Daily Voice «

update notifications

email

subscribe
unsubscribe

categories

Is T.I. an Idiot?

Posted by Tom Breihan at 5:15 PM, October 15, 2007

ti_vs_tip_album.jpg
Machine gun funk

So I got married a few days ago. It was awesome. I recommend it. I'm not going to turn into one of those people who writes a ton of stuff on his blog about his wedding, but a quick note about this: Don't think you can hire a wedding DJ and control him. You can't. You'll be having too much fun to care anyway. Also: if your wedding gets shut down by police, you probably had a pretty badass wedding, especially if they actually threaten to cart your father-in-law off to jail. Extended Irish families throw down.

But so back to this music-blogging thing. A couple of nights before my wedding, I couldn't sleep, so I did the thing where I haul my laptop into bed and click around on random blogs until I get tired enough to fall asleep. On this particular night, a few people had posted the new video for T.I.'s "Hurt." I watched it. This turned out to be a mistake. "Hurt" is the sort of rap video that nobody makes anymore: no girls, no money, no cars, lots of dudes in ski-masks in a dank bombed-out warehouse waving chains at unsteady black-and-white camera, jump-cuts every half-second, three or more rappers compete to see who has the craziest facial expressions. This is my favorite kind of rap video. And so after watching "Hurt" I couldn't fall asleep for another couple of hours because I got all amped and had to keep watching it over and over. Empty oilcans. Dry-ice fog curling up. T.I., giant link-chain draped over his tiny shoulders, brandishing a baseball bat even though the song is about guns. Alfamega, ski-mask over jagged face, looming motionless while a slow-mo crowd bugs out around him. Cameos from rappers, only about half of whom I recognize. Busta Rhymes grinning maniacally through a bloodthirsty double-time verse. I love this stuff. On T.I. Vs. T.I.P., "Hurt" was a clear standout, a short moment when the album's concept actually came to life and T.I. really seemed to be giving free reign to his knucklehead side before reigning himself back in. With the video, it becomes something more: a snarling spitting heaving monster of a track, a well-timed reminder that T.I. and Busta still have this sort of ferocity in them, a great general-audience introduction for Alfamega. T.I. cedes the spotlight to two vastly superior guest-verses but still looks smart in associating himself with these guys. And when Alfamega's verse is on, I catch flashback's to Freddie Foxxx's firebreathing tirade on Gang Starr's "The Militia." It's worth noting that all three singles from T.I. vs. T.I.P. have come from the T.I.P. side of the album, an interesting indication that T.I.'s tough side and his pop side are basically the same thing. And it's weird that it took him this long to figure out that broken glass and chains are much better ways of declaring your toughness than taking a private jet to Haiti to hang out with the bad guy from Shottas.

I was planning on writing about the "Hurt" video today anyway, but then this morning brought the news that T.I. had been arrested in Atlanta for some really serious federal gun changes, charges that could send him to prison for ten years and effectively end his career. The ATF's story goes that T.I. sent a bodyguard to buy three machine guns and two silencers. T.I. is a convicted felon, and so he can't legally own any guns, let alone unregistered machine guns like these ones. The bodyguard cooperated with agents, and ATF agents arrested T.I. when the bodyguard made the delivery. T.I. almost certainly has a team of insanely good lawyers at his disposal, and hopefully all this will turn out to be an aggressively prosecuted misunderstanding. Still, if the charges do turn out to be true, I am going to be disappointed as fuck. Because how dumb do you have to be? You're one of the world's most popular rappers, you just became maybe the first Southern rapper to headline Madison Square Garden, you sell millions of records during a time when nobody buys records, you have bodyguards, you're a convicted felon on probation, and you know full well that police make it a point to follow rappers around and make arrests on the thinnest shreds of evidence, and you still send some chump to buy your machine guns? How dumb do you have to be? This comes a couple of days after Prodigy, the guy who made my favorite rap album of the year, accepted a three-and-a-half year charge for criminal gun possession and a few months after Lil Wayne, my favorite rapper right now, got arrested in New York on similar charges. Too many of the rappers I like are risking prison-time for dumb and avoidable offenses (seriously, bodyguards), and all of a sudden it's distressingly apparent that "Hurt" is a song about killing you, something I'd realized but not altogether recognized before today. Before today, it was easy to focus on the details, like the badass way Alfamega mispronounces Sayonara ("Sarra-nara!"). After the arrest, it's harder to ignore the fact that I'm listening to millionaires bragging about their guns, and now the "Hurt" video doesn't seem like quite the triumph it was when I woke up this morning. Ideally, the divide between persona and personality, between theatrical displays of bravado and actual threats of violence, should be wide enough to keep a song like this from getting too problematic. For whatever reason, though, even the richest and most successful rappers seem to be having trouble leaving their old lives behind. It would be ridiculous and reactionary to suddenly stop liking "Hurt" because the guy who made the song got arrested for buying guns. But context matters.

