Lower East Side Neighbors Rally Against Notorious Landlord

Throughout our coverage of evictions and foreclosures these past few months, there's been a giant elephant in the room: Just about everyone one we've reported on has been black or hispanic.

Although there is no doubt the housing crisis is affecting minorities in the outer boroughs the most, this very serious problem can be found all over New York City.

Yesterday evening, a crowd of over 100, made up mostly of Lower East Side residents and activists gathered outside an apartment complex on 58 East 3rd Street to rally against the building's landlord, who has, apparently, demanded residents of the five-story apartment building, along with two neighboring buildings (50 and 54 East 3rd Street), to move out within 60 days.

Sue Palchak, a social worker who's been living, with her husband, in one of the buildings for the past two years, said the landlord, from Abart Holdings LLC, informed them that they must move out within 60 days.

"He refused to give us an explanation," Palchak said. "We've been getting threatening phone calls telling us that 'there'd be trouble if we don't leave' lately."

Palchak said the building is being put up for sale, and Abart Holdings are hoping to empty out the buildings to leverage a higher bid.

The Palchaks' are supposed to be out by this Sunday; they have not found another place to move yet.

"We don't have the money it takes to move out within 60 days right now," she said. "What are we supposed to do? We'll be on the streets."

Supporters of the rally included members of community groups, and neighbors on the block, many of whom have seen a similar incident three years ago, when tenants from a 15-unit apartment complex were forced out within 60 days.

Even people who are not directly affected, such as Peter Gee of Asian American For Equality, showed up to support.

Claire Birmingham, a neighbor on the block, said she's heard neighbors deal with threatening landlords, who often resort to scare tactics to evict tenants.
"I'm here to let [the tenants] know that Chinatown is standing with them" Gee said. "These landlords are so shady, I've heard stories where they have intentionally neglected apartments to let the building deteriorate, and then calling the housing department to demolish the building."

Wasim Lone, of Good Old Lower East Side, said he's been trying to contact the landlord on behalf of the tenants to negotiate, but they've been refusing to take phone calls.

"The landlord's request is quite outrageous, considering he's trying to kick out 17 families out of the houses in just two months," said Lone, adding that he is trying to get the City Council involved to speak to the landlord.

But the plot thickens.

A few phone calls and a Google search revealed that the landlord trying to kick these residents out is none other than Abe Haruvi, a man who reportedly owns up to 40 buildings throughout the city and has been accused several times of resorting to shenanigans to evict tenants.

In fact, The Voice wrote about Haruvi 12 years ago, unveiling how he told the same embellished sob story, to several different judges, to kick out multiple tenants.

Mr Garcia, who lives down the block from the three apartment complexes, had this to say: "How much longer are we going to let a man like that, who's had a history of cheating the system to unfairly evict tenants, get away with this?"


Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
Generalissimo X
Generalissimo X

so shocked a serial douche like haruvi is at it again.  and i love how you all scream about private property when this scumbag doesn't even live in the city or NY state for that matter.  so what we have is just some outside a hole for the sake of profit evicting tax paying citizens so he can make more money.  so this is about one human being's greed and not property rights as such.  the people that live in the domicile have rights not only as tenants but as human beings. bar the door and refuse to leave.  screw these disgusting immoral scumbags who sell people into the streets for their own gain.  

Marc Hurst
Marc Hurst

um these are free market tenants, their rights to these apartments expire with their lease.  I am really tired of all this tenant entitlement. Its insane! I rent my apartment. I know my lease expires in July and if my landlord wants, he doesnt have to renew. Its that SIMPLE


There's no way these buildings are 100% fair market.   Good luck slumlord.


Although they may not be rent-regulated (I didn't see mention of it one way or another), presumably, most of these tenants have signed a lease for a year and aren't month-to-month. If the landlord is seeking to break the lease, he needs a reason, regulated or not. And if Haruvi is planning on using the owner's use law, he's going to have to make up a new story, since the "I need to care for my 12 year old son" line he used in 1995 will no longer work now that his son is about 29.


If the apartments aren't rent-regulated, what reasoning do the tenants have against moving out?


so if you are living in a building with 15 families, some who have lived there for 10 years and your landlord decides that he wants everyone out in 60 days you would just say that's the way it is?  grow a spine dude.  letting slumlords get away with whatever they want because individual renters have no power is a fact, but not fighting for your home because of this makes you a pussy.  support the people not the man. think about someone else for once. 

Jack Foreigner
Jack Foreigner

Just because something is legal doesn't mean it's moral -- and morality should determine our laws.

Now Trending

New York Concert Tickets

From the Vault