Is It Legal to Ride the 6 Train Through the Abandoned City Hall Station?

Categories: MTA

New York Municipal Archives
City Hall Station in its heyday
Consult any subway map printed in the last 69 years and it will tell you the 6 train dead-ends at Manhattan's Brooklyn Bridge Station. An older map would show the train's original track--the one it still uses everyday--loops through the now abandoned City Hall station before ending up on the north-bound side of the track and heading back to the Bronx.

When it was opened in October, 1904, City Hall station, with its intricate skylights and Guastavino tile arched ceiling (just like the whispering gallery in Grand Central Station), was the jewel of the subway system. It wasn't used nearly as much as the nearby Brooklyn Bridge station, though, so in December, 1945, the station was pulled out of commission.

Today, it's technically possible to stay on the 6 train at Brooklyn Bridge as it trundles through the ghost station and before shuttering to a stop at the uptown platform. We always thought it was perfectly legal, too, but our beliefs were shaken when we heard how one man's odyssey through the abandoned City Hall station dragged him through the Transit Adjudication Bureau's byzantine arbitration process too.

At Brooklyn Bridge station, Joshua Patchus remembers hearing the announcement informing anyone left on the train: "This is the last downtown stop on this train, the Next stop on this train is the Brooklyn Bridge/City Hall on the uptown platform. Not only is it unlawful but also dangerous to leave a moving train."

He and his buddy stayed on the train as it passed through City Hall station ("which is boring when it is not lit," he says). His problems began when, as the train headed back to Brooklyn Bridge's uptown platform, the pair were summoned over by two officers.

"Thinking they wanted us to report on something that happened, we agreed. Came off the train, they asked to see our IDs so they could 'Run them,' we handed our IDs," Patchus explains via email. "Next thing we know, they handed us the ticket for violating 1050.6(d)2, failure to adhere to a posted sign or announcement."

The problem is, Patchus and his friend didn't violate any posted sign or an announcement--They stayed on the train through the station. He was fairly confident that the officers were wrong, so vowed to fight the $50 ticket with the Transit Adjudication Bureau.

Patchus went to the T.A.B office in Brooklyn "a REALLY sad place" where says he was patted down, before waiting more than two hours to plead his case. He played them recordings of the train announcement itself and a recording of Patchus asking the train conductor if he was allowed to stay on the train... And two weeks later he got a letter: the court was siding with the officers, and upholding the citation.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

They should make a tourist attraction.Let subway passengers  get off and walk around this old  subway station

Tessa Inners
Tessa Inners

Interesting read. Never knew, and I rode the 6 everyday.

frank124c topcommenter

If the police arrest you or give you unfair summonses you must fight them. Plead not guilty, if found guilty refuse to pay the fine or do public service. Resist and fight the police in every way possible!

David Reinken
David Reinken

I've only had people look at me strange, never had any law enforcement activity doing it. Interesting read though.

Brian Perfect
Brian Perfect

According to Harvey A. Silverglate, you are committing roughly three felonies every day.

Joseph Duke
Joseph Duke

Its always great when the police don't know the laws they're supposed to be enforcing.

Michael Pires
Michael Pires

Depends on who you ask, the nice lady at the information window was definitely sure that "you gotta get off the train" because she "didn't no nothing about no city hall stop"

Now Trending

New York Concert Tickets

From the Vault