New York Pols Wonder How Many NYPD Beatings Aren't Caught on Tape

As we reported yesterday, a Crown Heights man was roughed up by a NYPD officers because they mistakenly thought he was trespassing when they found him sleeping on a couch in a synagogue and outreach center for troubled youth in Crown Heights.

Following the two-minute-long beat-down -- during which he was punched in the head, pepper-sprayed, and beaten with a club -- he was hit with a felony charge of assaulting a police officer, as well as four misdemeanor charges and four violations, including trespassing, resisting arrest, and harassment.

Luckily, the beating was caught on tape, and it's clear the victim, Ehud Halevi, never assaulted anyone. Nor was he trespassing -- or harassing -- anyone. He was asleep.

The incident has prompted local pols to question how many similar beatings -- and BS criminal charges -- occur but are never questioned; in most cases, it's the word of a suspected criminal versus that of a cop -- a scenario where the cop wins almost every time.

"If not for the clear evidence of this video, we might believe that Mr. Halevi had committed the crime he was accused of, which included assaulting an officer of the law," says Brooklyn Assemblyman Dov Hikind, an Orthodox Jew who represents Brooklyn. "But the video proves this was a lie. How many similar claims by law enforcement officers are equally fictitious?"

Others, including City Council member Jumaane Williams, say the video is indicative of poor training from the higher-ups at the NYPD.

"This is another low for abuse of police power. Good policing does not require the excessive use of force Halevi endured and that New Yorkers are now seeing on their televisions," Williams says. "The NYPD is an institution to be trusted, not to be feared. Clearly that message was not absorbed by these officers, which calls into question once again the standards of training that they receive from their superiors."

The NYPD's story is that Halevi was drunk when he was awoken by the officers -- who were called by a janitor who thought Halevi was trespassing at the synagogue -- and that he became belligerent when they asked him to leave.

Halevi, however, had permission to be at the temple, and had been staying there for the past month. When he tried to explain this to the officers -- after having been abruptly woken up -- he refused to leave, and briefly resisted as the officers tried to throw cuffs on him. Then he got the crap kicked out of him.

The officer involved in the beating has been placed on modified duty as the NYPD's internal affairs bureau investigates the incident. The Brooklyn District Attorney's Office also is looking into the incident.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

I don't think this is a case of poor training, although that is a factor.  I think this is just a couple of vicious bastards who like to kick the shit out of powerless people for fun, and who should never have been allowed to be police officers.


The NYPD is obviously neither trained nor equipped to handle such everyday situations. The officers know less about manual control of an obstinate subject than lifeguards rescuing panicked swimmers who fight them. And it appears that the NYPD has never heard of the longstanding and simple use of tranquilizers.


 @otterpower Tranqs are potentially dangerous, or do nothing at all. A certain dosage is required to tranquilize someone. If its too high, it kills them. If its too low, it does nothing. So saying that proves your ignorance on the topic.  Notice how no longer organization (military, police force, etc) use tranqs on humans. There's a reason. To have a tranq that can give the required dosage to a wide range of cases would be unreasonable, or there would be too much to carry.

Also, lifeguards ARE trained to deal with panicked swimmers who resist, or attempt to drown them (unintentionally, but forcefully).

I do agree though that the NYPD do not have the proper training, and not enough 'training hours' to put their officers on duty.

Now Trending

New York Concert Tickets

From the Vault