Is Tom Cruise Worthy of a Simon Wiesenthal Award? Also: Scientology's Building Spree

CruiseScieno.jpg
Jewish Journal writer Danielle Berrin recently took on a subject that has Scientology watchers chattering.

On May 5, L.A.'s famous anti-Nazi organization, the Simon Wiesenthal Center, will bestow on Tom Cruise its 2011 Humanitarian Award.

As Berrin points out, Cruise isn't exactly known for rescuing orphan children or parachuting into disaster zones. But as she documents very well, the Simon Wiesenthal Center and its Museum of Tolerance is just fine with bestowing humanitarian status on Hollywood celebrities who are, at least, generous with their cash. She writes:

Every year the center hosts a swanky dinner in Beverly Hills for titans of the industry, the centerpiece of which is the bestowal of the Humanitarian Award--the museum's highest honor--upon individuals who ostensibly promote human welfare, but perhaps more importantly, can get their friends to write big checks to the museum.

Cruise, however, is proving a controversial choice, since he's long been the poster boy for Scientology.

Berrin notes that Cruise's critics are howling about his being named a humanitarian when, just a couple of months ago, Lawrence Wright's lengthy New Yorker profile of director Paul Haggis revealed that the FBI has been looking into "human trafficking" claims about Scientology's poor treatment of children and low-paid workers.

Berrin found that the Center's board didn't seem too concerned about Tom's involvement in Scientology. One trustee told her Cruise shouldn't be held responsibility for the actions of an entire religion. Another said Cruise was a major giver to the Center and had been for two decades. A third trustee admitted she didn't know anything about Scientology (ugh).

Perhaps most importantly, Berrin found that the Simon Wiesenthal Center trustees seemed almost proud of how much controversy their choice was kicking up. And with the FBI investigation into Scientology maybe not really turning out to be going anywhere, it's hard to imagine the SWC caving over it.

In other Scientology News, The Daily's Hunter Walker has another good dispatch, this one about Scientology's ongoing real estate buying spree.

News broke this week that KCET, L.A.'s former PBS station which is transforming itself into some kind of college TV station (or something) is selling its historic studios to Scientology.

Walker points out the paradox that at the same time Scientology seems to be vanishing in the numbers of actual, active members (recent, documented estimates range as low as 25,000 in the United States), the church has been on a mad buying spree, and plans to open 60 new facilities around the world.

Walker does the math, and calculates that Scientology already has purchased about 484 square feet of real estate for every active Scientologist in the country.

Now that is some strange financial planning.


Tony Ortega is the editor-in-chief of The Village Voice. Since 1995, he's been writing about Scientology at several publications. Among his other stories about L. Ron Hubbard's organization:

The Larry Wollersheim Saga -- Scientology Finally Pays For Its Fraud
The Tory Bezazian (Christman) Story -- How the Internet Saved A Scientologist From Herself
The Jason Beghe Defection -- A Scientology Celebrity Goes Rogue
The Robert Cipriano Case -- A Hellacious Example of Fair Game
The Paul Haggis Ultimatum -- The 'Crash' Director Tells Scientology to Shove It
The Marc Headley Escape -- 'Tom Cruise Told Me to Talk to a Bottle'
The Aaron Saxton Accusation -- Australia turns up the heat on Scientology
The Jefferson Hawkins Stipulation -- Scientology's former PR genius comes clean
The Daniel Montalvo Double-Cross -- Scientology lures a young defector into a trap
A Church Myth Debunked -- Scientology and Proposition 8
Daniel Montalvo Strikes Back -- Scientology Hit with Stunning Child-Labor Lawsuits
When Scientologists Attack -- The Marty Rathbun Intimidation
A Scientologist Excommunicated -- The Michael Fairman SP Declaration


My Voice Nation Help
84 comments
Albert
Albert

The Scientology staff member's I've met are totally awesome and comments about slave labor are total rubbish. Scientology staff members are there voluntarily and get satisfaction by helping improve people's lives and the community. They use awesome tools available in Scientology that get real results. They've been able to make serious impacts on Human Rights Violations, Drug Abuse, and more. Scientology staff member's receive a small stipend for their work but it's not the money they're working for, they are volunteering their time to make the world a better place. Mother Teresa never complained about her meager salary, my daughter (non Scientologist) who works for the United States Peace Corps in the Ukraine earns about $150/month, she's not complaining. These people are great humanitarians who get gratification by helping others. If more people did the same, our world would be a better place. I hope the new Scientology Television channel spreads the word, and lets more people understand that their is hope. If the number of Scientology volunteers and practitioners increase the world will be a better place.

