Fong
Patrick Fong

Not exactly Legal Sea Foods, but it all does look very good.

Rsietsema
Rsietsema

I think you ought to try it before you diss it Diamondkevdandy

BrooklynClams
BrooklynClams

With all these wonderful mom&pop restaurants you want to compare them to a massive chain. Please.

Rsietsema
Rsietsema

Hey, Legal Sea Foods isn't what it once was -- I used to go to the original one in Charles Square, and it was wonderful

Diamondkevdandy
Diamondkevdandy

It's not good food! People like to eat fat. I know that. But deepfried is the least healthiest cooking method.  I would rather saute it with just a tiny bit of salt and generous black pepper and sweet paparika using light olive oil making it crisp on the outside and serve with steamed assparagus- no bread!

Rsietsema
Rsietsema

It wasn't a chain back then -- it was a fish market with an informal restaurant on the side, and it was really, really good.

JK
JK

L Train is right.  Fuck off.

Diamondkevdandy
Diamondkevdandy

What is your problem besides the fact that you are angry and probably fat as well.

BrooklynClams
BrooklynClams

Yes, but now it is a hugh chain and not what it was.  Why compare it to something that does not exist any more and to a restaurant that is not even in NYC?.  I could just as well say the restaurants in Sheepshead Bay are good but they don't compare to Lundy's but that closed 20 years ago.  What I would say is they are probably not as good as London Lennies in Woodhaven, Queens.

Loading...