Welcome to blogs.villagevoice.com
Blogs
  • News
    • » News Home
    • » Daily News
    • » Runnin' Scared - News Blog
    • » Tom Robbins
    • » Wayne Barrett
  • Music
    • » Music Home
    • » Top Picks
    • » Find a Bar or Club
    • » Pazz & Jop
    • » Down in Front
    • » Sound of the City
    • » Siren
    • » Submit an Event
    • » Jukebox
    • » Join Music Newsletter
    • » Entertainment Ads
  • Calendar
    • » Calendar Home
    • » Top Picks
    • » Comedy Events
    • » Submit an Event
    • » Entertainment Ads
  • Restaurants
    • » Restaurants Home
    • » Restaurant Guide
    • » Restaurant Reviews
    • » Sietsema's Counter Culture
    • » Find a Bar or Club
    • » Fork in the Road (column)
    • » Fork in the Road (blog)
    • » Sponsored Online Menus
    • » Choice Eats Tasting Event
    • » Join Dining Newsletter
    • » Restaurant Ads
    • » Happy Hours App
  •  
  • Arts
    • » Arts Home
    • » Calendar
    • » Books
    • » Theater
    • » Art
    • » Dance
    • » Obies Theater Awards
  • Films
    • » Films Home
    • » Now Showing
    • » Movie Showtimes
    • » Reviews
    • » Join NY Film Club
    • » Movie Ads
  • The Ads
    • Ad Index
    • Flip Book
    • Media Kit
    • » Fitness Health & Beauty Guide
    • » Sponsored Online Menus
  • Classifieds
    • Free Online Classifieds
    • Real Estate For Rent
    • Sexy Black Book
    • Virtual Career Fair
    • Personals
    • Real Estate for Sale
    • Place an Ad (print)
  • Blogs
    • » Runnin' Scared
    • » Sound of the City
    • » La Daily Musto
    • » Fork in the Road (blog)
    • » All City
  • Columns
    • » La Dolce Musto
    • » Tom Robbins
    • » Sex
    • » Horoscope
  • Best Of
    • » Arts & Entertainment
    • » Bars & Clubs
    • » Food & Drink
    • » People & Places
    • » Shopping & Services
    • » Sports & Recreation
    • » Best of Ads
  • Bars/Clubs
    • » Bars/Clubs Home
    • » Gay Bars & Clubs
    • » Bars/Club Ads
    • » Happy Hours App
  • Archives
    • Advanced Archive Search
    • Locations Map
    • Event Search
  • Reader Recommendations
  • Promotions
    • Street Team
    • Join The Street Team
    • Contests & Promotions
    • Text Alerts
    • Buy Village Voice Merchandise
    • Supplements Archive
  • Site Map

Top

blog

Stories

  • Overlooked and Hoberated

    J. Hoberman Responds to Armond White

    By J. Hoberman

    1
  • Lies, Damn Lies, and Statistics

    The Media's Hipster Addiction

    By Foster Kamer

    2
  • Protest

    Tea Partiers Lose Morning to Bloodfest

    By Roy Edroso

    3
  • Blowhards

    Andrew Breitbart: Pussy.

    By Foster Kamer

    4
  • Exploring the Right Wing Blogosphere

    Rightbloggers Whoop Up a Texas Re-Education

    By Roy Edroso

    5
  • Dating

    Renaissance Dating Tips: The Finale

    By Village Voice contributor

    6
  • Media

    Happy Birthday, Rupert Murdoch!

    By Foster Kamer

    7
  • Primers

    Carlos Slim: The Richest Man in the World

    By Foster Kamer

    8
  • Overlooked and Hoberated

    Proof! Critic Called for Baumbach's Abortion

    By J. Hoberman

    9
  • Politics

    Chatting with Monserrate's Spiritual Advisor

    By Steven Thrasher

    10
  • Dating

    Still More Renaissance Pick-Up Lines!

    By Village Voice contributor

    11
  • Dating

    Renaissance Pick-Up Strategies Exposed

    By Village Voice contributor

    12
  • Nanny State

    Bloomberg: Won't Somebody Please Think of The Children?

    By Roy Edroso

    13
  • Death and Taxes

    Oldest Woman in U.S. Cedes Crown

    By Foster Kamer

    14
  • Exploring the Right Wing Blogosphere

    Let's Not Politicize John Patrick Bedell, Say Rightbloggers

    By Roy Edroso

    15
 
Featured

Benedikt v. Roiphe: Is Your Facebook Profile Enforcing the Patriarchy?

