Can a Happy Trent Reznor Write Good NIN Songs?

Categories: Nine Inch Nails

reznorangry560.jpg
Reznor at peak anger.
Trent Reznor sure is a happy guy these days.

In a recent interview in The Fader, Reznor is even shown as chipper when facing a root canal. Reznor's apparent changed mood is so interesting because he has faced his demons so publicly in his music. Reznor today is sober. His first Nine Inch Nails album since 2008 has received solid reviews. His NIN tour--which hits the Barclays Center tonight--has gotten generally positive reviews. He's married. He has two kids. He has huge biceps. And he even won a Grammy! He's actually halfway to EGOT.

But, well, some NIN fans are a little disappointed in the new album. On NIN messageboards, there are many complaints about the happy tone of the new album. Of course, this is a little silly: Reznor is 48, and people shouldn't expect him to write the same type of music he did 25 years ago. But it's easy to see the source of the complaints. Many have noticed that "Came Back Haunted"--Hesitation Marks' first single -- kinda sorta sounds like "Gangnam Style." And "Everything" is probably the most upbeat song Nine Inch Nails have ever released. Big Time Rush could cover it.

Regardless of how one feels about the mood of the new NIN album -- I find it fairly straightforward and enjoyable--Trent Reznor has enough of a catalog that you can select a project of his to fit the mood you'd like. I've collected the data in a very scientific study to help you select a Trent Reznor work for every occasion.

Let's explore.

Era: 1989-1991

Nine Inch Nails albums: Pretty Hate Machine, several maxi-singles of PHM songs (Halos 1-4, for you NIN dorks like me)

Other notable work: The vocals on 1000 Homo DJs' "Supernaut," maybe

Song titles: "Sin," "Terrible Lie," "Head Like a Hole"

Common words in songs: you, just, what, want, away

Representative music video:

The video for "Down In It" was dark enough for the FBI to investigate it as a possible snuff film.

Anger level (out of 100): 44. The Voice called Pretty Hate Machine "a Human League album, except with punchier guitars." The lyrics may be those of a tortured soul, but the album is so danceable and 1980s the band even appeared on Dance Party USA.


Era: 1992-1998

Nine Inch Nails albums: The Broken EP, The Downward Spiral, "The Perfect Drug," various remix albums (Halos 5-12)

Other notable work: Producing Marilyn Manson, the soundtrack to the 1996 video game Quake

Song titles: "Help Me I Am in Hell," "Happiness in Slavery," "The Downward Spiral," "Mr. Self Destruct," "Hurt"

Common words in songs: you, your, control, want, come Representative music video:

When shown on MTV, "Closer" had several scenes edited out and replaced with "scene missing" cards.

Anger rating (out of 100): 94. Yeesh. Remember, he recorded Downward Spiral in the house Sharon Tate was killed in. Even the sex song is "I want to fuck you like an animal."

Era: 1999-2007

Nine Inch Nails albums: The Fragile, With Teeth, a couple crappy remix albums (Halos 13-22)

Other notable work: "We Want It All," a collaboration with Zach de la Rocha on the album Songs and Artists that Inspired Fahrenheit 9/11.

Song titles: "Even Deeper," "Into the Void," "Starfuckers, Inc.," "The Hand that Feeds," "Every Day Is Exactly the Same"

Common words in songs: you, just me, away, where, know Representative music video:

Oh, it turns out the woman is Marilyn Manson! Nice twist, M. Night Shyamalan!

Anger level (out of 100): 70. Reznor brings some melody to his depressing beats, making this era a little happier.

Era: 2007-2008

Nine Inch Nails albums: Year Zero, Ghosts I-IV, The Slip and--you're not going to believe this--another remix album (Halos 23-27)

Other notable work: Closely worked with Saul Williams on The Inevitable Rise and Liberation of NiggyTardust!

Song titles: "HYPERPOWER," "Meet Your Master," "Another Version of the Truth," "The Four of Us Are Dying," and then Ghosts I-IV doesn't even have any song titles.

Common words in songs: you, your, what, just, need

Representative music video:

This is the only one NIN released during this time period.

Anger level (out of 100): 55. Year Zero is a concept album about a dystopian future. It sounds suspiciously like Reznor's dystopian present, but he's trying.

Era: 2009-2013

Nine Inch Nails albums: None

Other notable work: The post-industrial (or whatever) band How to Destroy Angels--a reference to a Coil song--put out a few EPs and an album; Reznor and Atticus Ross scored The Social Network and The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, winning an Oscar for the former.

Song titles: "The Wake Up," "Keep It Together," "Welcome Oblivion"

Common words in songs: away, fade, you, little, keep

Representative music video:

A simple studio video!

Anger level (out of 100): 43. Reznor's getting so upbeat. His new band is so laid back it even played both weekends of Coachella.

Era: 2013

Nine Inch Nails albums: Hesitation Marks (Halo 28)

Other notable work: A collaboration with Dr. Dre's Beats Electronics

Song titles: "Copy of A," "Came Back Haunted," "Everything"

Common words in songs: you, just, what, copy, back

Representative music video:

Reznor finally makes another weird video, but classes it up by getting David Lynch to direct it.

Anger level (out of 100): 13. It's not NIN has released "Walkin' on Sunshine," but this is Trent Reznor at his happiest.


Ten Metal Albums to Hear Before You Die
The Top 20 New York Hardcore and Metal Albums of All Time
The Oral History of NYC's Metal/Hardcore Crossover


Location Info

Venue

Map

Barclays Center

620 Atlantic Ave., Brooklyn, NY

Category: General

My Voice Nation Help
1 comments
Hazel354
Hazel354

<!--upto I looked at the paycheck ov $9443, I accept that...my... friends brother had been realie erning money part time at there computar.. there best friend haz done this 4 only 6 months and resantly repaid the debts on their house and purchased a brand new BMW M3. check out here .....................................Buzz55.ℂom-->

Now Trending

From the Vault

 

New York Event Tickets
Loading...