Unrelated: RIP Big Moe. Sad day.

Voice review: Katie Hintz on T.I.'s T.I. Vs. T.I.P.
Voice review: Makkada B. Selah on T.I.'s King
Voice review: Keith Harris on T.I.'s Urban Legend

comments

blame it on t.i.p.

also:
r.i.p. barre baby

Posted by: manimar at October 15, 2007 5:47 PM

You can take the idiot out off the village, but you can't take the village out of the idiot. I mean seriously, it's getting harder and harder to defend the music I once loved. It's dark and hell is hot.

Posted by: Peter Truth at October 15, 2007 5:58 PM

Fill this under "Oh, like you've never wanted to kill somebody!?!?!"

I'm the first person to call celebs out for DUI raps when they have enough cash to start a limo company and comp themselves, but...

I don't think you should let this situation taint the video for you. It's a catch-22... We call people out for being studio gangstas and not knowing the streets, not meaning what they say, not having lived what they claim to have lived. If that's fair, how do we then call someone out for having a song/video about wanting to kill someone and actually wanting to kill someone. Some comedian (I think it was Martin Lawrence) did a bit about this: I ain't sayin' it's right... but I understand. Sometimes people cross the line. Sometimes you tell 'em they crossed the line and they listen to you and remember their role. And sometimes not. It sounds like T.I.P. isn't the only hard-headed person T.I. knows...

Posted by: ondioline at October 15, 2007 6:47 PM

i hear ya Tom. as someone who doesn't buy into the blanket "freedom of speech!" defense, as if music doesn't have an impact on pop culture, certain hip hop i like right now is kinda hard to defend as responsible. and when shit like this happens the line between "oh it's just music, chill" and reality becomes even more blurred than it already is in rap.

on an only slightly-related note, i'll be expectin' in-depth thoughts on what the Jay-Z/Lil Wayne American Gangster collabo will be like tomorrow. at 3PM. sharp. nah kiddin', i was surprised when i saw that today though.

Posted by: T.R.E.Y. at October 16, 2007 1:29 AM

oh and i disagree Tip got murked on that song. Busta went harder than him, but their verses are pretty close, and i thought alfalfa leaves was the weakest one on there. even though he still goes hard.

Posted by: T.R.E.Y. at October 16, 2007 1:30 AM

yeah, this shit is painful to me, as a young black man and as a hip-hop head. i think the best reaction that i've read or heard to date was from miss info: she said something to the effect that t.i. hasn't hurt anybody with these weapons, but for a man to be so paranoid as to think that he needs that much firepower just to survive is sad, and truly no way to live..i wish the music could just be music, and i pray for the day when creative production from america's underclass doesn't have to live what it's reporting. i mean fuck, nobody's emptying clips on governator arnold, or questioning his macho cred. meanwhile, 50 moves into the CT. estate befitting a pop star, and gets called out for not showin his face in the hood. kanye avoid this dumb shit altogether and gets called a fag. damn i hate what hip hop's become, and what this country's made it. guess i'll wait for aaron mcgruder to parody this nonsense, so i can laugh and cry along with the absurdity.

Posted by: jtilla at October 16, 2007 6:14 AM

congratulations!

good call on freddie foxxx. had completely forgotten about that guy.

Posted by: Ass Hat at October 16, 2007 7:37 AM

So, the moral of the story is that rappers are astoundingly fucking stupid alot of the time. That's some really earth-shattering stuff man. So, when you mix lots of money and lots of ignorance together what do you get? A whole lot of felony charges and another idiot ruined rapper to laugh about. Way to go dumbass. Maybe he and Michael Vick can have a good long cathartic cry together about how they both ruined their pretty much perfect fucking lives because they both have shit for brains. Man, what are all the loser parasites in his entourage gonna do when T.I. goes to prison. They might just have to go back to drug trafficking to make ends meet.

Posted by: Panthro at October 16, 2007 1:26 PM

"Don't think you can hire a wedding DJ and control him. You can't. You'll be having too much fun to care anyway."

As a dj, your earlier post on the subject annoyed the shit out of me. I'm glad to hear that the dj didn't take your instructions to mix "Sippin' on Some Sizzurp" into The White Stripes, or whatever. Don't mean to sound snarky, but you gotta let a dj do his thing sometimes.

Posted by: Crimson at October 16, 2007 5:42 PM

yes, he is an idiot, but you have to remember...money don't buy brains, class or common sense. he's still the same pitifully undereducated kid he was before the millions. the hood mentality is formed out of poverty, desperation and lack of opportunity. this is why people like him and michael vick stay on the hood shit even when it's no longer necessary for survival. it's a mindset that is formed in childhood and is very hard to break later. only when america stops subjecting millions of its kids to crap ghetto schools will these stories stop ending in tragedy.

