Welcome to blogs.villagevoice.com
Blogs
  • News
    • » Daily News
    • » Runnin' Scared - News Blog
    • » Tom Robbins
    • » Wayne Barrett
  • Music
    • » Top Picks
    • » Find a Bar or Club
    • » Pazz & Jop
    • » Down in Front
    • » Sound of the City
    • » Siren
    • » Submit an Event
    • » Jukebox
    • » Join Music Newsletter
    • » Entertainment Ads
  • Calendar
    • » Calendar Home
    • » Top Picks
    • Valentine's Day Events
    • » Comedy Events
    • » Fitness Health & Beauty Guide
    • » Submit an Event
    • » Entertainment Ads
  • Restaurants
    • » Restaurant Guide
    • » Restaurant Reviews
    • » Sietsema's Counter Culture
    • » Find a Bar or Club
    • » Fork in the Road (column)
    • » Fork in the Road (blog)
    • » Sponsored Online Menus
    • » Choice Eats Tasting Event
    • » Join Dining Newsletter
    • » Restaurant Ads
  •  
  • Arts
    • » Calendar
    • » Books
    • » Theater
    • » Art
    • » Dance
    • » Obies Theater Awards
  • Films
    • » Now Showing
    • » Movie Showtimes
    • » Reviews
    • » Join NY Film Club
    • » Movie Ads
  • The Ads
    • Ad Index
    • Flip Book
    • Media Kit
  • Classifieds
    • Personals
    • Sexy Black Book
    • Free Online Classifieds
    • Place an Ad (print)
    • Career Fair
    • Real Estate for Sale/Trulia
    • Personals Blogs
    • Real Estate For Rent
  • Blogs
    • » Runnin' Scared
    • » Sound of the City
    • » La Daily Musto
    • » Fork in the Road (blog)
    • » All City
  • Columns
    • » La Dolce Musto
    • » Tom Robbins
    • » Sex
    • » Horoscope
  • Best Of
    • » Arts & Entertainment
    • » Bars & Clubs
    • » Food & Drink
    • » People & Places
    • » Shopping & Services
    • » Sports & Recreation
    • » Best of Ads
  • Bars/Clubs
    • » Bars/Clubs Home
    • » Bars/Club Ads
  • Archives
  • Reader Recommendations
  • Promotions
    • Street Team
    • Join The Street Team
    • Contests & Promotions
    • Text Alerts
    • Buy Village Voice Merchandise
    • Supplements Archive
  • Site Map

Top

blog

Stories

  • R.I.P.

    War Critic Rep. John Murtha Dies

    By Roy Edroso

    1
  • Advertising

    10 Best Super Bowl XLIV Commercials

    By Mackenzie Schmidt

    2
  • Exploring the Right Wing Blogosphere

    Rightbloggers Share Tea Party Rage at Gov't Spending

    By Roy Edroso

    3
  • Weather

    In New York, 'Sno Storm

    By Julia

    4
  • Transitions

    13-Year-Old Recruited to USC: Day of the Tweens!

    By Roy Edroso

    5
  • Fashion

    Project Runway: Ugly

    By Stacey Anderson

    6
  • Corruption

    Seminerio Gets 6 Years

    By Elizabeth Dwoskin

    7
  • Studies in Crap

    Rock 'n' Roll -- The Devil's Music!

    By Alan Scherstuhl

    8
  • Advertising

    7 Extremely Weird Political Ads

    By Roy Edroso

    9
  • Hate Crime

    Rush Limbaugh -- Assman!

    By Roy Edroso

    10
  • Q&A

    Parks and Recreation's Aziz Ansari

    By Araceli Cruz

    11
  • Democracy

    Poll: Paterson Hated (Not Because He's Black, Though)

    By Roy Edroso

    12
  • Drinking

    In Defense of Drunken Rip Torn

    By Roy Edroso

    13
  • The Arts

    Which Oscar Nominees Are Ringers?

