Daily Voice «

update notifications

email

subscribe
unsubscribe

categories

Metal Will Own 2008

Posted by Tom Breihan at 4:03 PM, January 24, 2008

disfear.jpg
A testament! Born out of desperation!

Well, this is convenient. It took a while for any really good 2008 albums to finally hit retail shelves; the winter doldrums are a bitch that way. But two albums that came out on Tuesday finally ended the drought, and both of them work variations on a crusty old-school metal aesthetic. My favorite metal albums of 2007 all depended, on one way or another, on some form of prog-rock frippery: Baroness's searching sludgy bong-rock, Jesu's depressive emo/shoegaze dreamscapes, Watain's icy classicist ambience. When bands manage to make that fantastical pretension work for them, the results can be stunning, as they are on all three of those albums. But I really love the way both Saviours and Disfear manage to strip all that away, concentrating on rhythmic pummel and riff-centric propulsion rather than virtuosic meditations on their own despair or whatever. Both bands play styles of metal that've been done to death by scores of other bands in decades past, but both find ways to inject life and purpose and urgency into those forms. This is utilitarian stuff; neither band does a whole lot to challenge anyone. But after a month of absolutely nothing, it comes as blessed relief to hear both bands vengefully plying their trades. Even though Saviours' Into Abaddon and Disfear's Live the Storm are two vastly different albums from two vastly different bands, I'm going to have a tough time thinking of them as separate parts of a crushingly rewarding whole.

Saviours, an Oakland-based stoner quartet, often get derided as being hipster-metal, which is fair enough: like their Kemado labelmates the Sword, they lean hard on unrepentantly retro 70s boogie-metal riffage, keeping their tempos somewhere between doomy plod and power-metal gallop. And as with the Sword, it's easy to imagine the band finding an audience outside the extreme-metal diehard set. For this band, the riff is everything. Vocals tend to disappear from their songs for long stretches, and anyway the vocals and drums and bass are almost always buried in the mix, making room for a whole lot of guitars. Those guitars are big and chunky and repetitive, and when they lock into a groove, they devastate. But Saviours like to pull the same trick as Mastodon often does: rather than playing actual songs with structures and choruses and stuff, they settle into geometric patterns and then, without warning, switch up their time-signatures and lurch off into some other groove. It always sort of throws me off when they abandon one beat for another; it's hard to get comfortable listening to the band. But they don't bash you over the head with their technical proficiency; when the solos come, they're brief and perfunctory and refreshingly short on show-offy virtuosity. I'm willing to bet actual money that one of the songs on Into Abaddon ends up in Guitar Hero 4; the band has a right mix of rhythmic repetition and structural unpredictability pretty much perfect for that game. Listening to Into Abaddon, I can't close my eyes without picturing colored dots flying at me.

But as intuitively heavy as Into Abaddon might be, it's got nothing on the glorious adrenaline-rush intensity of Live the Storm. Disfear is a Swedish hardcore band that's been around for just about forever. They broke up for a while in the late 90s before returning a few years ago, with former At the Gates frontman and melodic death-metal OG Tomas Lindberg now fronting them. For this album, they've added a former Entombed guitarist to their ranks. But even if two members of the band have their roots in hyper-technical death-metal, Disfear stays on some greasy simplistic biker-rock shit, rarely leaving room for guitar-wheedles or breakdowns. The obvious precedents here are Motorhead and Discharge; the tempos are fast and hammering, the guitars hyper-distorted and vaguely scary, the indulgent moments nonexistent. Lindberg's kept his scorching yowl firmly intact, and this album makes an argument that the standard death-metal Cookie Monster growl sounds a whole lot better on music that isn't death-metal. Half the choruses on the album are basement-show gang-chant shoutalongs, as catchy and fun as they are punishing and intimidating. The guitars sometimes shift into triumphal In Flames mode, but the band's lower-register rumble prevents them from ever getting cheesy. Converge guitarist Kurt Ballou produces, and he gives Disfear his own band's cinematic skree, walking a thin line between compressed thud and grimy squall. And so Live the Storm brings just about everything I could possibly want from a metal album: pick-slides, dense and rumbling riffs, Ted Nugent caveman-solos, youth-crew call-and-response chants, epic pseudo-tribal drumming, vein-popping screams, incomprehensible lyrics that seem to be about staying true to yourself, song-lengths that generally stay in the three-minute range. Hooks. This thing absolutely slays, and I sort of can't believe it exists.

comments

"I sort of can't believe it exists" - I sort of think this about any music I like (or anything artistic), the line between something awesome being created and not is that vanishingly thin...

anyway, I'd like to hear these records.