Posted by: spineofsnake at October 16, 2007 6:03 PM

yes, he is an idiot, but you have to remember...money don't buy brains, class or common sense. he's still the same pitifully undereducated kid he was before the millions. the hood mentality is formed out of poverty, desperation and lack of opportunity. this is why people like him and michael vick stay on the hood shit even when it's no longer necessary for survival. it's a mindset that is formed in childhood and is very hard to break later. only when america stops subjecting millions of its kids to crap ghetto schools will these stories stop ending in tragedy.

Posted by: spineofsnake at October 16, 2007 6:04 PM

Panthro, ya really oughta get out more man.

Posted by: T.R.E.Y. at October 16, 2007 10:10 PM

In my opinion this kind of self-destructive behavior can't be excused. I know that videos and music like this can be fun and we all feel this way sometimes. I'm not willing to call TI an idiot for being unable to escape his background. It just spells out that there need to be changes. If his career ends like this, setting a negative example, maybe something good will come of it. I think we all want music to reflect real life, and like jtilla says rappers are looked at for how close their lyrics match their reality. The lyrics maybe need to change, but the reality definitely does. I honestly feel sorry for TI but I can't be mad about this or blame it on anyone else. The music needs to change, but more importantly the lifestyle needs to change. Until this kind of behavior is no longer glorified we'll see talented people throw their lives away. Yes, blame society if you must, but we ARE society. We ask for this, and then we say, "Oh ummm, sorry, didn't really want you to do it for real".
Right now this is where we're at, but it doesn't have to stay this way.

Posted by: tshirtlevis at October 21, 2007 5:04 AM

Personally I was embarrassed for him. Especially after he got up on T.V. on Hip Hop Vs. America talking about what he COULD be doing as if he's no longer doing it. It's either he's lying or he's not. If the thought even crossed his mind to prove to America that he means what he says when he did it then his is an idiot and he as his crazy. If this is the case then he was surely zoned out to the point of no return in his image. This is what people are talking about. He made a very clear example of what every person against Hip Hop is saying which really fucked my head up. In the midst of all these arguments about Hip Hop's relation to gangs and violence he goes and makes himself look like a pure idiot. It was a slap in the face. But our culture has been through worse so let's not be too hard on him.

Though the guns were uncalled for and out of line, they did carry some impact for the "Hurt" video. No one can look at the video the same way now. One can truly believe that shit T.I. is talking about. I just hope it was geered towards LIL FLIP and not me. LOL!

Posted by: 7bornbuild at October 27, 2007 10:51 PM

lööve T.I.!!!!

Posted by: LövMusic at December 27, 2007 5:03 PM

love you TI

Posted by: Ranaas@pea at December 29, 2007 5:08 PM

ommggg
im lyk repeating da same shit ovr n ovr n diiff. syts :P:P
man i tottaally agree wid Tom.
juss a moment ago we r all *inlove* wid t.i's vicious raapp n den we go lyk, naw da guyz all messed up juss cause he got into sum nasty shit?? cum on ya'll we're his fanz stickk up fo da man!!
i noe im lyk da gr8st fan evr :P lool at least in da middle east!! i luvv daa guy big tym n i wud b soo fuckn pissd to c him lose dis casE!!! :(:(

Posted by: §нaωτiз веııaıicου§ at January 2, 2008 10:04 AM

Hi

Posted by: Anonymous at January 4, 2008 1:57 PM

hey cutie i must say your are one of my top cute rappers and just wanted to show my love to you so please write to mail to know you got these massage

Posted by: angilenia padilla at January 10, 2008 7:36 PM

hey cutie i must say your are one of my top cute rappers and just wanted to show my love to you so please write to mail to know you got these massage

Posted by: angilenia padilla at January 10, 2008 7:37 PM

hey cutie i must say your are one of my top cute rappers and just wanted to show my love to you so please write to mail to know you got these massage

Posted by: angilenia padilla at January 10, 2008 7:37 PM

T.I. is my favorite rapper and i love him to death

Posted by: helen at January 24, 2008 9:28 AM

fuck u

Posted by: Anonymous at February 6, 2008 6:34 PM

DONT EVER N YO LYFE DISRESPECT T.I

Posted by: mrs harris at December 2, 2008 1:49 PM

wat up luv frm abubakar, dont touch it,dont think, just hav it u are d born and d best. never mind wat haters say ignor dem til they dead away

Posted by: zeey at January 4, 2009 1:30 PM

luv u t.i. frm abubakar

Posted by: zeey at January 4, 2009 1:33 PM

post a comment

All reader comments are subject to our Terms of Use. By clicking "Post", you acknowledge that you have reviewed and agree to these Terms.




Remember Me?
(you may use HTML tags for style)
 

Most Popular