Welcome to blogs.villagevoice.com
Blogs
  • News
    • » Daily News
    • » Runnin' Scared - News Blog
    • » Tom Robbins
    • » Wayne Barrett
  • Music
    • » Top Picks
    • » Find a Bar or Club
    • » Pazz & Jop
    • » Down in Front
    • » Sound of the City
    • » Siren
    • » Submit an Event
    • » Jukebox
    • » Join Music Newsletter
    • » Entertainment Ads
  • Calendar
    • » Calendar Home
    • » Top Picks
    • Valentine's Day Events
    • » Comedy Events
    • » Fitness Health & Beauty Guide
    • » Submit an Event
    • » Entertainment Ads
  • Restaurants
    • » Restaurant Guide
    • » Restaurant Reviews
    • » Sietsema's Counter Culture
    • » Find a Bar or Club
    • » Fork in the Road (column)
    • » Fork in the Road (blog)
    • » Sponsored Online Menus
    • » Choice Eats Tasting Event
    • » Join Dining Newsletter
    • » Restaurant Ads
  •  
  • Arts
    • » Calendar
    • » Books
    • » Theater
    • » Art
    • » Dance
    • » Obies Theater Awards
  • Films
    • » Now Showing
    • » Movie Showtimes
    • » Reviews
    • » Join NY Film Club
    • » Movie Ads
  • The Ads
    • Ad Index
    • Flip Book
    • Media Kit
  • Classifieds
    • Personals
    • Sexy Black Book
    • Free Online Classifieds
    • Place an Ad (print)
    • Career Fair
    • Real Estate for Sale/Trulia
    • Personals Blogs
    • Real Estate For Rent
  • Blogs
    • » Runnin' Scared
    • » Sound of the City
    • » La Daily Musto
    • » Fork in the Road (blog)
    • » All City
  • Columns
    • » La Dolce Musto
    • » Tom Robbins
    • » Sex
    • » Horoscope
  • Best Of
    • » Arts & Entertainment
    • » Bars & Clubs
    • » Food & Drink
    • » People & Places
    • » Shopping & Services
    • » Sports & Recreation
    • » Best of Ads
  • Bars/Clubs
    • » Bars/Clubs Home
    • » Bars/Club Ads
  • Archives
  • Reader Recommendations
  • Promotions
    • Street Team
    • Join The Street Team
    • Contests & Promotions
    • Text Alerts
    • Buy Village Voice Merchandise
    • Supplements Archive
  • Site Map

Top

blog

Stories

  • Somebody Got Murdered

    Staten Island Slay Suspect "High As a Motherfucker"

    By Graham Rayman

    1
  • Urban Wildlife

    Coyotes Invade Columbia University

    By Roy Edroso

    2
  • Exploring the Right Wing Blogosphere

    Rightblogger Tributes to the Late John Murtha

    By Roy Edroso

    3
  • R.I.P.

    War Critic Rep. John Murtha Dies

    By Roy Edroso

    4
  • Advertising

    10 Best Super Bowl XLIV Commercials

    By Mackenzie Schmidt

    5
  • Exploring the Right Wing Blogosphere

    Rightbloggers Share Tea Party Rage at Gov't Spending

    By Roy Edroso

    6
  • Weather

    In New York, 'Sno Storm

    By Julia

    7
  • Transitions

    13-Year-Old Recruited to USC: Day of the Tweens!

    By Roy Edroso

    8
  • Fashion

    Project Runway: Ugly

    By Stacey Anderson

    9
  • Corruption

    Seminerio Gets 6 Years

    By Elizabeth Dwoskin

    10
  • Studies in Crap

    Rock 'n' Roll -- The Devil's Music!

    By Alan Scherstuhl

    11
  • Advertising

    7 Extremely Weird Political Ads

    By Roy Edroso

    12
  • Hate Crime

    Rush Limbaugh -- Assman!

    By Roy Edroso

    13
  • Q&A

    Parks and Recreation's Aziz Ansari

    By Araceli Cruz

    14
  • Democracy

    Poll: Paterson Hated (Not Because He's Black, Though)

    By Roy Edroso

    15
 
Featured

Fighting Foreclosure: Subprime Borrowers Battle (and Beat) Lenders in Court

By Amanda Stutt, Wednesday, Sep. 3 2008 @ 3:01PM
Comments (11)
Categories: Bricks and Mortar, Subprime Meltdown, The Money Trail

foreclosure.jpgIn response to the subprime mortgage foreclosure crisis sweeping New York City, the highest court in the State is finding new ways to provide homeowners with legal advice and representation if they are faced with foreclosure.