Posted by: Richard at January 24, 2008 7:04 PM

Bit of a typo in the title, I think you meant 1988, since no one gives a rat's ass about metal anymore. Barely anyone give's a rat's ass about hip hop anymore either, but at least I read it when you write about it. This I won't even bother with.

Posted by: MK at January 24, 2008 8:00 PM

Thanks for a review of something that's "outside of the box". Much appreciated!

Posted by: BB at January 25, 2008 6:31 AM

"No one gives a rat's ass about metal anymore"? Wow, congratulations on announcing to the world that you have absolutely no idea what you're talking about. Here's an idea: go see Slayer the next time they come to town, you might learn something.

Posted by: mjhk75 at January 25, 2008 8:13 AM

Gawd - with this kind of crap and hipsters with thier obligatory cartoon-festooned arms infecting the genre, it's no wonder no one gives a crap about metal anymore. Hardcore is not Metal; prog-rock is not Metal; death/black metal is sped-up punk rock and not Metal. Motorhead is Metal. Three Inches of Blood is Metal. Dragonforce is Metal. Iron Maiden and Priest are Metal. The Sword and Mastodon are Fisher-Price punks.

Posted by: Pat from Austin at January 25, 2008 10:58 AM

"Barely anyone gives a rat's ass about metal anymore"?

Way to have your finger on the pulse of music there, MK.

Posted by: Richard at January 25, 2008 12:41 PM

1. Plenty of people care about metal. Read Decibel magazine if you want to grow your awareness of extreme music in an educated manner.
2. Stating what is and what is not metal is decidedly not metal. Personally, I think corpse paint is downright silly. But someone else may think that Cam Pipes screaming about orcs and castles is silly (I don't..big 3ioB fan, but also love Mastodon, Isis, 3, Nile, Machine Head, yadda yadda yadda). To each his own, and move on.
3. No real need for a third point here, but I have a Monk-like complex about rounding out lists, so hence, a placeholder.

Posted by: Sandeep at January 25, 2008 1:44 PM

If this shit is gonna own 2008, then 2008 is going to be a very average year.

Posted by: pussyctrl at January 25, 2008 2:47 PM

Slayer? Wow, is that some hot new metal band? I've never heard of them. I bet they're about to inject the sort of excitement into the metal world that will totally prove my statement wrong.

Perhaps I should have said no one beyond a cadre of largely unwashed fanatics gives a rat's ass about metal. It's kind of like musical radical Islam. I like heavy music both old (Motorhead) and new (the new Black Mountain is good, but not really metal), but to act like metal has some sort of cultural capital in 2008 that it clearly doesn't is just ridiculous.

Posted by: MK at January 25, 2008 6:22 PM

Blog post titles are definitely serious business.

Posted by: Joseph at January 25, 2008 10:08 PM

Man, people suck when it comes to metal.. Everyone creams their pants when you mention Mastodon, and they're boring. Metalheads in the 2000s are like punk rockers in the 1990s. The music is boring, repetitive, and derivative of far superior stuff from an earlier time; but that's OK, because it's not really about the music anyway - it's about the scene. And that's fine, I'll just keep my ears out for the diamonds in the rough (Boris) and ignore the rest.

Posted by: The Future at January 26, 2008 3:07 AM

Funny, I didn't realize that only music approved by clean-cut intellectuals (as opposed to "unwashwed fanatics") was worth writing or reading about. If I ever get to the point where I start judging music by how much "cultural capital" it has, please, feel free to shoot me.

Slayer are just one example out of many metal bands who have fanbases as rabid and loyal as any band in any genre, so to act like no one gives a rat's ass about metal anymore is just ridiculous. There's no need for an injection of excitement into the metal world, there's plenty already there if you bother to look.

Posted by: mjhk75 at January 27, 2008 4:14 PM

Wow. All of you are idiots.

I'm hesitant to give creedance to any metal article ever, because most people who write about metal are either A)humorless or B)Have shitty taste.

Newsflash: Indie rock doesn't matter, as does rock or any other form of music not on the radio. Tastes are ridiculously compartmentalized and iPod-shuffled this decade, and scenes are perfectly fine in their respective areas. Metal, both shitty mainstream metal on Headbangers Ball, great underground metal, and trite hipster metal being fapped about (Baroness sucks, LOL. So did "Blood Mountain")

TO question the "cultural capital" of any genre is to have your head up your ass and still think somehow it's the 90's. It isn't, and metal, because of the clueless investment in the sanitized kind or ironic kind by the hardcore scene/indie scene the last few years, is maintaining and surprisingly gaining a degree of exposure.