By Allison Benedikt, Wednesday, May. 20 2009 @ 8:00AM
Comments (14)
Categories: Media, Technology
facebookkid.jpg
Have you been reading Double X? It's Slate's recently-launched lady web site founded by three smart women, one whose bio proclaims that she "got her start in journalism at the New Republic writing contrarian essays."

Last week Double X published Katie Roiphe's desperate cry for relevance, "Get Your Kid Off Your Facebook Page." Roiphe, you might remember, is a little famous for a book about how college girls shouldn't let themselves get raped so much. Now she's gone and written about how moms on Facebook shouldn't let themselves get raped so much -- of their identity, that is, railing against "the trend of women using photographs of their children instead of themselves as the main picture on their Facebook profiles." This will be the topic of a woman's studies seminar, "My Status Update, Myself," in the very near future.

I'll address Roiphe's central point -- that moms with kiddie profile pics are actually subjugating their own identities, setting feminism back, and acting like 1950s housewives if 1950s housewives had laptops and joined fanclubs for bacon -- in a sec, but first: Roiphe surrounds her whine with other, even-less interesting "points," including the groundbreaking, "Hey Don't You Hate Women Who Won't Stop Talking About Their Kids at Dinner Parties," and our favorite, "Hey Don't You Hate Women Who Spend All Weekend Doing Stuff With Their Kids," cause in the good old days, when moms let toddlers fend for themselves and "music class" was code for "key party," mothers "loved their kids as much as we love our children, but they had their own lives... and we played around the margins. They did not plan weekend days solely around children's concerts and art lessons and piano lessons and birthday parties."

Which couldn't have been because they didn't work during the week, and got to spend time with their kids and love them during daylight and stuff.

(Crap, I just realized: I take a music class with my son on Sundays, and they make us take off our shoes before class, so that we are BAREFOOT. What the hell, Music Class?)

OK: Facebook profile pics. Currently, mine is of my son. Which Roiphe says has something to do with me swallowing the part of myself that wrote my "senior thesis in college on Proust" and is a "brilliant and accomplished woman." Well, thank you for the compliment, Katie. I did not write my senior thesis on Proust or anything else because I guess state universities let you slide by and--fun fact--my high school didn't even have AP classes! But if I had, and if I were still identifying with my senior thesis at the age of 32 instead of the small human being I currently live with, I would certainly talk about it at dinner parties, as well as my junior year abroad and my mom Anne Roiphe.

Wait, huh? I got sidetracked. Anyway: Roiphe's is just one more chapter in the long and tired book on mothers setting aside their own needs for their kids--an evergreen that isn't necessarily untrue in every instance, but one that Roiphe has absolutely nothing new to say about, other than inserting the word "Facebook" into the argument randomly.

Katie, do you really want to know why my photo is of a baby instead of myself? Much as you think it's because, in the haze of motherhood, I've let myself go (untrue!), or am trying to be "dowdy and invisible" (why would I try to be invisible on Facebook?), or because I think I am nothing more than the mother of my child (I'm also the wife to my husband lol), it's actually because I want all the people I grew up with to see how much cuter my kid is than theirs. Also, now I do it to annoy people like you.

Comments (14) Write Comment
Share

Related Content

  • The End of the Affair: An Anthology of Lost Girls and Wounding Rifts May 17, 2005
  • Why Clinton Gets Away With It January 26, 1999
  • The Accused October 24, 2000
  • Who Stole Feminism? October 10, 2000
  • The Real Andrew Sullivan Scandal June 19, 2001

More About:

  • Katie Roiphe
  • Anne Roiphe
  • Websites
  • Science and Technology

Comments (14)

Ken Wheaton says:

The least you could do is post your SAT score instead of your baby's picture.

Posted On: Wednesday, May. 20 2009 @ 3:57PM
julia says:

I guess she didn't see mom's interview calling the demeaning of the role of mother as the root of the misogyny in our society.

That wasn't very feminist of her, now, was it.

Posted On: Wednesday, May. 20 2009 @ 4:09PM
Ren says:

God, this post was awesome.

Posted On: Wednesday, May. 20 2009 @ 4:25PM
Sally says:

Alison is in the land of "just not getting it." We get that you think it's precious that you'd post a picture of your kids as your profile photo. But if you applied for a job at my company, I would not hire you. I would be afraid you'd be too oppressive with my clients with your parenting preciousness with no sense of self-reflection. You know, if your teenage son put your picture as his profile picture, you'd think something was wrong. If your husband put your face as his profile face, people would think he's a wuss. A kid's face as your profile photo is as adorable as your kid leaving your outgoing voice mail message. People who do that are drunk with their own preciousness and Roiphe wrote about these people. Guess it cut too close to you. A grown adult woman should be confident enough to use her own face.

