Welcome to blogs.villagevoice.com
Blogs
  • News
    • » News Home
    • » Daily News
    • » Runnin' Scared - News Blog
    • » Tom Robbins
    • » Wayne Barrett
  • Music
    • » Music Home
    • » Top Picks
    • » Find a Bar or Club
    • » Pazz & Jop
    • » Down in Front
    • » Sound of the City
    • » Siren
    • » Submit an Event
    • » Jukebox
    • » Join Music Newsletter
    • » Entertainment Ads
  • Calendar
    • » Calendar Home
    • » Top Picks
    • » Comedy Events
    • » Submit an Event
    • » Entertainment Ads
  • Restaurants
    • » Restaurants Home
    • » Restaurant Guide
    • » Restaurant Reviews
    • » Sietsema's Counter Culture
    • » Find a Bar or Club
    • » Fork in the Road (column)
    • » Fork in the Road (blog)
    • » Sponsored Online Menus
    • » Choice Eats Tasting Event
    • » Join Dining Newsletter
    • » Restaurant Ads
    • » Happy Hours App
  •  
  • Arts
    • » Arts Home
    • » Calendar
    • » Books
    • » Theater
    • » Art
    • » Dance
    • » Obies Theater Awards
  • Films
    • » Films Home
    • » Now Showing
    • » Movie Showtimes
    • » Reviews
    • » Join NY Film Club
    • » Movie Ads
  • The Ads
    • Ad Index
    • Flip Book
    • Media Kit
    • » Fitness Health & Beauty Guide
    • » Sponsored Online Menus
  • Classifieds
    • Free Online Classifieds
    • Real Estate For Rent
    • Sexy Black Book
    • Virtual Career Fair
    • Personals
    • Real Estate for Sale
    • Place an Ad (print)
  • Blogs
    • » Runnin' Scared
    • » Sound of the City
    • » La Daily Musto
    • » Fork in the Road (blog)
    • » All City
  • Columns
    • » La Dolce Musto
    • » Tom Robbins
    • » Sex
    • » Horoscope
  • Best Of
    • » Arts & Entertainment
    • » Bars & Clubs
    • » Food & Drink
    • » People & Places
    • » Shopping & Services
    • » Sports & Recreation
    • » Best of Ads
  • Bars/Clubs
    • » Bars/Clubs Home
    • » Gay Bars & Clubs
    • » Bars/Club Ads
    • » Happy Hours App
  • Archives
    • Advanced Archive Search
    • Locations Map
    • Event Search
  • Reader Recommendations
  • Promotions
    • Street Team
    • Join The Street Team
    • Contests & Promotions
    • Text Alerts
    • Buy Village Voice Merchandise
    • Supplements Archive
  • Site Map

Top

blog

Stories

  • Free Verse Poetry

    Tiger Woods' Sex Texts as Free Verse Poetry

    By Foster Kamer

    1
  • Overlooked and Hoberated

    J. Hoberman Responds to Armond White

    By J. Hoberman

    2
  • Lies, Damn Lies, and Statistics

    The Media's Hipster Addiction

    By Foster Kamer

    3
  • Protest

    Tea Partiers Lose Morning to Bloodfest

    By Roy Edroso

    4
  • Blowhards

    Andrew Breitbart: Pussy.

    By Foster Kamer

    5
  • Exploring the Right Wing Blogosphere

    Rightbloggers Whoop Up a Texas Re-Education

    By Roy Edroso

    6
  • Dating

    Renaissance Dating Tips: The Finale

    By Village Voice contributor

    7
  • Media

    Happy Birthday, Rupert Murdoch!

    By Foster Kamer

    8
  • Primers

    Carlos Slim: The Richest Man in the World

    By Foster Kamer

    9
  • Overlooked and Hoberated

    Proof! Critic Called for Baumbach's Abortion

    By J. Hoberman

    10
  • Politics

    Chatting with Monserrate's Spiritual Advisor

    By Steven Thrasher

    11
  • Dating

    Still More Renaissance Pick-Up Lines!