A series of startling court decisions nationwide have ruled against subprime lenders attempting to foreclose on borrowers after failing to legally establish ownership of the loans in question because they had been 'transferred' multiple times.

New York Chief Justice Judith Kaye has now called for a special Foreclosure Court to deal solely with foreclosure cases in Queens -- where, the New York Post reports, the number of foreclosures has increased 81 percent in just one year. The Court will serve as an alternative dispute process -- advising homeowners of legal options by proactively sending notices to homes under threat of foreclosure.

"Reaching out" to homeowners

Judge Kaye is concerned about New Yorkers losing their homes in "record numbers," and wants borrowers to know that legal representation is available. "We are hoping people will reach out… and get counsel," she told the Voice.

Judge Kaye said since January 2005, foreclosure filings have increased 150% statewide. "Queens has over 15,000 new foreclosures pending...they are overwhelmingly defaults... but we don't know who the people are -- we don't see a profile," she said.

Nationwide, court initiatives similar to the Queens project are helping borrowers in default who may not know what to do.

Judge Kaye said the Court initiative "has begun in the sense that we have sent out notices to people who have pending foreclosures."

Supreme Court documents issued to homeowners state, "Under the law, you are entitled to a Conference with you and your lender to see if your case can be resolved".

Through state-enacted legislation, these "Court Conferences" will be held to advise borrowers of their legal rights, and provide them a bridge to legal representation during foreclosure proceedings.

"We are trying to locate pro-bono lawyers to identify and train... to raise consciousness of the need to help. We are in sync with courts in Ohio and Pennsylvania trying to get to the homeowner. We are on the right track. The Federal reserve is working with us. I think this is the best of the profession -- lawyers helping people," Judge Kaye said.

The Court Conferences are set to begin in December.

"If the paperwork is garbage I deny it"

More and more Judges have demonstrated they are not willing to foreclose on a mortgage when they can't determine where it originated, or who actually owns the loan.

Brooklyn Supreme Court Judge Arthur Schack, who sees plenty of defaulted subprime loans in his courtroom, believes the Queens project "is an attempt to help people. If it can help save peoples' homes -- more power to it" he said.

Schack estimates that of approximately "Seven to eight thousand foreclosures in the past year in King's County alone -- 80 to 90 percent are subprime and in minority neighborhoods. It's the bulk of what we get," he said.

In a recent National Law Journal article Shack said, "I deny more foreclosures than I approve… I want to see all the paperwork before I approve it. If the paperwork is garbage, I deny it. If you're going to take away someone's home, it should be done properly."

Schack recently ruled in a foreclosure suit brought by Wells Fargo that the bank "lacks the standing to foreclose" because it "failed to establish ownership of the mortgage."

The foreclosure "killer"

Florida Jacksonville Legal Aid Attorney April Charney is known nationwide as the "foreclosure killer." She travels the country teaching lawyers how to fight foreclosure in court -- and win.

Charney said Judge Schack "is setting the bar high for other judges. His court is only [being] accessed by persons with legitimate claims to bring to court. There is an obligation to make sure the paperwork is appropriate."

Charney is making sure Schack's opinions "are getting well read all over the country."

Charney said it is important that lawyers and judges are trained to deal with the new legal issues arising out of the legal revelations about subprime loan transfers.

"It seems to be a no-brainer that a judge should make sure the [foreclosure] has a legal claim."

She said what resulted from the "transferring" of loans is there is now "no ownership" of loans.

"I don't understand why lawyers didn't check to see if the paperwork is valid" she said. "Law firms have been sued over debt collection... and foreclosure firms have been sued in active litigation," she said.

Charney explained where it went wrong: Mortgage loans were originated by brokers and lenders to fill up mortgage "pools." The pools were then sold off to investment banking firms that have trustees acting on behalf of the banks.

"When it became apparent that millions of subprime mortgage loans were not viable because they were no longer affordable to the borrower, the trustee comes in to file a foreclosure, but they can't prove they own the loans," Charney said. "The originating lenders were not transferring the loans until the mortgage had already gone into foreclosure -- the paperwork hadn't been moving."

When a subprime mortgage goes into default and the trustee acting for the bank goes to file a foreclosure, often it turn out that ownership of the loan cannot be established. Over and over, these foreclosures are not standing up in court.

"The task of defending foreclosures largely falls upon legal aid attorneys, because most of the big firms are conflicted out because they represent the banks," Charney said.