Aims of Scientology: http://www.whatisscientology.o...

Xenu Caused the Wall of Fire
Xenu Caused the Wall of Fire

The 4th dynamic engram is the biggest engram in recent (it's only 75 million years old) history. The Wall of Fire incident plus the 36 !/2 days of the R6 mental implanting, is ALL Xenu's fault. Xenu caused it all. Scientology undoes the damage from this mega engram all earthlings are suffering from. Scientology is THE answer. Everyone needs to lose their "body thetans" and be "body thetan" free like Tom Cruise is now. Scientology handles that!

Guest
Guest

Whether Cruise is complicit due to ignorance or lack of due diligence, he is still complicit in promoting a cult with many recent human rights violations. Terrible choice for an award.

ibivi
ibivi

Scientology is a mean, vicious cult. The Wiesenthal Center should do its due diligence on them and withdraw their award to Cruise. Are they so hard up for publicity that they have to sink this low? Please reconsider.

E.R.Rosenberg
E.R.Rosenberg

How embarrassing......someone didn't do their homework!

After all, even the media in Israel recognizes Scientology as a very dangerous totalitarian cult......and has broadcasted several programs on television exposing their crimes.

Also, I wonder how the Simon Wiesenthal Center Trustees feel about the new alliance between Scientology and Nation of Islam leader, Minister Louis Farrakhan?

A recent article on Rantrave reported....."On Sunday morning (Aug. 22), the Honorable Minister Louis Farrakhan brought a message to over a thousand members of the Nation of Islam. In a move which surprised many outsiders, including scholars of religion, Farrakhan concluded his sermon with an ultimatum that any past, present, or future "laborers" (people holding any position) in the Nation would have to sign papers agreeing to take Dianetics training (entry-level Scientology dealing with the body..."

Doesn't Farrakhan have a record of being rabidly anti-semitic??? The Anti-Defamation League (ADL) certainly thinks so......apparently Farrakhan's anti-semitic speech caught their attention on Feb 27, 2011, as well as Farrakhan's announcement of a new anti-semitic book "The Secret Relationship between Blacks and Jews".

Maybe the SWC Trustees should call the Anti-Defamation League for their opinion of Scientology's new partner, Nation of Islam.

Anonymous
Anonymous

It seems that Germany is more interested in protecting against a fascist "religion"/ideology than an organization that's tasked with fighting against fascism. It's sad how easy Hollywood can sell out ideological integrity.

Hal Jordan
Hal Jordan

I'm kinda bummed because the St. Paul "Ideal" Org has yet to open, despite buying the property in 2007 and saying it would open in...2008? '2009?

C'mon Scientology! Give us a building to protest in front of instead of that tiny office building on the ass-end of the downtown St. Paul skyway!

What_were_they_thinking?
What_were_they_thinking?

I wonder how the Simon Wiesenthal Center Trustees feel about the new alliance between Scientology and Nation of Islam leader, Minister Louis Farrakhan? Here's a link:

"On Sunday morning (Aug. 22), the Honorable Minister Louis Farrakhan brought a message to over a thousand members of the Nation of Islam. In a move which surprised many outsiders, including scholars of religion, Farrakhan concluded his sermon with an ultimatum that any past, present, or future "laborers" (people holding any position) in the Nation would have to sign papers agreeing to take Dianetics training (entry-level Scientology dealing with the body..." Here's the link: http://www.rantrave.com/Rant/N...

Doesn't Farrakhan have a record of being rabidly anti-semitic??? The Anti-Defamation League (ADL) certainly thinks so......apparently Farrakhan's anti-semitic speech caught their attention on Feb 27, 2011, as well as Farrakhan's announcement of a new anti-semitic book "The Secret Relationship between Blacks and Jews". Here's a link:

http://abclocal.go.com/wls/sto...

Maybe the SWC Trustees should call the Anti-Defamation League for their opinion of Scientology's new partner, Nation of Islam.

KKK
KKK

So what's the going price for a Simon Wiesenthal Center Humanitarian Award?

MarkStark
MarkStark

One thing is for sure, it has got to be higher than the $200 the Phoenix Org donated to Toys-for-Tots. Toys-for-Tots is Scientology's biggest [and only] beneficiary of the cult's money. That, and fraternal police organizations probably.

KeepOnLearning
KeepOnLearning

I can't think of any more fitting and poetically just embrace than a prominent Scientologist and the Simon Wiesenthal Center/Museum of Tolerance.

One point that exhibitions at SWC make piercingly is that persecution of minority religions begins in media. SWC gives example after example of small religions or ethnic minorities--to their everlasting credit, not just their own--being pilloried in mass media, then massacred in the streets.