    By Allison Benedikt

    14
  • Politics

    Bloomberg Aide Dunned, Still Comes Out Ahead

    By Tom Robbins

    15
 
Follow-up

Nightline's Bad Journalism 101

By Graham Rayman, Wednesday, Aug. 6 2008 @ 1:26PM
Comments (2)
Categories: Featured

ABC News Nightline has weighed in on the A Long Way Gone saga, and the verdict is that all is kosher in Ishmael Beah’s memoir about his days as a child soldier during the Sierra Leone civil war. (The Voice came to a very different conclusion after examining issues with the veracity of the memoir first brought up by a team of Australian journalists.)

But Nightline Correspondent Cynthia McFadden violates the Journalism 101 rule against single source stories, quoting only Beah in the entire segment. Naturally, he defends the accuracy of his work, which has brought him a lot of money and fame.

McFadden deals with the controversy over his book by mentioning in a couple of paragraphs the questions raised about the book. She doesn’t bother to consider the content of the questions, just refers to them in a vague, general sort of way.

Then, McFadden allows Beah to refute the claims, without doing any additional on-camera interviews to back up his account.

"I don’t think it’s possible that I made a mistake," he tells McFadden.

No one is arguing that Beah entirely faked the memoir, but there are serious questions about the timeline that he claims in the book. He writes, for example, that he was a child soldier for two years, but the newspaper The Australian interviewed school officials and found records, indicating he was in school for some of that time.

Moreover, the key battle, which underpins the entire chronology, most likely took place two years after Beah says it did. Thus, the entire timeline itself is suspect. The whole story may have unfolded over months, rather than years. And no one can verify his clinical account of a deadly brawl that supposedly took place in a refugee camp for former child soldiers.

And so, until someone (a former comrade in the army, for example, or an aid worker who witnessed the deadly brawl) comes forward to verify Beah’s claims once and for all, the questions will linger.

What would Ted Koppel think?

And an interesting side note: Last April, Beah’s book was a finalist for a Los Angeles Times Book Prize. But the judges snubbed Beah and voted to give the award to a much more obscure book by author Elizabeth Samet, who wrote about her experiences teaching literature at West Point.

Comments (2) Write Comment
Share

Related Content

  • Calling Ishmael Beah April 15, 2008
  • Letters April 1, 2008
  • Still 'A Long Way' From Answers About Ishmael Beah Book March 31, 2008
  • UNICEF Cannot Confirm Beah's Camp Brawl Claim March 19, 2008
  • Boy Soldier of Fortune March 18, 2008

More About:

  • Ishmael Beah
  • Cynthia McFadden
  • Elizabeth Samet
  • West Point
  • Ted Koppel

Comments (2)

Janice Harayda says:

Another good story, Graham.

Bad Journalism 202: McFadden also said that her report marked the first time Beah had agreed to be interviewed about the veracity issues. But as long ago as January, Beah was responding to his critics in an interview with Hillel Italie of the AP, published in the Washington Post and other major papers. And he's talked to others since.

Posted On: Thursday, Aug. 7 2008 @ 12:58AM
Anonymous says:

Who really cares if the timeline is not exactly correct? It's a great book that everyone should read and it tells the story of being a child soldier like no other author before him has done. Does the media always have to bring out every little negative point they can about things? Get over it!!

Posted On: Friday, Aug. 8 2008 @ 3:16PM

Write Comment


Comments may not show up immediately after submission. Please wait a minute after posting a comment for it to appear.

All reader comments are subject to our Terms of Use. By clicking "Post," you acknowledge that you have reviewed and agree to these Terms.

Tools

Search Runnin' Scared


Follow

Email tips to tips@villagevoice.com

SlideShows»

  • Bikini Burlesque (NSFW)
  • Brooklyn Taco Experiment
  • Idiotarod 2010
  • More Slideshows >>