    By Village Voice contributor

    12
  • Dating

    Renaissance Pick-Up Strategies Exposed

    By Village Voice contributor

    13
  • Nanny State

    Bloomberg: Won't Somebody Please Think of The Children?

    By Roy Edroso

    14
  • Death and Taxes

    Oldest Woman in U.S. Cedes Crown

    By Foster Kamer

    15
 
Congestion Pricing

Congestion Zone Drivers Earn More $$$: Report

By Michael Clancy, Wednesday, Dec. 12 2007 @ 9:32AM
Comments (1)
Categories: Congestion Pricing

The commuters who drive into Mayor Bloomberg's proposed congestion pricing zone earn more money than those who take public transportation to the heart of Manhattan, according to a new independent analysis.

The average yearly income of drivers in to Manhattan was 24 percent higher than other commuters, $75,523 versus $60,889, according to “Behind the Wheel: Who Drives Into The Proposed ‘Congestion Zone?’,” a report by the city's Independent Budget Office, which took a deeper look at who drives and who takes mass transit into Manhattan below 86th Street each weekday.

The IBO also found that, when looking at the extremes of income distribution examined in the report, drivers were more likely to be in the top ten percent of earners and less likely to be in the bottom ten percent. More drivers came from outside the five boroughs than from within, according to the report, and those City drivers still made more money than their non-driver counterparts.

“These findings largely counter concerns that congestion pricing would disproportionately affect workers less able to afford additional commuting costs,” the report said.

All this proves the arguments of congestion pricing supporters, said Wiley Norvell, spokesperson for Transportation Alternatives. Norvell’s group and other congestion pricing supporters have made the argument that income disparities between drivers and other commuters were so great that the congestion charge would not have a negative effect on the working class.

And while some might question the statistics of interested activists, the IBO report is “unassailable proof” that congestion pricing supporters have been right all along, Norvell said.

“Folks that are using the poor to kill this plan are being really cynical, and are not being truthful,” said Norvell, who specifically referenced Westchester Assemblyman Richard Brodsky. Brodsky has in large part led the fight against congestion pricing while championing the middle-class, said Norvell, even though Transportation Alternatives’ study found that drivers from his district earn $176,231 annually.

“This confirms what we’ve been saying all along,” said Norvell. “[The IBO report is] a big shot in the arm for advocates looking to bolster our case, and we’re glad to see it.”

Bronx Assemblyman Jeffrey Dinowitz, who has stood with Brodsky during the fight over congestion pricing, felt that the IBO report’s findings were no real surprise. Of course drivers earn more money, said Dinowitz, because you need more money to drive a car. Still, Dinowitz felt that the income disparities were not as great as congestion pricing advocates make them out to be.

This was especially true when one compared City-living drivers, who the IBO state make $41,209 annually, compared to $32,279 for the City’s other commuters. No matter what you think of congestion pricing, said Dinowitz, you would never think $40,000-per-year makes anyone rich.

“It’s obvious that they make more money,” said Dinowitz of drivers. “But even if their average income is higher, most of these drivers are still middle class.”

He added, “People who are rich get driven, they don’t drive.”


Comments (1) Write Comment
Share

Related Content

  • Bloomberg's Congestion Pricing Plan Has Rivals February 29, 2008
  • Mayor Mike and the Yanks: How Suite It Is January 7, 2009
  • Plaxico Burress Will Take Everyone Down With Him August 25, 2009
  • Two Stadiums. No Waiting. March 7, 2006
  • Times: "Cluster-Site" Homeless Housing Bonanza for Landlords, Bad for Tenants March 4, 2009

More About:

  • Jeffrey Dinowitz
  • Richard Brodsky
  • Michael Bloomberg
  • Transportation Policy
  • Politics

Comments (1)

Susan says:

Having just read the Independent Budget Office report, your article is disingenuous. The report finds that a majority of those commuting by car come from outside the city. Remember that only NYC residents (of all five boroughs) will pay the full freight of this misbegotten tax. Those commuting from New Jersey, Long Island, Westchester, Rockland, Connecticut, etc. will be able to deduct it from their bridge and tunnel tolls, thus paying NOTHING. And taxis and limos, 30% of the traffic burden in the zone, also pay nothing but serve the well-off in the parts of the city best served by public transportation. Meanwhile, NYC residents pay the taxes that build and repair these roads, while commuters no longer even pay a commuter tax, while using all city services. (As an aside, the appropriate figures to use are median incomes, not mean incomes, as means are skewed by the very rich.) Before a single city taxpayer is dunned for this regressive tax, every city, state, and federal government parking permit must be rescinded, which would get traffic off the roads as well as out of bus stops, cross walks, fire hydrant areas, no-parking zones, and off sidewalks. We all need to get to work; if the city is afraid to confront it’s own, putting them on the public transportation they tout for the rest of us, then they need to reconsider this transparently elitist express service for the well-to-do and well-connected with their endless belief in their own entitlements.

Posted On: Wednesday, Dec. 12 2007 @ 2:58PM

Write Comment


Comments may not show up immediately after submission. Please wait a minute after posting a comment for it to appear.

All reader comments are subject to our Terms of Use. By clicking "Post," you acknowledge that you have reviewed and agree to these Terms.

Tools

Search Runnin' Scared


Follow

Email tips to tips@villagevoice.com

SlideShows»

  • Smell the Glove Party
  • Driven by Boredom's 9 Year Anniversary Party (NSFW)
  • Late-Night at the Shank
  • More Slideshows >>

Most …

  • Something's Missing from the Terry Richardson Stories
  • Jay McInerney's New Gig: WSJ Wine Critic
  • Big Energy Tube Thing "Smashes" Record, Sounds Terrifying, Still Totally Misunderstood
  • Big Win for Satan: Heavy Metal Addict Wins Disability Benefits
  • Sauced Court Cop Pops Paddy's Day Gat Shot
  • More Recent Entries...
  • Richard Cedeno, 25, Shot and Killed Outside City College (37)
  • Is the Media's "Hipster" Grifting Soon to End? (37)
  • Rightbloggers Find New Texas School Curriculum a Boon to Re-Education (29)
  • If Armond White Only Knew What a Monster J. Hoberman Really Is... (27)
  • Bruce Asante, 29, Stabbed and Killed in the Bronx (23)
  • Is the Media's "Hipster" Grifting Soon to End?
  • If Armond White Only Knew What a Monster J. Hoberman Really Is...
  • Proof That Critic Armond White Did Call for Noah Baumbach's Abortion
  • Anthony Weiner, Senators Call for End to Ban on Gay Men Donating Blood
  • Breaking: Malcolm X's Killer Paroled, is a Free Man Next Month