No, I don't think that's in store for Scientologists, and let us pray no group ever suffers as did those in the Holocaust.

But if we neglect the PRINCIPLE that media sales rise when they sell hate and controversy, then we RISK smaller-scale repetitions of gangs vandalizing churches, temples and mosques after the religion has been unfairly slurred by media.

Evidence is Anonymous' cyber-attacks on Scientology's Web sites, the envelopes of white fake anthrax powder sent to Scientology churches and synchronized with their hacking attacks, death threats against Church executives, and Church fax and phone lines jammed so 911 calls couldn't be made.

Those are today's attacks. They've happened.

And the intellectual community is opening its eyes to the fact that modern ruffians are no less vicious than those in the past. They hate just as much. They're simply more closely watched and more afraid of the law than those of the past.

For that, every minority should be grateful.

Laura
Laura

Sry that I am not interested in you whining and lying about who attacked or did not attack your cult.

Got some questions to Scientology:

Was anybody tortured in a Gulag for years by your critics?Did your critics betray your religion on money?Did your critics pray anti-democracy?Did your critics traffick minors to get cheap workers?Did your critics beat their staff or members of your cult?

Your critics just make sure that reports by ex-members get published.Your critics offer help to those who escaped.

May I suggest you STFU, because the humanitarian people of the world would lilke to applaude Scientology Critics. This is true courage.

Jimbo
Jimbo

It seems rather strange that a group that places such emphasis on definitions that they insist on a dictionary in each of their course-rooms cannot seem to realise the difference between PERSECUTION and PROSECUTION..

Katie
Katie

Google Tom Cruise and Slave Labor

Katie
Katie

"Those are today's attacks. They've happened."

No, my dear, Louanne, they haven't. Post the dox of the supposed Anonymous attack on a Scientology church with anthrax, or dox as to the death threats. You can't. Because they don't exist. But you'll keep trying to spread the lies.911 abuse? Oh my, you are right that Scientology is guilty often of flagrant 911 abuse, calling constantly to bother police for situations that don't exist as you try to smear critics.There is ample evidence of this, most recently Mark Bunker innocently filming on a street in Clearwater (a public street, but I guess since it is Clearwater, everything is owned by Scientology, according to CoS). Anyway, it was again a false attempt to to third party a critic in the hopes police would tell him to leave and disrupt his filming.

The problem as critics will tell you again and again-IT"S NOT THE BELIEFS; IT'S THE CRIMES!

You keep saying people are attacking your beliefs. Do you believe then in doing criminal acts?

Jimbo
Jimbo

The problem as critics will tell you again and again-IT"S NOT THE BELIEFS; IT'S THE CRIMES!

Right on!

"Any group arrogant enough to believe it has the *exclusive* abilityto Save The Planet will inevitably conclude that any crimes are justified inpursuit of its higher purpose." -Ed Wolfe

choocho
choocho

Yeah, did you also need to make another sock-puppet account Louanne?

MarkStark
MarkStark

Oh Louanne(s), get a grip. Scientology probably defaces its own property, and Miscavige sent the fake baking soda anthrax to make it LOOK like the cult is being persecuted. What's with all the fake sock-puppet accounts? The crappy writing in all of them reveals it's you, Louanne.

choocho
choocho

"Those are today's attacks. They've happened."

Only in Scientology press-releases, OSA-bot.

MarkStark
MarkStark

I've read Wiesenthal's A LIFE IN SEARCH OF JUSTICE, and saw documentaries on him also. He was not a loon. If he were alive, he would be well informed about the totalitarian nature of the cult of Scientology, and wouldn't want to have any association with their Homo Novi culture, including Homo Novus Operating Thetan Cruise.

As Tony suggested, this is using Cruise as an honoree, to get the attention of other rich people, and I can't help but think Cruise may have dumped some money on them already. With his minuscule conception of history, Cruise conflates persecution of the Jews during WWII, with criticism of his cult. Maybe Cruise and Miscavige fantasize about an "apostate-hunter," (like Wiesenthal hunted Nazis), who will go after all the ex-members of Scientology for their crimes, like Marty, with his uncalibrated e-meter.

