Ask Andrew W.K.: I'm Not Ready For a Baby

Photo by Clipto
[Editor's note: Every week New York City's own Andrew W.K. takes your life questions, and sets you safely down the right path to a solution, a purpose or -- no surprise here -- a party. Need his help? Just ask:]

Dear Andrew,

My wife is keen to have a child. She often asks me, "Do you want to have a baby?" and I tell her yes, but then I quickly change the subject. The truth is, I've never imagined myself as a father, and if I was to answer the question honestly, my answer would be no. I love my wife. What should I do?

- Indecision Personified

See also: Ask Andrew W.K.: Understanding Our Parents

Dear Indecision Personified,

You don't have to make a baby if you don't want to. Just like the other notches on the traditional life-belt, "go to college, get a job, get married, buy a house," having a baby is a choice many people take for granted without deeply considering all it entails. It's good you're thinking honestly about what you want, rather than just blindly following what society does or what your wife thinks you should do. It's always helpful to deeply consider big life choices, and there are few bigger moves you can make than forming another human being.

Making a person is probably the most intense and mind-blowing act a human being can participate in. The fact that we're all a result of the magic of birth actually makes it harder to appreciate -- it's so commonplace that the miraculous aspects of forming new life can be difficult to appreciate. It's actually so intense that we tend to water it down into something less incredible. People are having children every day, but ideally it should never be reduced to an "every-day" experience. Each and every person we see around us was just a baby formed by two other people. It's so incredibly pervasive that it's often hard to zoom out and consider the miracle of life with proper perspective -- getting distance is hard when we're immersed in something.

And just like death, forming a human is mysterious and otherworldly. Making a life and taking a life are the two most mind-boggling things we can do as humans -- it's only right to be intimidated by the weight of either experience. Let's really think about it -- we're literally making another human being from scratch, or we're ending that life in an instant. Because these two extreme poles of creation and obliteration are so overwhelming, it's pretty much impossible to fully prepare for having a baby, just like there's no way to fully prepare for death. You can imagine what it will be like, but until it happens, all you can do is speculate.

Some people's main interest in life is having a baby. The act of forming and raising a child becomes their life's work and passion. This is wonderful, but somewhat rare. Other people have a personal passion that consumes all their energy and time, such as pursuing a particular dream or career -- this leaves them without much inclination to build a human being and make it their primary effort. Remember that, in a very real way, your own dream or passion is a type of child. Your own life and interests can count as your baby. And in turn, someone's baby and family can be their life's dream and primary project.

Some people fall into both categories or neither. No matter what, there's usually a hierarchy to one's life -- with one's "self, family, work, hobbies, entertainment, etc" getting ordered in some way to make them manageable and comprehensible. It's good to consider how your life is stacked-up at the present. How do you want to keep it ordered, and how will other events re-order it? Sometimes cataclysmic life occurrences like illness, disaster, or a baby, can forcibly reorder your life's hierarchy, and it takes an exceptionally strong person to give themselves over to a higher calling when they're time and energy has been previously dedicated elsewhere.

See also: Ask Andrew W.K.: Why It's Perfectly OK to be Shy

These days it seems more couples are not having kids, or at least waiting to do so later in life. In the old days, couples usually had kids as quickly as possible, 1) because life expectancy in general was short (you were lucky to live past 40 so you better get a move on), and 2) because kids could really help a family survive thanks to the children's ability to work, bring in money, and support the family in general. But that's not really true in Western civilization today. Having a child nowadays can be a choice based purely on the joy (or torment) of being a parent. In some ways, this is a great step forward, but as with many types of increased freedom and prosperity, it can also make the decision more complex and puzzling.

Despite all this, you shouldn't have a baby only because your wife wants to, nor should you have a baby just because it's part of the "normal" life trajectory. You should have a baby because it's something you want to do, deep down inside. Just remember, there will never be any other experience in your life that can compare to forming a new human. And there's not really any other prior experience that will help prepare you for it -- so you may never feel "ready" in the same way as you do with other life experiences, like moving to a new place or getting a new job. The best you can hope for is a feeling of readiness for what you'll never be ready for -- a readiness for the unimaginable.

If you do go through with it, I'm sure it'll not only be beyond anything you could have imagined, but it will constantly be changing and blowing your mind for the rest of your life. You're creating a new living being and it will rely on you 100% for everything -- its life is literally made of you. Despite the fact that it'll be harder and more challenging than just about anything else you'll ever do, it'll probably be the most rewarding as well -- "the toughest job you'll ever love." Whatever you decide to do, don't stress about it. Plenty of people don't have kids, and billions and billions of people do - and if they can manage it, I'm sure you'll be fine too.

Your friend,
Andrew W.K.

The 50 Most NYC Albums Ever
Our Favorite Online Resources for Metal Knowledge
The Oral History of NYC's Metal/Hardcore Crossover

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

I love Andrew's advice about not following the order of what typical society expects adults need to do. I often face pressure to get married and have children right away, but the older I get, the happier I am making the choices that make me happy! PARTY ON!

But for real, this guy needs to have a serious and honest conversation about his needs and wants to his wife.


I always liked childrens, since start of highschool I wanted to marry and have babys (or adopt one or two). I really dont think that I'll have a girlfriend that doesnt like children if we gonna be looking for our future, if she someday says me that she dont wanna have babys at all I end right there our relation ship at least romantically and feel really betrayed.
If she told me that is like she says to me that she dont wanna ever listen music with me I could not go ahead with that!! cause I really really want to play all day long with my future wife and my sons.


Um, also maybe stop lying to your wife. Especially if having kids is a dealbreaker for her,  the dishonesty is really unconscionable.


Um, also maybe stop lying to your wife. If having kids is a dealbreaker for her, your dishonesty is really unconscionable.


Also he writes the answers to be readible and helpful to a broad range of people

Jenn Maskell
Jenn Maskell

While you went on and on about the purpose of making a baby you didn't touch a more important part, the dishonesty in this relationship. Also too many facts are missing, was this discussed prior to getting married? Was he dishonest then too? She may have married him because she felt he would be a good father. If that's the case he needs to tell her his true feelings now and let her decide if this was a right relationship for her.


Well, those points, while relevant to this guy's relationship with his wife, were not what he asked about. I this case the reader asked what he should do. He didn't ask what AWK thought about his relationship. I think AWK tries to steer clear of making value judgments about people. There's dishonesty in every relationship. That's perhaps a topic for another column. This is a column to address concerns that people are asking about. AWK encouraged this guy to be honest with his wife. I presume that she will weigh their relationship against the fact that he does not want to have a baby if/when he does that.

Now Trending

New York Concert Tickets

From the Vault