Is It OK to Ask to Get Paid for a Benefit Gig?
Are you a musician? Is your group having issues? Ask Fan Landers! Critic Jessica Hopper has played in and managed bands, toured internationally, booked shows, produced records, worked as a publicist and is the author of The Girls' Guide to Rocking, a how-to for teen ladies. She is here to help you stop doing it wrong. Send your problems to her -- confidentiality is assured, unless you want to use your drama as a ticket to Internet microfame.
My band is pretty popular here in the Pacific Northwest and so we get asked to do benefits at least once a month if not more. Shows are not our entire livelihood as a band, but the bulk of it, aside from merch and some CD sales/Bandcamp revenue. We are politically-minded and community-oriented people but our ability to play for free is limited. How kosher is it to ask for a small guarantee? We are usually a headliner or a support headliner for touring bands. Some of the things we get asked to play are not very well put together and so the success of the event rests on our fans showing up and rocking out.
A Seattle Band
I imagine that any band with a bigger draw than 150 people locally gets asked to do dozens of benefits a year. It's thoughtful for you to even say yes to a few.
Something that can cause problems for benefits and the bands that play them is that often the organizers are people who have no show-booking and show promoting experience. They imagine the draw is pre-existing and constant for the bands, that people will be compelled purely by their heartstrings being pulled for the good cause. They also don't know that bands are sacrificing their own earning ability for the month, that fans coming to this benefit may not come to your next concert or that you are going out of pocket to be there for the night. Which is a good reason to ask for an honorarium.
If you are a headliner and you know you can bring in 300 people to their fundraiser, ask for $300. This may also help to weed out the offers. It might also help determine who has their shit together enough to be confident about turn out, and insure that they promote the hell out of it. A $100 honorarium is fair for any decently drawing band to ask for. Also, if there is a non-profit involved, they may be able to provide you with a tax-credit for the donation of your performance. Your time and effort is worth honoring.
Best of luck,