Loans "fraudulently induced"

Catherine Austin Fitts, former Assistant Secretary of Housing and Urban Development, adds a new twist: She believes that borrowers can fight foreclosure because "most mortgages issued in this country from 1996 on were fraudulently induced."

Fitts said in cases of fraudulently induced loans lenders "knew they were issuing mortgages that were not affordable to the borrower," and the borrower "may not owe the money back because they essentially failed to disclose something about [the borrowers]' financial situation that they knew and the borrower didn't."

Josh Zinner, co-director of NEDAP, New York Economic Development Advocacy Project, was formerly director of the Foreclosure Prevention Project at South Brooklyn legal services where he defended hundreds of foreclosure cases that were the results of subprime mortgage loans.

He said that after the recent spate of publicity subprime garnered, courts are becoming more open to hearing about abuses in the lending system.

This is good news for subprime borrowers who are in danger of foreclosure because "borrowers who had legal representation had a much better chance of saving their homes," said Zinner.

There has been a "quantum leap in the last year -- judges' attitudes are changing significantly. The bottom line is that as judges become more aware, they'll see it in a different light," he said.

Zinner recounted stories of clients who were approached by brokers knocking on their front door. Brokers were reportedly so motivated by the "Yield Spread Premium fee" they collected for bringing in loans to a lender at the highest possible subprime rate that they would go door-to-door in low-income neighborhoods, convincing unprepared borrowers that they qualified for mortgage loans.

"People were made promises. Many borrowers were 'bait and switched' into loans they couldn't afford."

"It's fraudulent inducement," he said.

Foreclosure cases thrown out of court

In a recent Supreme Court case in Saratoga, New York, Judge Thomas Nolan denied Deutsche Bank's foreclosure action against a borrower because the Bank offered "no evidence that it took physical delivery of the note and mortgage before commencing this action."

As recently as August 19, a Massachusetts bankruptcy court denied Deutsche Bank National Trust's motion and ordered counsel to the debtor "to submit an application for compensation."

In Ohio, Chief Justice Thomas Moyer issued a plea for lawyers to defend foreclosure cases.

Lenders have reportedly abandoned foreclosure action after courts have demanded to see original mortgage notes, and as judges see the substandard structure of paperwork of many subprime loans going into foreclosure, there have been more rulings in favor of the borrowers, not the lenders.

Also in Ohio, a rash of foreclosure cases brought by mortgage investors were dismissed by Judges. According to court documents, Federal Judge Christopher Boyko dismissed 14 foreclosure cases filed by Deutsche Bank in 2007, ruling that "the plaintiff had failed to establish that they had a standing to bring the lawsuits."

And in the largest consumer protection settlement in the history of the Federal Trade Commission, in 2002, the California Supreme Court ordered Citigroup and the Citifinancial credit Company to "establish a $215 million redress fund for subprime borrowers" after the plaintiffs filed a class action lawsuit for "violation of the Consumer Remedies Act, Unfair, unlawful and fraudulent business practices... Fraud, Fraudulent Concealment and Deceit and unjust enrichment."

All of this bodes well for the Court Conferences the Queens pilot project has planned -- and for homeowners facing foreclosure.

Comments (11) Write Comment
Share

Related Content

  • Obama's New Bank Laws Would Re-Criminalize Wall Street Shenanigans; Panicky Dems Finally Listen to Paul Volcker January 21, 2010
  • We've Bailed out the Banks. When Do We Go After the Crooks Behind our Financial Collapse? October 27, 2009
  • Krugman called it: 'Heads they win, tails we lose' October 14, 2008
  • Bloomberg Keeps His Billions Separate From His Mayoral Obligations? Yeah, Right! September 1, 2009
  • What Cooked the World's Economy? January 28, 2009

More About:

  • Judith Kaye
  • April Charney
  • Court Conferences
  • Subprime Lending
  • Personal Finance

Comments (11)

David Phan says:

A foreclosure is a foreclosure. Regardless of how you got into this mess, own up to it and let the house go.

I'm sitting on the fence with my 100K down payment to buy your home.

Stop finding loop holes in the court system to bail your "> Smart a$$"

Posted On: Thursday, Sep. 4 2008 @ 3:36PM
Lou says:

Here's a novel idea, if you never got one of these loans in the firstg place, you wouldn't be in foreclosure. I'm not defending these brokers and banks, they're scum. But it takes 2 to tango. These banks and borrowers are like drug dealers and addicts. No one is innocent.

Posted On: Thursday, Sep. 4 2008 @ 7:39PM
v says:

Wait, so these people can continue to live in their homes and not make mortgage payments? I want free housing too....