Twitter Feed

Follow villagevoice on Twitter

More Twitter >>

VVM on Digg

  • 1
    diggs
    Army of Prose: How I Kicked My Habit(s), With a Little Help
  • 1
    diggs
    Funds Pulled for Anaheim-to-Las-Vegas Choo Choo - Orange Cou
  • 1
    diggs
    Judge Goes Easy On Guilty CHP Pedophile - Orange County News
  • 70
    diggs
    Bitch Who Left Jesse James is Back!
  • 2
    diggs
    Colorado Health Dept. Opposes Medical Marijuana for PTSD
  • 1
    diggs
    Stephen Colbert Discovers Sweet Shamrock
  • 90
    diggs
    Old Man Charged With Hate Crime for Grabbing Woman's Butt
  • 62
    diggs
    Firefighter Can't Extinguish Flame of Passion - In His Pants
  • 87
    diggs
    Sign This is Going to Be a Long Day (Pic)
  • 71
    diggs
    Six Fictional Restaurants That Should be Real
  • 297
    diggs
    Man arrested for peeing on 7 Hispanic girls
  • 348
    diggs
    Cheech and Chong: 5 surprising facts
  • 335
    diggs
    How a Bag of Rice Can Save Your iPhone’s Life
  • 497
    diggs
    Wachovia Admits It Laundered Millions in Mexican Drug Cash
  • 406
    diggs
    Top 10 Kit Kat Flavors You’ve Probably Never Tried
  • 347
    diggs
    Missouri Lawmaker Wants Women to Give Reason For Abortion
  • 351
    diggs
    Woman Gardens Topless Near School; Kids Like It, Cops Don't
  • 391
    diggs
    Dad Tries to Sell Son on Craigslist for $5,000
  • 277
    diggs
    SXSW Interactive Is Dead
  • 194
    diggs
    Alex Chilton Of Big Star Dies In New Orleans
  • 8775
    diggs
    Legalization of Marijuana Bill in California
  • 5801
    diggs
    Guess Who is Facing 21 Years in Prison?
  • 5051
    diggs
    Guys Dates Several Prostitutes. No Sex. Just Regular Dates.
  • 4605
    diggs
    Get Up, Stand Up: Ammiano Introduces Marijuana Legalization
  • 3753
    diggs
    Denver Airports Controversial 32 FT Zombie Mustang Sculpture
  • 3743
    diggs
    Guy Dumps His Cheating Girlfriend Live on Radio (Audio)
  • 2720
    diggs
    Meet Scientology's Worst Enemy
  • 2695
    diggs
    Decision Tree: Should I Buy an iPad? (PIC)
  • 2631
    diggs
    The best (PIC) of Colin Powell you'll see today.
  • 2589
    diggs
    Police Get The Wrong House In Galveston, Assault 12-Year old

Links

  • Village Voice
  • Wayne Barrett
  • Elizabeth Dwoskin
  • Jockbeat
  • Michael Musto
  • Tom Robbins
  • Somebody Got Murdered
  • Studies in Crap
  • New York Daily News
  • New York Post
  • New York Times
  • Newsday
  • Wall Street Journal
  • Washington Post
  • YouTube
  • Salon
  • Slate
  • Gawker
  • Huffington Post
  • Daily Kos
  • Drudge Report
  • The Daily Show
  • Colbert Report
  • Politico
  • Philadelphia Inquirer
  • Associated Press
  • Fox News
  • The Onion
  • ESPN
  • CNN
  • Time
  • Forward
  • New York
  • New Yorker
  • New York Review of Books
  • New York Observer
  • ABC News
  • CBS News
  • MSNBC
  • Newsweek
  • New York Sun
  • National Review
  • New Republic
  • Harper's
  • Atlantic
  • Vanity Fair
  • The Nation
  • Radar
  • New York Law Journal
  • Columbia Journalism Review
  • Columbia Spectator
  • Washington Square News
  • News India Times
  • Women's Wear Daily
  • Amsterdam News
  • New York Press
  • Time Out
  • IRIN
  • Indymedia
  • FAIR: Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting
  • Cryptome
  • Human Rights Watch
  • United for a Fair Economy
  • International Crisis Group
  • nola.com: New Orleans Times-Picayune
  • The New Yorker:Iraq Coverage
  • Index on Censorship
  • CounterPunch
  • Center for Contemporary Conflict
  • McClatchy D.C. Bureau
  • TomDispatch.com
  • Common Dreams News Center
  • War Report — Project on Defense Alternatives
  • Power & Interest News Report
  • Selves and Others
  • Antiwar.com
  • Johnson's Russia List
  • Energy Bulletin
  • Dry Dipstick
  • IFIWatchnet
  • Al Jazeera
  • chechnya-sl
  • Bushims
  • ACLU's Torture FOIA
  • Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty
  • National Security Archive
  • Waxman Committee
  • Ethics Daily
  • Bretton Woods Project
  • Human Rights First
  • Center for Public Integrity
  • GlobalSecurity.org
  • Institute for War & Peace Reporting
  • 9-11 Timeline
  • Iraq Body Count
  • Students for an Orwellian Society
  • Center on Budget and Policy Priorities
  • whitehouse.gov
  • whitehouse.org
About Us | Work for Village Voice | Esubscribe | Free Classifieds | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Problem With the Site? | RSS | Site Map
©2010 Village Voice, LLC. All rights reserved.