Torychristman
Torychristman

Amazing to me that the "church" of $cientology has weaseled into the Simon Wiesenthal group. They ((OSA)) had sent me there, years ago, to "See if they say Scientology is a CULT".It so happened they weren't speaking of cults that day, they were talking about the Net. They had taken a bunch of kids and taught them how to evaluate a Net Web site, to decide IF it was safe/good to go onto, or not. I thought it was brilliant, and returned to suggest Scientology do the same. They had *no* interest in it, and instead came up with their Covert "NET NANNY" which they covertly put on all Member's Computers. And the SW group---who lived through similar covert ops in Germany, is going to hail Tommy Cruise, the floor mat for C of $, who supports these very covert ops I speak of? Please. WAKE UP AND SMELL THE OPS. Thank you. Tory Christman---not "just an apostate"--I'm an X-Scientologist, exposing the very abuses they try to hide with words.

enthetasource
enthetasource

If the Simon Wiesenthal does end up giving the award to Tom Cruise despite being alerted to Tom Cruise's knowledge of human trafficking inside the "church" of Scientology (what? Mr. Cruise with all his infamy and fortune doesn't have any power to stop the cult abuses?) the SWC will have forever besmirched this award, if indeed the award still holds any value at all.

Better that the Oscar award was given to "Battlefield Earth" for Best Picture.

Note to Scientologists: When the FBI begins to investigate your church, "rumors" of human rights abuse have morphed into "charges."

Gary Lee-Nova
Gary Lee-Nova

Thank you for staying on the case, Tony. Always interesting to read about the media spin-doctors casting $cientology as a paragon of virtue and failing.

The latest manipulation of media, using the Simon Wiesenthal Center and its Museum of Tolerance, is clearly an act of desperation on the part of the $cientology cult.

The public image of the $cientology cult is currently so bad, it indicates that the cult is in a steady-state of crisis management.

You are making excellent contributions that are providing people with opportunities to understand that $cientology is a leaning tower of fraud, malfeasance & corruption, and soon to topple over.

Most of The New Yorker article profiling Paul Haggis was printed in the UK and San Francisco over the recent weekend.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/worl...

http://www.sanfranciscosentine...

Your article here underscores the fact that Mr. Cruise is a probably a beneficiary of slave labour controlled by the $cientology cult.

Humanitarian? Preposterous. It would be funny if it wasn't all so tragic.

Brussell1000
Brussell1000

Apparently Scientology's connection to Louis Farrahkan isn't a problem either. The SWC award is clearly available to the highest bidder. What's next, the Albert Einstein award for intellect being presented to George Bush?

Just like Scientology, the SWC is all about money and power. A real humanitarian would be speaking up about Scientology's slave labor camps and it's exploitation of its own members.

anoncangirl
anoncangirl

I am totally sickened by the thought of a man that has taken full personal advantage of slave labor (Google Tom Cruise/slave labor) is being bestowed with an Humanitarian Award. I'm left wondering how much money a person needs to contribute to have those egregious crimes overlooked!! It also baffles me that the SWC has chosen to honour a man that believes and promotes the belief that the Holocaust was totally perpetrated by psychiatrists.

ANONYMOUS
ANONYMOUS

Lots of OSA bots and the same old copypasta.What has Tom done to merit this award.Has he fed the starvingGiven shelter to the homelessComforted the sick.Try as hard as i could i found nothing on google.We know that charity is unknown in the cult and is out exchange,everything is bought and paid for.Has anyone ever seen a scientology soup kitchen.

James Village-Wolf
James Village-Wolf

Nice Tony...your pro-anon agenda couldn't be more clear. Disgusting.

Katie
Katie

Dear James,Scientology is not compatible with Catholicism. Hubbard teaches that all religion is an implant, made up. If you believe in your Catholicism, this will take you down a really bad road. Look at Catholic Online and google that and Scientology. See what is being said by Catholics on the subject Also Google Scientology and Cardinal Marc Ouellet and/or Scientology and Archbishop Robert Rivas.Damn, man, just go to any religious on your campus and ask them! Don't allow yourself to be taken in.

Mark Cabian
Mark Cabian

Nice James, you pro-Scientology agenda couldn't be more clear. Enterbulating.

Katie
Katie

You forgot to use your proper sock, James of the Wolves, although I see you posted under it above. Same sock.

David
David

I don't see why Tom's religion should get in the way of him receiving a humanitarian award - this goes for all other religions. I've read a lot about the various things Tom has done and supported all in the name of simply helping people out. Doing good and helping out is not exclusive to any religion, so we shouldn't judge anybody on the basis of what they believe in. The blatant religious discrimination in this article is unfathomable to me in 2011.

choocho
choocho

Louanne, your blatant sock-puppetry is fathomable.

Katie
Katie

I think it is interesting that all the OSAbots came out in force.Of course, they are probably all "Louanne".

