Is There a Pastry Chef in the House?

Liz Barclay
Elwyn Boyles' cheesecake at Per Se

I've been tasting a lot of desserts lately that are sloppy and off-key, that don't quite make sense, that look and taste lazy or rushed. In each case, the kitchen lacked a pastry chef.

Dessert is an essential part of a great restaurant meal, but too many kitchens in New York seem to be operating without a pastry chef.

A kitchen can make ice cream in-house all it wants, but no cook will replicate the work of a dedicated, talented pastry chef -- a person who thinks of nothing else but how to send out delicious desserts, who is always working to adjust the texture, refine the flavor, strengthen the riff, or whip up a special.

Lauren Shockey
Alex Ray's lemon meringue pie at North End Grill

Some kitchens do manage by limiting the dessert menu and working cleverly within their space and budget constraints, or by consulting with pastry chefs and carefully training their cooks. (And despite the stereotype, some savory chefs really can make good desserts.) But let's face it, most restaurants without a pastry chef are struggling to provide the service of a proper dessert menu, and their desserts often look and taste amateur.

Do you need a reminder of why pastry chefs are crucial to a great restaurant's team? Try the compelling dishes that Karen DeMasco serves at Locanda Verde, or the beauties Malcolm Livingston II turns out at wd-50. Visit Calliope for Shuna Fish Lydon's seasonal desserts, pastries, and petit fours. Stop by North End Grill for a slice of Alex Ray's glorious lemon meringue pie.

Liz Barclay
Malcolm Livingston's smores

New York's pastry chefs set such high standards -- I wish more restaurants would aim to compete at their level.

Location Info

Locanda Verde

377 Greenwich St., New York, NY

Category: Restaurant


50 Clinton St., New York, NY

Category: Restaurant


84 E. 4th St., New York, NY

Category: Restaurant

North End Grill

104 N. End Ave., New York, NY

Category: Restaurant

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

You can always tell when a restaurant doesn't have a pastry chef when their dessert menu consists of:

bread pudding, chocolate molten cake, creme brûlée, and tart tartin. 

It's the same dessert menu in every pastry chefless restaurant in every major city. 


@ForkintheRoadVV pastry economics are hard for restos: labor intensive, low price-point, especially when only ~25% customers order dessert