Oh, and the "1988" comment was cute, despite how huge metal was in the early to mid 90's. Way to be accurate.

Posted by: Chris at January 28, 2008 1:28 AM

ISIS play music so slow I couldn't wait for the songs to start! 3 minutes into the start of their songs only sounds like something more exciting will happen soon but I gave up and played some other video. Isis starts off slow and quiet and maybe they stay that way, for all I know!, They might as well be zombies!Boooooorrring!!!

Posted by: SNAP at January 29, 2008 4:34 PM

I'm really sorry I used a big words, I forgot I was talking to metal fans. Cultural capital just means how important something is in society (Angelina Jolie has a lot, Kathy Griffin has none). So when Tom said Metal Will Own 2008, that was an intertubes-friendly way of saying that metal will have a significant amount of cultural capital in 2008. He's wrong, but that's what he meant. On the bright side, now you two have learned something, and that probably hasn't happened in a long time.

And to clarify, I wasn't judging metal on how much cultural capital it has, I was judging it by how much it sucks (a lot) and also saying that it will continue to have little influence on culture outside of dudes with dragons on their shirts.

Posted by: MK at January 30, 2008 5:39 AM

Um, neither At the Gates nor Entombed were "hyper-technical," or even very technical at all.

Posted by: AB at January 30, 2008 12:05 PM

metal may suck (it doesn't) but to say it doesn't have cultural capital is dumb. popular artists now as always scavenge what's easily sold, and nothing's easier right now than emoting. the histrionics displayed by Fall Out Boy (whose cultural capital is at least at Jolie levels) and their own imitators demonstrate this. this lot ape what they lack, that same what Slayer fans have to spare: personal investment in their choice of music. that's why metal is even more relevant now in 08 - if you're not a poser, you're metal for life, thus your pockets are always open. If that loyalty can be transferred to other genres, maybe the record industry won't die. Problem is, you can't fake it.

Posted by: KM at January 30, 2008 1:06 PM

I can't really pay too much attention with a snide little biased internet troll with his mouth securely fastened on his own cock. I'm not copping out, I'm saying you're fucking stupid. I do appreciate your ability to use Internet Condescension at Level 4. That was impressive.

I'd write a long diatribe, but the fact that you pigeonhole metal as "dragons" and etc kind of advertises how laughably incorrect and unaware you are. You also don't seem that intelligent, as you think "cultural captial" is a "big word". There should be a literacy test on Briehan's blog comments, your lack of comprehension behind your billowing veil of crapulence is a bit distressing.

No, you aren't talking to "metal fans", you're talking to music fans that know more than you. And please, shrug off into your irony bin accordingly, or head to lastfm and pitch your cliches if you really need your e-dick massaged so badly.

Though, I guess I would think metal sucked too if, like you, I only knew about Dragonforce. LOLZ@deriding genres and not bands.

Posted by: Chris at January 30, 2008 8:56 PM

If not paying attention to me means writing a short, 4 paragraph diatribe then I think I understand why you don't get jokes. I get it, you have some personal attachments to the music, but don't act like "mainstream" metal means the actual mainstream. I've listened to lots of metal (enough, anyway) and I like some bands, mostly older stuff, because a lot of it sounds silly to me, even though they all seem so serious, GWAR notwithstanding.

I love Social Distortion but I'd never act like they've even remotely distorted any society lately. They're a relic, but I love their music and their fans are some of the most devoted and inviting I've ever seen. But they're not mainstream like Fergie or Soulja Boy (two of the worst offenders)and I don't act like they are. There's still a lot of people who love metal but as "The Future" mentioned, it's as vital as punk rock.

I'm making fun of metal because it takes itself too seriously, and reacting like that only makes it easier. I love hip hop too, but when Tom's next column talks about the new Timbaland-produced Jay-Z song with DJ Clue yelling over it I'm sure there'll be opportunities to make jokes wondering if it's 1998 again. Bill Clinton was bombing Iraq, Jay-Z looks like a camel, Timbaland was the size of a tank but not built like one yet, etc. etc.

