La Stefani En Rose: Is Lady Gaga The Edith Piaf Of America's Disenfranchised?

Categories: Lady Gaga

Back in February Lady Gaga had this to say to Vogue about the song "Americano," which is going to appear on her increasingly imminent album Born This Way: "[It's] a big mariachi techno-house record, where I am singing about immigration law and gay marriage and all sorts of things that have to do with disenfranchised communities in America. It sounds like a pop record, but when I sing it, I see Edith Piaf in a spotlight with an old microphone." Well, thanks to the omnipresence of personal-recording devices, you can listen to the song while seeing a spotlight create a pale blob against a very dark background--Gaga performed the song last night during a rain-drenched show in Guadalajara, and multiple copies of it have already made their way to YouTube. It's certainly stormy, with a flouncy-sounding middle bit that inspired the audience to clap along, and it has lyrics in both English and Spanish that include the presumably-required-for-this-album reference to Jesus Christ. (They also sound a lot less clunky than the words to "Born This Way," thankfully.) Clip after the jump.

Doing a Google Image Search on Gaga is such an instructive trip down memory lane. Remember when she just wanted to paint David Bowie bolts on her face and sing about being confused by how she'd turned her shirt inside-out? We were all so innocent back then.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

Lady Gaga needs to get her feet on the ground and realize that she is no where near Mme. Piaf's level in any aspect of her life. Her songs don't have the depth or the power that Mme. Piaf's songs had. While I am glad Gaga wants to address those issues in her songs, she does it in a way that is so detached from herself as a person that the result is only an empty message with catchy tunes. Piaf sang with her heart. Gaga sings with autotune and money.


poor Edith Piaf. She was an absolute legend with an untouchable voice. putting her in the same sentence as this girl who's known for nothing but her wacky customs, is an absolute insult to her memory.

Now Trending

New York Concert Tickets

From the Vault