Occupy Wall Street Sues Bloomberg And New York City Over Library Destruction

Attorney Norman Siegel and Occupy Wall Street librarians announced their federal lawsuit against the city this morning.
Six months after the New York Police Department launched a secretive dead-of-night military-style operation to evict Occupy Wall Street protesters from Zuccotti Park, conducting mass arrests and destroying thousands of dollars worth of property, Mayor Bloomberg, Police Chief Ray Kelly, and others are being sued in federal court.

In a complaint filed today in US District Court, Occupy Wall Street is suing for compensatory and punitive damages and seeking a declaration that the city and its agents violated the constitutional rights of the movement's members.

The lawsuit is specifically pegged to the destruction of the Occupy Wall Street People's Library, at the time a collection of some 5,500 donated volumes that had served as a powerful symbol of the movement's commitment to critical inquiry and self-sufficiency.

On November 15, the night of the raid, about 3,600 of those volumes were on site at Zuccotti Park. Around 1 a.m. that night, the NYPD swarmed the park, surrounding it and announcing that everyone had to leave and take any property with them. Librarians attempted to move the collection, but after removing their first load were barred reentry into the park. 45 minutes later, police and sanitation crews began throwing property still in the park -- including library books -- in trash-compactor trucks. The majority of the library was completely destroyed.

Eventually, librarians were able to recover 1,003 volumes from the city's storage facility. But more than 200 of those were so damaged -- smashed, accordioned, soaked and moldy, smeared with food and waste -- that they were effectively destroyed.

Also wrecked were six library computers, a wireless internet device, and shelving attached to the library. All told, $47,000 worth of property was destroyed.

The sacking of the library has become a rallying point for Occupy Wall Street, which sees the destruction as a metaphor for what they see as the city's efforts to stifle the exchange of critical ideas that took place in the occupied park.

Occupiers and their lawyers also recognize the public-relations opportunity presented by the city's wanton destruction of books. Attorney Norman Siegel invoked Nazi Germany and the Florida Koran-burning, concluding "The bottom line is: You don't nuke books."

Some of the books destroyed in the city's raid on Occupy Wall Street.
The lawsuit asks for $47,000 in compensatory damages, as well as punitive damages. But in recognition that sanitation employees, who the city doesn't indemnify against punitive damages, might get stuck with the bill, Occupy Wall Street took the unusual step of limiting its request for punitive damages to $1,000.

Also significant is the insight into the planning process behind the November 15 raid that the case may produce. If it goes forward, the discovery process is likely to illuminate aspects of the city's decision-making process that have so far remained opaque.

The main point, said Siegel, is to get some acknowledgment that the raid was unconstitutional, violating protesters' First-Amendment rights to freedom of speech, their Fourth-Amendment rights against unreasonable search and seizure, and their Fourteenth-Amendment rights of due process.

"Anyone in the Bloomberg administration, including the mayor, who thought they could get away with this, well, it's six months later and we're now in Federal Court," Siegel said.

Siegel noted that other cities that ultimately evicted Occupy encampments went to court first before moving in with police. In New York, there was no pre-hearing before the surprise night-raid.

City lawyers initially tried to amicably resolve the issue, Siegel said, but that after conferring with the administration they told the plaintiffs there could be no settlement.

"My sense was the Bloomberg administration was not prepared to say it did anything wrong," Siegel said. "Look, if we can amicably resolve this without going to court, great. But we want a declaration for historical purposes, that the government can't do what it did on November 15 and get away with it."

One of the Occupy Wall Street librarians, Frances Mercanti-Anthony, echoed the sentiment: "Mayor Bloomberg and the NYPD and the City of New York think they can shut down this conversation, and they can't," she said. "We're just going to keep coming."

Here's the complaint filed today:

OWS v. City of New York Complaint

And here are some photographs of the mangled books that managed to escape the trash compactors:





Previous Coverage:

[npinto@villagevoice.com] [@macfathom]

Go to Runnin' Scared for all our latest news coverage.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
Staten Island Bob
Staten Island Bob

It's ironic that every year Bloomberg cuts the New York Public Library budget and the branch libraries in areas other than midtown Manhattan suffer. The $100,000,000.00 gift from Schwarzman is going largely to gut the main branch and ship books to New Jersey. Most libraries now devote more and more time to alternate forms of media, like DVDs, and special events, like Zumba classes. When you add in the emergence of ebooks and the internet, and police actions, like the destruction of the People's Library in Zuccotti Park, the good old-fashioned book doesn't stand a chance. I would say we should be wary of centralized data distribution, because it can be controlled and shut down. (It is already being surveilled.) We should fight like hell to keep books in our life, and to protect our civil liberties, (the few that still exist).


So the Christians are all spitting mad that the NYPD trashed a Bible, right?


The destruction of the Occupy Wall Street library was an absolutely tyrannical thing to do by the authorities.  Citizens of the world expect such draconian measures by regime states like China and Iran, but this is supposed to be America where things like this don't happen!


Sorry but destroying books is a heinous crime, doesn't matter if it was committed by the USA or by the Nazis so don't even try a 'keeping the peace' comment/tirade here.  This destruction of property was repeated on March 17th 2012 when garbage trucks again were loaded with books by city sanitation workers under the auspices of the NYPD - so it was no accident: it was an aimed attack on the library.  Indefensible. You lose Mayor. 

You know the British when they attacked the colonists who founded the USA also thought they were keeping the peace.  As they did when they wantonly hanged many rebellious Irish. In certain dictatorships and in the face of extreme repression the keeping of the peace is known to have been consistently perpetrated as a crime and I am afraid the ruthless crushing of the harmless Zuccotti park camp will *definitely* go down in history as one of those times. The truth about our country hurts sometimes.  But just look at the situation of who is standing for what here: democracy and literacy vs. bank corruption and repression of free speech and you needn't look farther.  NY your shame is there for all to see - city of intellectuals, artists and police and city officials throwing books into the trash of some people who wanted to found an historical people's library.  


Is it wrong to say the librarian on the right is kind of hot? Will this get Lt. Bookman chasing after me?

Now Trending

New York Concert Tickets

From the Vault