Most …

  • Slate: Mayor Bloomberg #4 Among U.S. Givers
  • Mumps Outbreak Hits Suburbs; Summer Camp Blamed
  • Coyotes at Columbia Latest Grim Portent of Nature's Wrath
  • The Grateful Dead: Trying to Figure Out this Odd SF Rock Band
  • Rightbloggers Offer Tributes to the Late John Murtha
  • More Recent Entries...
  • Ruben Larios, Harlem Teen, Shot to Death in His Own Lobby (53)
  • James O'Keefe and Race: An Update (46)
  • James O'Keefe, ACORN and Landrieu Stinger, Ran Racist Forum Present at Race Debate (31)
  • Tom Tancredo Kicks Off Tea Party Convention With Speech on Socialist Obama, Stupid Voters (15)
  • Rightbloggers Share Tea Party Rage at Gov't Spending -- Until a GOP Senator Puts His Hand Out (14)
  • 7 Political Ads That Might Be Weirder Than Carly Fiorina's "Demon Sheep"
  • James O'Keefe and Race: An Update
  • James O'Keefe is Arrested, and Rightbloggers Tell You What the Real Crime is -- The Liberal Media Coverage!
  • Jenny Sanford's Top Ten Reasons Her Husband, South Carolina Governor Mark Sanford, Is a Really Bad Person
  • Obama Quotes Village Voice, Proving Treason, Fondness for Kinky Sex

Calendar

  • Tue
    9
  • Wed
    10
  • Thu
    11
  • Fri
    12
  • Sat
    13
  • Sun
    14
  • Mon
    15
This week's best events
3 Best Things To Do on Tuesday, Feb 9
  • 20/10 Vision

    Where: Gallery Hanahou

    Type: Art

  • Fêtes de la Nuit

    Where: Ohio Theater

    Type: Off-Off-Broadway: Opening, Theater, Valentine's Day

  • The Residents

    Where: Webster Hall

    Type: Experimental

  • submit an event
  • 340 more things to do today >>

Twitter Feed

Follow Runnin' Scared on Twitter

More Twitter >>

Runnin' Scared on Digg

Services

Health & Beauty

  • VADA SPA

    View Ad | View Site
  • Contemporary Dental Implant Centre

    View Ad | View Site
  • NUTRAMEDICS INC.

    View Ad | View Site
More >>

Links

  • Village Voice
  • Wayne Barrett
  • Elizabeth Dwoskin
  • Jockbeat
  • Michael Musto
  • Tom Robbins
  • Somebody Got Murdered
  • Studies in Crap
  • New York Daily News
  • New York Post
  • New York Times
  • Newsday
  • Wall Street Journal
  • Washington Post
  • YouTube
  • Salon
  • Slate
  • Gawker
  • Huffington Post
  • Daily Kos
  • Drudge Report
  • The Daily Show
  • Colbert Report
  • Politico
  • Philadelphia Inquirer
  • Associated Press
  • Fox News
  • The Onion
  • ESPN
  • CNN
  • Time
  • Forward
  • New York
  • New Yorker
  • New York Review of Books
  • New York Observer
  • ABC News
  • CBS News
  • MSNBC
  • Newsweek
  • New York Sun
  • National Review
  • New Republic
  • Harper's
  • Atlantic
  • Vanity Fair
  • The Nation
  • Radar
  • New York Law Journal
  • Columbia Journalism Review
  • Columbia Spectator
  • Washington Square News
  • News India Times
  • Women's Wear Daily
  • Amsterdam News
  • New York Press
  • Time Out
  • IRIN
  • Indymedia
  • FAIR: Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting
  • Cryptome
  • Human Rights Watch
  • United for a Fair Economy
  • International Crisis Group
  • nola.com: New Orleans Times-Picayune
  • The New Yorker:Iraq Coverage
  • Index on Censorship
  • CounterPunch
  • Center for Contemporary Conflict
  • McClatchy D.C. Bureau
  • TomDispatch.com
  • Common Dreams News Center
  • War Report — Project on Defense Alternatives
  • Power & Interest News Report
  • Selves and Others
  • Antiwar.com
  • Johnson's Russia List
  • Energy Bulletin
  • Dry Dipstick
  • IFIWatchnet
  • Al Jazeera
  • chechnya-sl
  • Bushims
  • ACLU's Torture FOIA
  • Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty
  • National Security Archive
  • Waxman Committee
  • Ethics Daily
  • Bretton Woods Project
  • Human Rights First
  • Center for Public Integrity
  • GlobalSecurity.org
  • Institute for War & Peace Reporting
  • 9-11 Timeline
  • Iraq Body Count
  • Students for an Orwellian Society
  • Center on Budget and Policy Priorities
  • whitehouse.gov
  • whitehouse.org
About Us | Work for Village Voice | Esubscribe | Free Classifieds | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Problem With the Site? | RSS | Site Map
©2010 Village Voice Media All rights reserved.