Robert Sepe, Who Killed Girlfriend With Bat, Eligible for Release After Five Years Thanks to Appeals Court Ruling

Westchester County D.A.'s office
Robert Sepe
On March 22, 2008, 54-year-old Robert Sepe killed his girlfriend, Janette Carlucci, with an aluminum baseball bat inside their Westchester County home. He explained during his murder trial that the pressure over throwing a family Easter party had driven him to commit the brutal crime.

"The party was looming on my mind: How am I going to deal with these people, how am I going to handle all these people, I can't do it," he testified. "I lost control. I don't know how to explain it."

The 12 jurors convicted him of second-degree murder, which carries a sentence of 25 years to life.

Last month, however, an appeals court changed that verdict. There had been no new evidence over the three years since the trial. Rather, three of the five State Supreme Court Appellate Division judges simply disagreed with the jury's conclusion. The court reduced Sepe's conviction to first-degree manslaughter, which carries a sentence of five to 25 years. Sepe, who has been locked up for more than five years, will be eligible for release as soon as he's officially re-sentenced in the coming months.

The three-justice majority stated that jurors were wrong to reject the defense team's argument that Sepe committed the crime while in a state of mental trauma--a mindset that causes a "loss of self-control."

"The evidence overwhelmingly demonstrates that the defendant, who was in a fragile mental state, was actually influenced by an extreme emotional disturbance when he attacked Carlucci, with whom he had previously shared a loving relationship," Judge Jeffrey Cohen wrote for the majority in the September 25 order. "We are convinced that the jury was not justified in concluding that the defendant was not under the influence of an extreme emotional disturbance, for which there was a reasonable explanation, when he attacked and killed Jeanette Carlucci."

The opinion noted that Sepe had "a history of depression and a long history of anxiety and panic disorder that would manifest itself in panic attacks."

He fell into a downward spiral in February 2008, about a month after Carlucci moved in with him. His business, which had already been struggling for a few years, faced a lawsuit. Even though he'd put down a deposit on an engagement ring for Carlucci, he began asking his ex-wife to take him back. There was also "a heated argument in which [Carlucci] refused to have sexual relations with [Sepe] and told him she had been unfaithful with one of his friends in retaliation for [his] similar conduct."

Sepe told his sister he couldn't sleep and that he "needed help," and on March 1, she took him to Westchester Medical Center's psychiatric emergency center. He spent one night.

As Easter approached, he grew more stressed over the prospect of hosting the family party.

The day before the party, Sepe testified, he woke up to a noise downstairs and grabbed an aluminum baseball bat as he checked for intruders. Upon finding none, his anxiety switched back to the party. He testified that he paced for "a couple of hours maybe, an hour and a half" because he was "worked up."

He entered the bedroom and told Carlucci, "I think we have to cancel the party."

In a "normal tone" she responded, "Are you crazy?"

"We can't do this anymore," he shot back. "I can't do this anymore, I can't do it anymore."

Then he began hitting her with the bat. She ran out of the bedroom and he followed. The appeals court document describes the scene:

Carlucci had sustained a minimum of four blows to the skull consistent with being struck by an aluminum bat with "tremendous force." There were four lacerations to the back of the head, the "entire skull" was fractured, and the brain matter was eviscerated. There was no brain tissue left in the skull. She also sustained a broken nose, fractured jaw, multiple lacerations to her forehead, ears, and eyelids, and abrasions to her cheeks, chin, and mouth. These injuries were consistent with "bone matter from being struck in the back of the head" and with being struck while face down on the bedroom floor.

Next page: the appeals court's justification for reducing the conviction.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

<!--upto I looked at the paycheck ov $9443, I accept friends brother had been realie erning money part time at there computar.. there best friend haz done this 4 only 6 months and resantly repaid the debts on their house and purchased a brand new BMW M3. check out here .....................................Buzz55.ℂom-->

whateveryousay topcommenter

They were cheating on each other, he was asking his ex-wife back and he couldn't stand the thought of an Easter party.  

He needs to stay in the pokey and his cellmate needs to wear an Easter Bunny suit at all times.  AT.ALL.TIMES...even during the "loving" moments.


@villagevoice anyone who can beat someone with a bat, to death, that they once loved and cared about. Totally a threat. Keep him in there.

Now Trending

New York Concert Tickets

From the Vault