Posted On: Wednesday, May. 20 2009 @ 9:38PM
mommalita says:

but my kid is cuter than i am!

Posted On: Wednesday, May. 20 2009 @ 10:54PM
wtf says:

i use my dog's photo

Posted On: Wednesday, May. 20 2009 @ 10:57PM
Kara says:

Excellent news, Sally, as I would definitely want to avoid working for you.

BTW, Facebook is not the same thing as Linked-In. Ask your long-suffering assistant to explain the difference.

Posted On: Wednesday, May. 20 2009 @ 11:09PM
mattymatt says:

But what are the implications for people whose profile pictures are of their pets?

Posted On: Thursday, May. 21 2009 @ 3:19AM
ilovebalk says:

I use an unflattering picture of Madonna as my profile picture. I've clearly run right off the rails.

Posted On: Thursday, May. 21 2009 @ 8:51AM
Ugh says:

So I guess I was wrong to think that Facebook is not the sole reason for my existence and everything posted there is not the genuine reflecion of who I am in the real world, instead of just an online fishbowl where I can stalk old friends? IF I weren't too busy actually living in the real world instead of analyzing what my facebook profile says about me, I might cry.

Posted On: Thursday, May. 21 2009 @ 9:51AM
Groovymarlin says:

Roiphe comes of as entirely humorless, scary, and very full of herself. Great response to her diatribe. So far, XX is turning out to be sadly lame!

I know several MEN who use pictures of their baby or other kids as their profile picture. What does that say about them, Roiphe? Jeez.

Posted On: Thursday, May. 21 2009 @ 11:33AM
Realist says:

My LinkedIn profile uses a pic of me and my cat precisely so I can avoid wasting my time on potential employers like Sally. My credentials and record speak for themselves. If you're put off by a picture with a cat, you're just the kind of asshole I don't care to work for anyway.

Posted On: Saturday, May. 23 2009 @ 3:44PM
Michel Hait says:

Hehe, wirklich gut. Komme nun auch öfters.

Posted On: Thursday, Jan. 21 2010 @ 12:15AM
Judith Melbert says:

Interessante Idee und übrigens auch geile Homepage.

Posted On: Thursday, Jan. 21 2010 @ 12:15AM

Write Comment


Comments may not show up immediately after submission. Please wait a minute after posting a comment for it to appear.

All reader comments are subject to our Terms of Use. By clicking "Post," you acknowledge that you have reviewed and agree to these Terms.

Tools

Search Runnin' Scared


Follow

Email tips to tips@villagevoice.com

SlideShows»

  • Smell the Glove Party
  • Driven by Boredom's 9 Year Anniversary Party (NSFW)
  • Late-Night at the Shank
  • More Slideshows >>

Most …

  • Something That Begins With 'Wiki' At Fault for Military Failings, Apprently
  • Bernie Madoff: Punked by a Black Belt in Judo, Mel Gibson Fan, Giving Financial Advice
  • NYC's Ed Nortons Score Sewer Deal
  • Remembering Groovy, the Murdered Hippie
  • I # NY: LCD Soundsystem vs. Michael Musto?
  • More Recent Entries...
  • Is the Media's "Hipster" Grifting Soon to End? (28)
  • Rightbloggers Find New Texas School Curriculum a Boon to Re-Education (27)
  • Bruce Asante, 29, Stabbed and Killed in the Bronx (22)
  • Game On, Part 4: The Courtier's Last Stand (12)
  • If Armond White Only Knew What a Monster J. Hoberman Really Is... (11)
  • Shady Mexican Dude Named Slim Now the Richest Man in the World: A Primer
  • Is the Media's "Hipster" Grifting Soon to End?
  • Proof That Critic Armond White Did Call for Noah Baumbach's Abortion
  • Anthony Weiner, Senators Call for End to Ban on Gay Men Donating Blood
  • If Armond White Only Knew What a Monster J. Hoberman Really Is...