Posted On: Friday, Sep. 5 2008 @ 9:54AM
scouser says:

please-- if you were some poor shmuck living in the hood, & some guy knocked on your door-- with lots of pretty brochures & a bunch of mortgage math calculations that nobody understands anyway-- to show you how you too could become a homeowner, are you telling me you all would have virtuously said "Begone, mortgage man, for I know I can not afford to buy a home!".

Y'all are full of it.

Posted On: Friday, Sep. 5 2008 @ 12:14PM
Brian says:

Unfortunately the basic premise of the article is flawed -- that these legal delays over "ownership" will let people keep their houses. In many cases, it is a technicality they are wrangling over -- whether the assignment to the next "owner" of the mortgage was properly documented, and whether original documents (usually kept in a vault somewhere) are what is necessary to prove ownership. it is usually a case of the mortgage servicer/law firm representing them trying to do things on the cheap. When slapped on the wrist by a judge, they can always go back and straighten out the paperwork. In every case I've heard of, they were subsequently able to "prove" ownership, and the foreclosure could proceed. It takes more time, and it's more expensive, but no servicer is going to just give up and go home. Unfortunately for the judges, they are constrained by the Uniform Commercial Code, common-law precedents and legislation. This Florida lawyer, April Charney, has apparently now made a career out of "teaching" lawyers about the system. If it makes banks and mortgage servicers go by the book, fine. But in the end, it's not going to make a difference.

Posted On: Friday, Sep. 5 2008 @ 12:33PM
Mortgage Foreclosure Process says:

Looking at all the comments make me realize that we should be really careful whom we sign the mortgage deals with.

Posted On: Sunday, Sep. 7 2008 @ 7:33AM
JAVER G says:

The bottom line is that it is imperative to maintain the integrity of the court system. All the good judges are asking is that those who bring cases to their court seeking justice do so with clean hands and prove every element of their case. This way, the purchaser at the foreclosure sale can ensure that he or she is getting good title to the property, and not buying the possibility of facing a lawsuit in the future. Is this too much to ask from the justice system. I think not.

Posted On: Saturday, Sep. 13 2008 @ 10:30PM
JAVER G says:

The bottom line is that it is imperative to maintain the integrity of the court system. All the good judges are asking is that those who bring cases to their court seeking justice do so with clean hands and prove every element of their case. This way, the purchaser at the foreclosure sale can ensure that he or she is getting good title to the property, and not buying the possibility of facing a lawsuit in the future. Is this too much to ask from the justice system? I think not.

Posted On: Saturday, Sep. 13 2008 @ 10:31PM
Eric says:

No, the bottom line is that too many people buy things on credit and then worry about how they will pay for it later. They get into an Option Arm loan with a minimum payment option that increases their loan balance. Do they even read their payment coupon? NO. Did they read the details of the loan prior to signing the docs? NO. However, we are in a society where nobody takes ownership of their own actions. At http://www.dreamhomefinancing.com I see credit reports all of the time. I have seen it all. In general, people are not responsible.

Posted On: Saturday, Jan. 3 2009 @ 10:00PM
Tummy Tuck says:

Really well written!

Posted On: Tuesday, Jan. 6 2009 @ 2:18AM
danteayala says:


I'm thinking of buying a few houses on my street that have been foreclosed on and renting them out or selling them on lease purchase terms...what do you think???? :)

Posted On: Friday, Sep. 25 2009 @ 12:52AM

Write Comment


Comments may not show up immediately after submission. Please wait a minute after posting a comment for it to appear.

All reader comments are subject to our Terms of Use. By clicking "Post," you acknowledge that you have reviewed and agree to these Terms.

Tools

Search Runnin' Scared


Follow

Email tips to tips@villagevoice.com

SlideShows»

  • Bikini Burlesque (NSFW)
  • Brooklyn Taco Experiment
  • Idiotarod 2010
  • More Slideshows >>

