Link Bait-y CNN Column on John Edwards Asks: 'Are Men Stupid?'

256px-Blue_Mars_symbol.svg.png
Frida Ghitis, a columnist for the Miami Herald and World Politics Review, has recently weighed in on the John Edwards trial for CNN.

Because John Edwards is not the first powerful man to get caught with his pants down, Ghitis wonders whether dudes are just dumb, writing: "Are men stupid? How else can we explain the endless parade of otherwise successful individuals, who by all appearances seem intelligent and competent, and yet risk destroying their careers and their personal lives over the chance to have a sexual escapade?"

Ugh.

Before we hit our head against the keyboard out of frustration -- apparently, we are still not beyond genital-based generalizations in America -- let's clear up a few things.

Obviously, the answer to Ghitis's question is "no." As made very apparent by the op-ed's authorship, it's clear that men and women can suffer from lapses in judgment.

And, to her credit, Ghitis doesn't actually argue that men are stupid.

She simply starts with a troll-friendly tone to suck you in to a laundry list of famous philanderers and vague conjectures about adultery. So no, she's not criticizing men per se.

What troubles, though, is that she would think that this type of rhetorical approach is appropriate in a serious setting. It's not. (It very rarely even works well with humor.)

If a man were to begin an essay with the question "are women stupid?" many women would be pissed -- as they should be.

Even if the answer is a resounding "of course not!", this kind of "reasoning" suggests that it's OK to weigh issues based on outdated biases, when it simply is not and never will be.

Follow Victoria Bekiempis @vicbekiempis.

My Voice Nation Help
5 comments
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Barry Donegan
Barry Donegan

Agreed. That article was way over the line. I'm glad someone noticed.

Papa Smurf
Papa Smurf

Even though the author does a somewhat passable job of calling this feminist idiot out, she clearly neglects a VERY important piece of information:

"She simply starts with a troll-friendly tone to suck you in to a laundry list of famous philanderers and vague conjectures about adultery. So no, she's not criticizing men per se."

Fridis actually is "criticizing men per se" by claiming that these 'famous philanderers and vague conjectures about adultery' are clear evidence that all (or at least, most) men are 'stupid'. Even though this blog is CERTAINLY better than the 'article' written by this feminist, we still have to make sure that this article is expressed for WHAT IT TRULY is.

Boris
Boris

She's a cunt plain and simple

Now Trending

New York Concert Tickets

From the Vault

 

Loading...