Twitter Feed

Follow villagevoice on Twitter

More Twitter >>

VVM on Digg

  • 5
    diggs
    West Hollywood Councilman Backs Full Legalization Of Pot
  • 1
    diggs
    SouZouCreations: Japanese Food Rings - Orange County - Slide
  • 1
    diggs
    U.S. Rep. With Auto Industry Ties Blames Victim In Toyota...
  • 2
    diggs
    R.I.P. Alex Chilton
  • 1
    diggs
    Ugly Meg Whitman, eBay billionaire, was a hottie! Video
  • 97
    diggs
    That Guy Holding His D*ck on ChatRoulette is Probably a Cop
  • 2
    diggs
    Cannabis Quote Of The Day: Ralph Waldo Emerson
  • 123
    diggs
    Marijuana Grow Houses Lead to a Frozen Body in Florida
  • 1
    diggs
    Top 10 Kit Kat Flavors You've Probably Never Tried
  • 1
    diggs
    First Listen: Mike Patton's Italo-Pop Opus 'Mondo Cane'
  • 151
    diggs
    Alex Chilton Of Big Star Dies In New Orleans
  • 347
    diggs
    Blockbuster Fights Bankruptcy: A Lost Cause?
  • 185
    diggs
    Teacher Arrested For Encouraging Teen Fights
  • 165
    diggs
    Fat People Are Making Us Into Fat People
  • 386
    diggs
    23-Year-Old Man Tries To Rob 63-Year-Old & Gets A Black Eye
  • 234
    diggs
    Top Five TV Themes Ripe for Mashup
  • 322
    diggs
    Is Cocaine to Blame for Global Warming?
  • 429
    diggs
    Teacher Stabs Student 7 Times for Farting
  • 328
    diggs
    Cop cheats death when drunk driver rear ends car during stop
  • 259
    diggs
    City of San Jose Shuts Down Medical Pot Clubs
  • 8774
    diggs
    Legalization of Marijuana Bill in California
  • 5801
    diggs
    Guess Who is Facing 21 Years in Prison?
  • 5051
    diggs
    Guys Dates Several Prostitutes. No Sex. Just Regular Dates.
  • 4605
    diggs
    Get Up, Stand Up: Ammiano Introduces Marijuana Legalization
  • 3753
    diggs
    Denver Airports Controversial 32 FT Zombie Mustang Sculpture
  • 3741
    diggs
    Guy Dumps His Cheating Girlfriend Live on Radio (Audio)
  • 2720
    diggs
    Meet Scientology's Worst Enemy
  • 2694
    diggs
    Decision Tree: Should I Buy an iPad? (PIC)
  • 2631
    diggs
    The best (PIC) of Colin Powell you'll see today.
  • 2589
    diggs
    Police Get The Wrong House In Galveston, Assault 12-Year old

Links

  • Village Voice
  • Wayne Barrett
  • Elizabeth Dwoskin
  • Jockbeat
  • Michael Musto
  • Tom Robbins
  • Somebody Got Murdered
  • Studies in Crap
  • New York Daily News
  • New York Post
  • New York Times
  • Newsday
  • Wall Street Journal
  • Washington Post
  • YouTube
  • Salon
  • Slate
  • Gawker
  • Huffington Post
  • Daily Kos
  • Drudge Report
  • The Daily Show
  • Colbert Report
  • Politico
  • Philadelphia Inquirer
  • Associated Press
  • Fox News
  • The Onion
  • ESPN
  • CNN
  • Time
  • Forward
  • New York
  • New Yorker
  • New York Review of Books
  • New York Observer
  • ABC News
  • CBS News
  • MSNBC
  • Newsweek
  • New York Sun
  • National Review
  • New Republic
  • Harper's
  • Atlantic
  • Vanity Fair
  • The Nation
  • Radar
  • New York Law Journal
  • Columbia Journalism Review
  • Columbia Spectator
  • Washington Square News
  • News India Times
  • Women's Wear Daily
  • Amsterdam News
  • New York Press
  • Time Out
  • IRIN
  • Indymedia
  • FAIR: Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting
  • Cryptome
  • Human Rights Watch
  • United for a Fair Economy
  • International Crisis Group
  • nola.com: New Orleans Times-Picayune
  • The New Yorker:Iraq Coverage
  • Index on Censorship
  • CounterPunch
  • Center for Contemporary Conflict
  • McClatchy D.C. Bureau
  • TomDispatch.com
  • Common Dreams News Center
  • War Report — Project on Defense Alternatives
  • Power & Interest News Report
  • Selves and Others
  • Antiwar.com
  • Johnson's Russia List
  • Energy Bulletin
  • Dry Dipstick
  • IFIWatchnet
  • Al Jazeera
  • chechnya-sl
  • Bushims
  • ACLU's Torture FOIA
  • Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty
  • National Security Archive
  • Waxman Committee
  • Ethics Daily
  • Bretton Woods Project
  • Human Rights First
  • Center for Public Integrity
  • GlobalSecurity.org
  • Institute for War & Peace Reporting
  • 9-11 Timeline
  • Iraq Body Count
  • Students for an Orwellian Society
  • Center on Budget and Policy Priorities
  • whitehouse.gov
  • whitehouse.org
About Us | Work for Village Voice | Esubscribe | Free Classifieds | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Problem With the Site? | RSS | Site Map
©2010 Village Voice, LLC. All rights reserved.