Posted by: MK at January 31, 2008 7:42 PM

As a person who has gone through the pains of being "out of touch" for listening to music as a teenager that came out when i was two years old, to having to defend the concept of metal as a twentysomething, all i can say is that most people don't get it. it is all metal. death metal is metal. black metal, doom, sludge, grindcore, it is all the same.

heavy metal is dead. there is no room for innovation there. but metal is not, go to a fucking local show and watch these kids play. for every unearth there are kids playing music like atheist. don't worry about subcultures, who your references are, what you are wearing, just get to a show and experience nothing short of total liberation. and bang your head, because that is what we do.

Posted by: Joe (fuck anonymity) at February 1, 2008 3:37 PM

Why any metal fan is getting upset over what boytoy MK says is beyond me. Since metal came to be, most people have a: never understood it and b: derided it. And we LIKE it that way. It's music for outsiders, and the more people that hate it the better. They can stick to their shitty hip-hop and post-avant-garde-"rock". I'm glad someone else digs Disfear.

Posted by: Snake at February 2, 2008 6:12 PM


Actually, "cultural capital" means nothing of the kind. It's a term derived from Bourdieu's sociology, & you can go look it up, nerd bear!

Idiots who claim to know what metal is or is not, idiots who think their value judgments are universal, & idiots who think a given genre is played out depending on whether it rules the charts (this goes both ways: there are idiots who dismiss country because it's popular & idiots who dismiss metal because it's not) are boring. Boring idiots in Idiotland, boring each other.

Posted by: Murk at February 12, 2008 8:46 PM

"Actually, "cultural capital" means nothing of the kind. It's a term derived from Bourdieu's sociology"

Duh, retard. I dumbed it down so metalheads could understand. And since this is all so boring that you felt compelled to comment 2 weeks after the fact, maybe you can comment again a year or so from now when you pick up on all the subtle details of my posts.

Oh, and Snake?
"Since metal came to be, most people have a: never understood it and b: derided it. And we LIKE it that way. It's music for outsiders, and the more people that hate it the better"

Keep dreaming that you're outside the mainstream and that it's 1985, no one is shocked by metal anymore. Your outsider status is self-declared and nonexistant. I saw a kid today with a spiked collar and a Cannibal Corpse t-shirt get on a bus and sit next to an old lady. No one cares, losers.

Posted by: MK at February 14, 2008 4:08 AM

If no one cares about metal, then how come you feel the need to write that no one cares and defend your opinion?

Posted by: Dave at February 22, 2008 10:50 AM

If no one cares about metal, then how come you feel the need to write that no one cares and defend your opinion?

Posted by: Dave at February 22, 2008 10:50 AM

Because I like to make fun of metalheads too stupid to only post their comments once?

Posted by: MK at February 24, 2008 4:04 PM

If no one cares about metal is there another kind of music to care about? There is metal and the rest is gay bullshit ! I'll stick to metal !

Posted by: Jaxx at March 12, 2008 2:44 AM

The comments on this post provide the lulz.

"death/black metal is sped-up punk rock and not Metal. Motorhead is Metal."

Posted by: Meh at April 28, 2008 5:56 PM

haha i like the haunted and dizzee rascal.. thats why my life is better than all of yours. just look at all of your condescending matter-of-fact bullshite, cant you see you're all the same??

this is why i hate blogs. why dont you fuck off and write a book if you care so much? its music (barely)!! pretty outspoken on the internet eh, where people will never see you or meet you? you muust be like that aaaall the time..

ARRGH!

Posted by: lhsdkfjhsdblfwe at June 26, 2008 2:53 PM

haha i like the haunted and dizzee rascal.. thats why my life is better than all of yours. just look at all of your condescending matter-of-fact bullshite, cant you see you're all the same??

this is why i hate blogs. why dont you fuck off and write a book if you care so much? its music (barely)!! pretty outspoken on the internet eh, where people will never see you or meet you? you muust be like that aaaall the time..

ARRGH!

Posted by: lhsdkfjhsdblfwe at June 26, 2008 2:53 PM

u guys took things way too seriously..haha

Posted by: michael at July 29, 2008 2:01 PM

WOW, so much angst, it would seem the tubes, blogging and metal are all serios buisiness. Say what you want about metal, music, the 80's, 90's, 00's, you're f**king poodle, whatever. Saviours 'Into Abaddon' is a good record, they're a good band a a nice bunch of dudes.

Posted by: jchi at August 13, 2008 2:28 PM

post a comment

All reader comments are subject to our Terms of Use. By clicking "Post", you acknowledge that you have reviewed and agree to these Terms.




Remember Me?
(you may use HTML tags for style)
 

Most Popular