But just for the heck of it, I'll respond. Human trafficking, Slave labor, child labor, re-education camps. it's the crimes, not the beliefs-did you see any beliefs mentioned in the article? Or is it your point that because he is a Scientologist he should not be criticized? That's what it sounds like.

Laura
Laura

It's not his religion. It's the crimes of this organisation and the fact that he doesn't care about them. That makes him the opposite of a humanitarian. He is nothing but submissive to a cult dictator. He has no courage to take a look what's really going on there.

Katie
Katie

Plus also his own involvement in the use of slave labor going back to the early 1990s.Google Tom Cruise, slave labor and woman's day for the article on the sworn testimony against Cruise.

Ginny
Ginny

I am glad that KCET sold their facilities to Scientology, at least they will utilize it to its full potential and the buildings won't be turned into a parking lot.

mirele
mirele

Another place to picket in El Lay! Big Win!

sarahinzurich
sarahinzurich

And what potential would that be? Filming a sequal to the Battlefield Earth?Or additional 500 "Meet a Scientologist" videos which are so incredibly popular on youtube?

Katie
Katie

This must be the current line.

SFF
SFF

Tom Cruise is effectively a spokesperson for the Citizens Commission on Human Rights, a Scientology front-group dedicated to attacks on Psychiatry.

CCHR has a "museum" on Hollywood, where Tom Cruise has personally taken Larry King, called "Psychiatry: an Industry of Death." The exhibits in this museum make the claim that psychiatrists were behind the Nazi death camps.

Look at the CCHR website yourself if you want to confirm this.

Tom's endorsement of this distorted, politically-minded exploitation of the holocaust is a pretty good reason for the Simon Wiesenthal Center not to give him an award.

Sandra Gortez
Sandra Gortez

This article seems to exist solely to A) continue your ongoing hateful and biased holy war against Scientology and it's adherents, and B) fill page space you can sell advertising around. 1. Who are you to criticize from a distance, a man who is charitable in private ways you know nothing of? Where is the rational basis for that critique? Let's be honest, there is none. 2. You're clearly upset that the Church you attack on a regular basis continues to grow. I have an idea for your next article: "Tony Ortega Visits The Church of Scientology". Why don't you go learn, see, touch, do, investigate for yourself. Why don't you talk to parishioners who's lives are enhanced and improved by the teachings of Scientology and offer a balanced perspective as a journalist rather than regurgitate the the message of bitter apostates who have been thrown out of the church for aberrant behavior? How about some balanced reporting for a change?

Mark Cabian
Mark Cabian

Balanced reporting? Such as? Seriously, for any ONE article you can find that isn't written by a Scientology shill or someone pandering to Miscavige himself, I can find 20 written by honest journalists.

You embarrass yourself but I find it highly amusing, so I hope that you can continue. Oh, where' Louanne by the way? Say hi to her for me.

sarahinzurich
sarahinzurich

Louanne, are you pretending to be hispanic now?

choocho
choocho

How about posting under one nickname for a change, Louanne?

xoxoxoxoxoxox
xoxoxoxoxoxox

Sandra. You think the church is continuing to grow? Do you see figures indicating this? For instance, do you know how many members the IAS has, and how this has changed year on year? Thought not. Heber Jentzsch was lying when he used to say there were 8 million scientologists. There were never much more than 1% of that figure, and the church has been shrinking for over a decade. Look inside the new buildings. Are they full or are they empty? Ask where Heber Jentzsch is now. (Actually, don't ask that. Just ask yourself how people can disappear like that.) Then get out. Don't be the last to leave.

Brussell1000
Brussell1000

LRH said that the only way to control people is to lie to them. Problem is that the biggest lie you tell is to yourself. We know that you joined Scientology to help yourself and others, but the constant regging and the mistreatment of others feels wrong to you. I wish for you the courage to take an honest look. When you're ready, there are people out here ready to help.

Turek Os
Turek Os

Thankfully the KCET building didn't wind up in the hands of out-of-town speculators who have a taste for knocking down the stately buildings from L.A.'s history and replacing them with poorly designed, soulless high rises or parking lots. At least the Scientologists have an enormous respect for the original building's heritage and rehab them beautifully from all accounts I've been able to gather. You could do much, much worse for neighbors other than a non-profit group restoring a classic building like this and continuing the tradition of broadcasting.

choocho
choocho

^^ Another new Louanne sock-puppet?

Laura
Laura

Excuse me, but as a matter of fact, Scientology has not respect of anything but money and power. And they have it until it's in their hands.

Katie
Katie

Beautiful buildings bought on the backs of fraud and abuse.

But gee at least they make them look nice.

From the Vault

 

©2013 Village Voice, LLC, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places New York

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city