Most …

  • Hiram Monserrate, David Paterson Still Hanging In There
  • Raj Rajaratnam's College Chum, Rajiv Goel, Pleads Guilty in Galleon Case; Another Pal Remains Defiant
  • Mayor Michael Bloomberg Warns of Power Outages During Snowstorm; Advises Flashlights, Milk
  • Michael Jackson Autopsy Reveals Thin Hair, Closed Bottle of Urine
  • David Paterson's Campaign Money Problems Only Highlight Andrew Cuomo's Good Sense
  • More Recent Entries...
  • Ruben Larios, Harlem Teen, Shot to Death in His Own Lobby (63)
  • James O'Keefe and Race: An Update (46)
  • James O'Keefe, ACORN and Landrieu Stinger, Ran Racist Forum Present at Race Debate (31)
  • Rightbloggers Share Tea Party Rage at Gov't Spending -- Until a GOP Senator Puts His Hand Out (16)
  • Tom Tancredo Kicks Off Tea Party Convention With Speech on Socialist Obama, Stupid Voters (15)
  • 7 Political Ads That Might Be Weirder Than Carly Fiorina's "Demon Sheep"
  • Jenny Sanford's Top Ten Reasons Her Husband, South Carolina Governor Mark Sanford, Is a Really Bad Person
  • James O'Keefe and Race: An Update
  • James O'Keefe is Arrested, and Rightbloggers Tell You What the Real Crime is -- The Liberal Media Coverage!
  • Rightbloggers Share Tea Party Rage at Gov't Spending -- Until a GOP Senator Puts His Hand Out

Calendar

  • Tue
    9
  • Wed
    10
  • Thu
    11
  • Fri
    12
  • Sat
    13
  • Sun
    14
  • Mon
    15
This week's best events
3 Best Things To Do on Tuesday, Feb 9
  • 20/10 Vision

    Where: Gallery Hanahou

    Type: Art

  • Fêtes de la Nuit

    Where: Ohio Theater

    Type: Off-Off-Broadway: Opening, Theater, Valentine's Day

  • The Residents

    Where: Webster Hall

    Type: Experimental

  • submit an event
  • 340 more things to do today >>

Twitter Feed

Follow Runnin' Scared on Twitter

More Twitter >>

Runnin' Scared on Digg

Services

Health & Beauty

  • VADA SPA

    View Ad | View Site
  • Contemporary Dental Implant Centre

    View Ad | View Site
  • NUTRAMEDICS INC.

    View Ad | View Site
More >>

Links

  • Village Voice
  • Wayne Barrett
  • Elizabeth Dwoskin
  • Jockbeat
  • Michael Musto
  • Tom Robbins
  • Somebody Got Murdered
  • Studies in Crap
  • New York Daily News
  • New York Post
  • New York Times
  • Newsday
  • Wall Street Journal
  • Washington Post
  • YouTube
  • Salon
  • Slate
  • Gawker
  • Huffington Post
  • Daily Kos
  • Drudge Report
  • The Daily Show
  • Colbert Report
  • Politico
  • Philadelphia Inquirer
  • Associated Press
  • Fox News
  • The Onion
  • ESPN
  • CNN
  • Time
  • Forward
  • New York
  • New Yorker
  • New York Review of Books
  • New York Observer
  • ABC News
  • CBS News
  • MSNBC
  • Newsweek
  • New York Sun
  • National Review
  • New Republic
  • Harper's
  • Atlantic
  • Vanity Fair
  • The Nation
  • Radar
  • New York Law Journal
  • Columbia Journalism Review
  • Columbia Spectator
  • Washington Square News
  • News India Times
  • Women's Wear Daily
  • Amsterdam News
  • New York Press
  • Time Out
  • IRIN
  • Indymedia
  • FAIR: Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting
  • Cryptome
  • Human Rights Watch
  • United for a Fair Economy
  • International Crisis Group
  • nola.com: New Orleans Times-Picayune
  • The New Yorker:Iraq Coverage
  • Index on Censorship
  • CounterPunch
  • Center for Contemporary Conflict
  • McClatchy D.C. Bureau
  • TomDispatch.com
  • Common Dreams News Center
  • War Report — Project on Defense Alternatives
  • Power & Interest News Report
  • Selves and Others
  • Antiwar.com
  • Johnson's Russia List
  • Energy Bulletin
  • Dry Dipstick
  • IFIWatchnet
  • Al Jazeera
  • chechnya-sl
  • Bushims
  • ACLU's Torture FOIA
  • Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty
  • National Security Archive
  • Waxman Committee
  • Ethics Daily
  • Bretton Woods Project
  • Human Rights First
  • Center for Public Integrity
  • GlobalSecurity.org
  • Institute for War & Peace Reporting
  • 9-11 Timeline
  • Iraq Body Count
  • Students for an Orwellian Society
  • Center on Budget and Policy Priorities
  • whitehouse.gov
  • whitehouse.org
About Us | Work for Village Voice | Esubscribe | Free Classifieds | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Problem With the Site? | RSS | Site Map
©2010 Village Voice Media All rights reserved.